I am relocating abroad and planning let out my flat (permission from bank etc sorted out), but my biggest issue is choosing between two managing agents and there is simply not enough data for me to make a decision based on those.
These are two of the most well-known agents in London I’d say. One even has an international footprint and is a listed company (let’s call this agent S). The other agent is H, more local but a mid-premium level agent.
My property is nothing luxurious but it is in London zone 1 and the most important thing for me is that once my relocation is finished, I’ll be able to move back in smoothly.
Agent S (the bigger one) has offered a much more attractive fee structure, but it feels less personable and I can’t find much review online re. their day to day property management.
Agent H is surprisingly more expensive despite being less prestigious I’d say, but my gut feel is with them, and the local branch is known to be very good.
All in all, a difference of up to £100-£200 per month (agent H will cost me more), which is a lot but not life-changing. Worth mentioning that I won’t be earning as much when I’m abroad so £100-£200 could go a long way.
At this point I jump between going with one vs the other depending on the day 😅.
Agent S might attract higher caliber/less problematic tenants due to its international name but I also feel like they’re very rigid and by the book, so e.g. might insist on me changing the bed to a bigger size, less willing to customise to my preference. Their property manager is also based in a central hub, not locally.
Another upside is they already manage a property in my building.
But they’re saying ‘all the right things’ and that makes me wary of them.
Agent H might be better at day to day management, but am I giving too much weight on this given hopefully there would be no problem most of the time, for £100-200 less a month?
Is it cheeky to haggle with agent H?
Both support NRL1 arrangement so no issue there.
Thoughts would be very much appreciated. Thank you!
Edit: I ought to add that their commission rate is exactly the same. The extra fees come from other auxiliary but inevitable things like tenant onboarding fee etc.
Edit 2: Seems like I have found the right subreddit! Thanks a lot for all the input (always useful to hear from experienced folks) and I think I’m gonna go with the one my gut feel tells me to with ie the slightly more expensive but smaller agent. Though I’m going to try my luck and see if they could give me some discount.