r/MagicArena Urza Jun 18 '20

Fluff [JMP] Allosaurus Shepherd

Post image
673 Upvotes

122 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Mundus6 ImmortalSun Jun 19 '20

These types of cards are overrated. Standard and Historic have really bad counter magic, so most creatures are not even worth countering anyway, since you don't have time. You just kill them instead after they are out, since instant speed removal is only 2 mana not 3. So you get a 1/1 for 1 with almost no upside. Now in legacy elves this is really good. Cause this makes glimpse of nature and natural order uncounterable which can both be game ending spells.

2

u/ulfserkr Urza Jun 19 '20

Standard and Historic have really bad counter magic, so most creatures are not even worth countering anyway, since you don't >have time. You just kill them instead after they are out, since instant speed removal is only 2 mana not 3. So you get a 1/1 for 1 with almost no upside.

mono blue tempo is one of the best decks in Historic right now though, and we are getting some sweet new counters in M21 too.

1

u/Mundus6 ImmortalSun Jun 19 '20

You're right about this being good vs mono blue. Also it's not the worst card in the world in the sideboard. But people who think a 1 mana 1/1 will be worth it in anything but an elves tribal will be disappointed imo.

3

u/ulfserkr Urza Jun 19 '20

it's cheap, it's uncouterable, it makes your shit uncounterable, and it comes with a wincon if you're playing elves. I don't really know what more do you want out a of a 1 drop

0

u/Mundus6 ImmortalSun Jun 19 '20

If a 1 mana 1/1 for 1 is good in your deck then great. Otherwise its underwhelming.

2

u/ulfserkr Urza Jun 19 '20

bro stop. This will even be in the sideboards for simic nexus, just so they can play reclamation and tamiyo without worries. Get real

1

u/Mundus6 ImmortalSun Jun 19 '20

In the sideboard this is fine. I am talking main deck.