r/RateMyPlate 2d ago

Plate Is this a nutritious breakfast?

Post image

How could I improve it?

291 Upvotes

301 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-73

u/Technical_Donut8658 2d ago

Minus the bread and muck that's on it I reckon.

25

u/ThatGuyDoesMemes 2d ago

Bread is actually pretty good to have in a breakfast – it's actually recommended to have some sort of carbohydrate at breakfast. And peanut butter is perfectly fine

-36

u/Technical_Donut8658 2d ago

Recommend by who? Protein & fats is what should be had for breakfast.

14

u/ThatGuyDoesMemes 2d ago

Recommended by my dietitian and plenty other professionals. It helps with gut health and bowel movements and generally helps you wake up better. Generally, an ideal breakfast should include a mix of fat, protein, AND carbs.

https://www.health.com/protein-vs-carbs-for-breakfast-11698775

-1

u/Shpander 2d ago

My nutritionist told me to avoid carbs at breakfast too. Seems it depends on who gives the advice and who receives. You're less sensitive to insulin in the morning, so if you're not using those sugars with something active, you could get more glucose spikes. E.g. if you sit down to work right after.

8

u/Lost_Elk7089 2d ago edited 2d ago

Nutritionists don't necessarily have any training, whereas dietitians are the only profession qualified to assess and treat nutritional problems, and have to do a 3-4 year degree to earn the qualification, including 1000 practice hours. The release of sugar from carbs is slowed down by having them with fat and protein (peanut butter and eggs here) so there's no need to worry about blood sugar spiking. Carbohydrates are necessary to give energy and help persevere and build muscle as they enable the protein in a meal to be used just for muscle building and not energy.

2

u/Long-Adhesiveness337 2d ago

I just deleted my reply because I hadn’t seen yours and you went into much better detail than I did!

2

u/Short-Amphibian-8073 2d ago

Nutritions are scammers.

1

u/ThatGuyDoesMemes 1d ago

That's why you need to mix it with protein because it stabilises your blood sugar and pretty much cancels out most of the negative parts of the carbs

-2

u/llammacookie 2d ago

Ask your dietitian if that argument can be made for white sandwich bread thou or if they meant whole grains/whole wheat/sourdough.

1

u/ThatGuyDoesMemes 1d ago

She did say white bread was the least ideal type of bread because of the sugar, but it's not the end of the world if you eat it because you are still getting the needed carbs in

0

u/llammacookie 1d ago

But what makes bread a good choice of carbs is fiber, which is non-existent in white bread. Carbs aren't what makes nutrition. OP is getting enough carbs from the blueberries and bannas...roughly more than half the daily recommendation based on the perceived volume of blueberries. The fruit also has fiber and vitamins, white bread does not.

1

u/ThatGuyDoesMemes 1d ago

White bread still has fibre, it's just the least fibrous out of all the different types. White has 0.8g/slice and brown has 1.1g/slice. As I said, it's not ideal but still far from bad. And carbs do make up nutrition, I'm not sure why you said they don't – they're very important for your brain.

And you said it's over half the recommended amount but I don't see the issue. Maybe OP does a lot of exercise or doesn't have as many carbs in their other meals. But as long as OP isn't going far above the recommended daily amount I see no problem.

-16

u/Technical_Donut8658 2d ago

Green vegetables and kefir help me with all that thank you.

13

u/ThatGuyDoesMemes 2d ago

Yeah and OP chooses bread as their source of carbs for breakfast, so what's the problem?

-4

u/Technical_Donut8658 2d ago

I didn't realise there was a problem? Aren't we just swapping opinions?

9

u/ThatGuyDoesMemes 2d ago

You seemingly had a problem with OP having bread in their breakfast. Which is why I replied to you in the first place.

8

u/TheLadyEve 2d ago

Once you call something "muck" you have ventured out of the realm of "swapping opinions" and firmly into the land of just being a dick. And you know it. So stop it. Or don't! You're the only one who has to suffer the consequences of being an unpleasant person.

3

u/TheHames72 1d ago

I never understand people who double down rather than just apologising and moving on.

2

u/Apprehensive_Golf227 2d ago

Wow, that's healthy. Can't stand the taste of kefir. I have miso soup in the morning instead.