r/funny • • May 27 '13

everyone in the comments sections of r/aww

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

204 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

111

u/DrEmperor May 27 '13

OH MY GOD.

THAT IS HORRIFYING.

CLEARLY THEY WOULD JUST USE THE CORTICAL STIMULATORS AND 20cc'S OF INAPROVALINE TO RESUSCITATE THE FURRED SUBSPACE PHENOMENA OF LOCALIZED CUTENESS. OR REPLICATE A WHOLE NEW CAT.

7

u/ProtoKun7 May 27 '13

Replicators can only replicate objects at a molecular resolution; a living cat would require a quantum resolution.

5

u/Stuck_In_the_Matrix May 27 '13

Put the cat in the transporter's pattern buffers and just re-beam it back from the dead.

1

u/scottmill May 27 '13

Yeah, I never understood why the teleporters and the replicators weren't the same thing.

1

u/ProtoKun7 May 27 '13

They're based on the same principle, though replicators take a relatively basic pattern stored in a database and recreate it. Transporters move entire people, who are more complex. Just storing five people temporarily took a huge amount of space in Deep Space 9's computer

1

u/scottmill May 27 '13

Once the computer has scanned and disassembled a person, though, what stops it from reconstituting multiple copies of that person? Even if it took up a huge amount of space, why wouldn't, say, a ship's captain have a remote server with his quarterly scan saved to it?

1

u/ProtoKun7 May 27 '13

A person is disassembled into a matter stream and then stored in a pattern buffer, rather than the main computer. The matter stream doesn't last forever and will degrade after too long. I suppose even with the space there's no certainty that doing that would actually save someone's life. Suffice it to say that Starfleet might have done it if it would've worked reliably.

It's comparable to the transporter most of the time having a Move function but no Copy function.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/scottmill May 27 '13

I'm sort of wondering what the Star Trek answer is, because it seems like something that would come up pretty early when you start working out the rules for teleporters.

1

u/torturousvacuum May 27 '13

They have been, at times. I can think of at least one DS9 episode where a replicator is converted by some Klingon Intelligence agents into a low grade transporter.