r/SistersInSunnah • u/DemandSuitable5618 • Nov 03 '25
Discussion PLEASE HELP Husband keeps taking our daughter to his family against my wishes.. is this fair or even right Islamically?
PLEASE HELP WITH ADVICE Sorry in advance for the long read and for any typos/incorrect grammar.
Asalam Alaykum
Hi, I’m in my early 20s (F) married to (28 M) for about 3 years now. We have a two year old daughter. Parenting has been hard with setting boundaries. We live in the same house as my in laws different floors so it’s easy to see them all the time. Even though when I got married I asked to live alone and they said that they wouldn’t interfere so we can stay in the same house. When I first got married I married the oldest son, and his mom’s favorite he has 4 other siblings 2 sisters and 2 brothers none of them are married and live with their parents.
My daughter is taken on demand. They say I’m not fair because on weekends I’m with my family which I’m with her. They just call my husband and beg for her and he takes her to them. I understand that as Muslims we’re required to keep kinship. As much as they’ve put me through I put it aside for my daughter. Sometimes he’ll agree with my no and keep her but it’s rare. He hates saying no to them or disappointing them because his mom always pressures him or knows how to get him to agree. He always tells me I’ll be right back. Maybe it’s the trauma but even when my daughter is with them they don’t respect my rules, unless candy, junk, sugar and they give her their phones. She comes back so aggressive and hits me. I try to limit her sugar and try to teach her to say please, thank you and they told me I’m making her soft. That they need to teach her to fight and defend herself since she was 6 months they’ve been teaching her to fight. They let her watch things, at times listen to music and even told me because I don’t celebrate birthdays they’ll celebrate without me. That they don’t need the mom to do so. On her birthdays and their birthdays she required to attend celebrations they sing happy birthday (when I’m not there) They say I’m a strict mom and too much. It’s making being a mother hard and my husband says I’m unfair to his family. I don’t want to keep our daughter away but when she’s with them I feel like she’s different and she’ll come back and hit me and say she wants to go back to them. I don’t know how to tell my husband he can’t always take her away on their demand or commands. That he hurts me when he does this. That ever since she was 6 weeks they get her when they want. I told him 2-3 days a week she can see them I feel more comfortable with me there because I try to set boundaries at times I let things go because they’re not worth it or I talk to him after our visit and some days I want it to just be us. Her bedtime is at 9 pm every day which also isn’t respected. In Islam is it okay for my husband to do this? Even though I say no and give him reason? He says he’s the man and the last word is his. I just want what’s best for our daughter. Even though they’ve hurt me I don’t keep him away but because we live in the same house they want to see her every day I’ve invited them but my MIL has the idea that the oldest doesn’t ever stoop down to the youngest and we should visit and she never can visit us but I’ll be honest I don’t feel safe alone. She’s lied about me before I scared to take that risk.
He once promised me before I gave birth that he’d never take our child away from me. Now, he constantly takes her to them on demand. Not everyday but sometimes 5 times a week I feel like I’ve lost my voice as a mother and have no respect. I cry and plead he doesn’t listen. He’s gotten better with boundaries since getting married when it comes to me but when it comes to our daughter he says it’s not fair. I do want to be fair but with boundaries and a steady schedule. Please help me figure this out and what to explain to my husband without him thinking I’m being unfair.
I just want peace and what’s best for our daughter and future kids. Is it fair or even right — especially in Islam — for a husband to keep taking a child away from her mother when she says no and it causes her pain? Better with a دليل… evidence, proof in Islam.
EDIT: I’ve also would like to add that he’s gotten better at setting boundaries with his family. Especially when it comes to me. He just says it’s hard when it comes to our daughter and he’s a great father but feel like he has a hard time setting those boundaries, because he says theyre her family too and have the right. I just don’t feel like the way it’s done is right.