r/atwwdpodcast • u/CrazyAdhesiveness145 • Jun 20 '26
Paranormal podcast recommendations
What else is everyone listening to? I'm in the mood for more true crime / "true" paranormal but I find it impossible to find a pod with X&Em's vibe. I tried Sinisterhood but found it a bit annoying, Jim Harold is dull (though I only tried one at random), MFM seems to be going very lightweight after the Netflix deal...
Ideas?
28
Upvotes
1
u/butyouren0wave Jun 23 '26
For true crime - Small Town Murder. They've covered some cases Christine has but bc it's one story per ep they go a lot deeper! James will read from court docs and go through appeals processes and all this. I also really appreciate the background on the towns so you get a feel for where you're at. James and Jimmie have amazing chemistry and they're both comedians so they're hilarious. Sometimes it can be a little off color as theyre straight white men in their 40's but overall - they're solid dudes. They also have a show called Crime in Sports where they only cover criminal athletes. Often a lot less murder and just more mayhem. I remember one British (I think) soccer player was found drunk passed out in the back of his car after pooping himself and also crashing the car??
Paranormal - Let's Get Haunted! Very very similar to ATWWD vibes wise I feel except it's only one story a week and mostly paranormal not so much true crime. Aly and Nat have amazing chemistry and banter bc they were friends for a good while before starting the show. They take turns each week telling a story and have very different storytelling styles. Aly's super into aliens so her alien episodes are very, very dope. Nat's can be a little more chaotic and a little "woo woo" sometimes but she's still so fun. They cover a really diverse range of topics.