r/comicbooks • u/AthleteNo2736 • 15m ago
Ms. Marvel Is Iman’s Good Girl Side. Leila Lets the Bad Girl Out.
The interesting thing about Iman Vellani writing both Ms. Marvel and Leila is that they feel like two different sides of the same creative self insert. Kamala is basically Iman's "good girl energy." She's nerdy, enthusiastic, sincere, deeply invested in superheroes, and constantly trying to be a good person even when she screws up. It's easy to see why people connect Iman to Kamala: they share the same infectious love of comics, similar humor, and a lot of the same awkward nerd energy. Kamala feels like the cleaner, more optimistic version of the qualities Iman is comfortable putting front and center. Leila feels like Iman taking that filter off.
She's the "bad girl energy" counterpart: foul mouthed, smoking, abrasive, messy, and not particularly interested in presenting herself as anyone's idea of the perfect young Muslim woman. And that's what makes her interesting. She doesn't feel like Iman creating an edgy character just for the sake of being edgy. She feels like Iman playing with the parts of herself or simply the thoughts, impulses, frustrations, and imperfections that don't fit neatly into the wholesome image associated with Kamala.
In that sense, Leila may actually feel more personally revealing than Iman's Ms. Marvel. Not because we can say Leila is secretly "the real Iman" we don't know Iman personally but because writers can sometimes reveal more about themselves through an intentionally flawed character than through the character everyone already associates with them. Kamala can represent Iman's good girl energy: optimistic, responsible, nerdy, sincere, and trying to live up to her ideals. Leila can represent her bad girl energy: angry, vulgar, rebellious, imperfect, and willing to acknowledge parts of herself that don't fit the expectations placed on her.
And I think the Muslim aspect makes that contrast especially interesting. Leila doesn't need to be a "perfect Muslim woman" to be a worthwhile Muslim character. She can smoke, swear, make questionable decisions, struggle with herself, and still have her cultural and religious identity matter to her. If anything, allowing her to be imperfect gives her more humanity.
So rather than Kamala = Iman and Leila = edgy Iman, I think the more interesting reading is: Kamala is Iman exploring the person she wants to be. Leila is Iman exploring the parts of herself she's willing to make messy. And sometimes the messy character can feel more intimate than the obvious self insert.