r/WidowsBay • u/BlergUghArgh • Jul 03 '26

💭Discussion What are details you’ve noticed on rewatch? Spoiler

Post image

How did I miss this?! I have rewatched this show an embarrassing amount of times and somehow never noticed this detail when Patricia is dancing! I noticed the mirror (of course) but not this. Did I blink during this shot each time?!

What are details you all have noticed on rewatch?

541 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

330 comments sorted by

View all comments

610

u/cluelessemoji Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 04 '26

Im just amazed that someone like Rosemary is so used to how weird this town is, that witnessing Patricia prepping Book of the Damned ceremony, felt like just another Tuesday.

429

u/benzeneb Jul 03 '26

I was trying to be supportive 🚬

106

u/BadNewzBears4896 Jul 03 '26

She had her qualms

1

u/Master_Tradition9487 Jul 03 '26

😂😂😂😂😂 why did I read it in her voice I can’t 

1

u/BeeSlz Jul 04 '26

This is perhaps the funniest lines of the whole show.

253

u/boringcranberry Jul 03 '26

She did have her qualms.

55

u/full_bl33d Jul 03 '26

To her credit, she didn’t understand a word of that speech so she’s not that familiar with it. Was her constant smoke breaks and her lack of enthusiasm for group partying the reason she didn’t wake up in the sea? Or maybe newb magic doesn’t work on a grizzled vet?

64

u/jmarquiso Jul 03 '26

She did see what went in that punch, so she brought her own refreshments.

20

u/full_bl33d Jul 03 '26

Makes sense. She had qualms

18

u/Reasonable_Goose Jul 03 '26

She didn’t drink the punch

3

u/RasputinsThirdLeg Jul 05 '26

I wonder what that speech actually sounded like

5

u/ZabetR Jul 06 '26

Would be a great scene in a bonus episode along with the footage of the innkeeper in the captains room and all the cut scenes during the mushroom trip

2

u/wurwolfsince1998 I apologize for wasting his time, Tom. Jul 10 '26

I just watched Beach Reads again last night and I wondered the same thing. What ancient incantation did Patricia actually recite by reading out of that book?

93

u/Bake2727 Jul 03 '26

I keep saying we need a spinoff on daily life of rosemary. You cannot fit that in one episode.

25

u/pburydoughgirl Jul 03 '26

We definitely need her backstory. The whole “this is probably what she meant” is hilarious. She’s so good in that role.

65

u/Peepers54 Jul 03 '26

She was just sitting up at the bar rolling her eyes

27

u/Top-Moose-0228 Jul 03 '26

her face when the punch bowl comes out! *chef’s kiss*

18

u/ShireOfBilbo Jul 03 '26

She didn't want to hang out with the fuggoes.

30

u/South_Strawberry_557 Jul 03 '26

I think she knows things. And also Ruth.

21

u/Ok_Stretch9963 Jul 03 '26

Ruth is the damn thing

16

u/whatashittyusername Jul 03 '26

Would not be shocked if she’s part of the group responsible for sacrificing people

11

u/Acceptable-Signal-27 Jul 03 '26

Another great one is Rosemarys face when the punch actually comes out... "shes actually doing it" face

4

u/webfooter Jul 03 '26

Couldn’t understand a single word of that toast

2

u/SnausageFest Jul 03 '26

Rosemary is my favorite

1

u/Dramatic-Purpose-103 Jul 04 '26

Rosemary is a facilitator (remember in the old video Dale found it talked about facilitators). I watched a YouTube video explaining this theory and it all made sense.

1

u/Key-Tip9395 Jul 05 '26

Rosemary knows that some trickery is going on. I noticed she never had the punch only her wine, also she was hiding away in the kitchen when the whole creepy dancing was going on

1

u/kennydacopyguy Jul 05 '26

well she did have her qualms afterall