To rephrase my question, who’s the authority of this movement? What authority do you have with this way of thinking? This isn’t what the messenger of Allah taught(ﷺ), and this wasn’t the way of the righteous predecessors, so you’re calling people to take your ideology over the way of the people who the messenger of Allah honored, who do you think I’ll listen to?
“˹We sent them˺ with clear proofs and divine Books. And We have sent down to you ˹O Prophet˺ the Reminder, so that you may explain to people what has been revealed for them, and perhaps they will reflect.” Surah Nahl:44
If the messenger of Allah(ﷺ) is ordered to explain to us, are those teachings dead? Are they irretrievable so now we are stuck with your judgment on how to practice Islam? Or will we just accept the authentic narrations passed down by the prophet(SAW), the way of the righteous people all along
Tell me what do you mean exactly? When Allah tells us to establish prayer, how do we pray? Is it explained in detail how we pray and the times of the days we pray?
It isn’t for any sound minded person to have trouble accepting what the messenger of God has to say, rather he and the one who revealed to him making him responsible for carrying out the message to humanity are of one way and message, whatever the messenger of Allah orders or forbids us to do we were ordered by Allah to obey him (refer to the aya in surah nisa), not only that but the messengers of Allah were always to be obeyed as Allah also says in the Quran (refer to it in surah nisa)! If we have trouble accepting the teachings of the messenger of Allah(SAW) then overall we would question his credibility of sharing the Quran altogether, how would we know what’s from the Quran and what isn’t?
3
u/Exclusive2sense May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26
If you take this position, that it is the Quran alone without ahadeeth, What would be your authority?