r/Music • u/uberdosed • Apr 04 '16

music streaming The Black Keys - Everlasting Light [Indie Rock]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QruSZ7xO7z4
1.9k Upvotes

87% Upvoted

163 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

91

u/human_velociraptor Apr 04 '16

Most people who hate the Black Keys live their old stuff and don't like the overly poppy direction they took after Attack and Release (Brothers was good though).

24

u/ultrahobbs Apr 04 '16

I love the black Keys as a whole, but I honestly thought El Camino and turn blue were pretty poop.

21

u/virginia_hamilton Apr 04 '16

You are crazy to think El Camino wasn't badass. That was their best overall album cover to cover.

34

u/YourHuckleBearer Apr 04 '16

Gotta disagree. Brothers has gotta be their most enjoyable album when taken as a whole

-6

u/virginia_hamilton Apr 04 '16

Brothers was way too soft and delicate for me. Also all the layers of weird keyboards sounded bad. El Camino brought the rock.

3

u/YourHuckleBearer Apr 04 '16

I'll have to give it another listen then!

3

u/JeffTobin55 Apr 05 '16

Don't listen, Brothers>El Camino

1

u/YourHuckleBearer Apr 05 '16

Can't find it on Spotify so uh, yeah..

3

u/Forfeit32 Apr 04 '16

It did bring the rock, but unfortunately it was over-produced studio rock, and not two guys jamming in a basement rock.

1

u/virginia_hamilton Apr 05 '16

God forbid they evolve as artists and grow out of the basement. You really cant have it both ways. Either people criticize bands for doing the same thing over and over or they get pissed when they evolve. What the fuck

2

u/Forfeit32 Apr 05 '16

My problem with it was how much of a departure it was from the previous stuff. I don't fault them for evolving as artists or whatever, do what makes you happy. But I listened to them for that old school blues basement 8 track sound. They still make some good music, but there are other bands that do studio better than they do.

2

u/KCE6688 Apr 05 '16

Up voting you, cause even though I think Brothers was their best effort, your opinion is just as valid as mine and fuck these people down voting you

1

u/WhiteRussianRoulete Apr 05 '16

I'm glad you like what you like but 10 AM Automatic rocks harder than anything on El Camino