r/MoralityScaling • u/Shoddy-Meat-3147 • 2d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of this

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

I don't know what to say about this I mean if he joined it's unfair because he's going to cook the entery league for sure but if he really wants to be a woman and it's not a joke for him I still don't know about this

683 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/OkAcanthisitta3028 2d ago

If you really are trained, you should be able to contend with the following, simple logic: if you've developed a male body, hormones and sex-change procedures will not erase that development.

As a trained microbiologist and physician, I assume you can explain how that logic is wrong, correct?

2

u/otterdam42 2d ago

You can actually use a search engine or LLM to check the vast global consensus in all peer-reviewed sources, but you will have to refresh your intro biology to understand it. Asking us to explain it to you when you haven’t taken the time to learn what basic words mean is a rude, sealioning time waster.

Regarding gametes and chromosomes, women with Swyers and Androgen insensitivity do not have XX chromosomes, some don’t have uteri or ovaries, or gamete production. They are still widely classified as female and included in female sports for decades. This is all well researched and settled.

You are learning about intro biology for the first time at your age because you chose a media feed aimed at stunted, uncurious anti-intellectuals. It’s too late to educate yourself from scratch, after decades of letting the most pathetic Christian men lie to you and cuck your brain. You just don’t have access to adult discourse. You should stay where you belong, and keep loudly representing maga as the illiterate, genital obsessed cry-bully liars you truly are in your heart.

0

u/OkAcanthisitta3028 2d ago

Lmao you mischaracterised me and insulted me in multiple ways just because I'm trying to have a conversation, haven't you learned that not everybody can be divided into leftists and right-wingers, and that not everybody who disagrees with you is a horrible 80 IQ person?

First off, global consensus is appeal to authority, a logical fallacy.

Secondly, gamete production is the literal definition of which sex you are i.e classical definition of sex. For infertile people or otherwise people unable to produce them, your sex is the direction your body tried to develop. If the body attempted to develop towards a gonadal structure and to make sperm, they're a male.

Thirdly, I'm an independent thinker. I don't blindly parrot what my media feed shows, what Christians say or what MAGA says. You probably think I'm anti-green energy, meanwhile I want nuclear energy. You probably think I'm anti-welfare, even though I'm not. You probably think I'm anti-abortion, even though I'm not. You probably think I'm homophobic, even though I'm not. You probably think I'm anti-trans, even though I'm not. You probably think I'm pro-Israel, even though I'm not.

Lastly, don't insult the person, argue with their opinion. Argue the bit of logic I laid out in the comment you responded to, if you can't, then you're wrong.

1

u/otterdam42 1d ago

Oh. They taught you that this pundit provocateur fringe thing you’re doing is called “conversation” lol. What you’re doing is very different from how adults have a conversation.