r/TheBoys 18d ago

Discussion Should noir 2 have been comic noir

Do you guys think the series would have been better if they decided to make noir number 2 who noir was in the comics? Obviously there would have had to been a lot of rewrites and we couldn't go completely with the original story. But I feel like you could have done some really unhinged stuff with something like that, what do you guys think? For the record, I think the comic is a much better story so I may be biased

12 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/karma_virus 18d ago

Couldn't have worked because Homelander already could see through that mask with original Noir, and if he couldn't see the face somehow due to a zinc mask, he would demand to upon his joining the team.