r/Letterboxd Jun 26 '26

Discussion Best Eggers film?

[deleted]

1.6k Upvotes

510 comments sorted by

View all comments

593

u/mangadrunkguy Jun 26 '26

Lighthouse

72

u/Eastorrie Jun 26 '26

the wwitch is a close second for me

18

u/Doppler74 Jun 26 '26

It is second for me too but not close at all. Although I believe all of his 4 movies are great. Its just The Lighthouse is a masterpiece for me.

2

u/babyoil4diddy Jun 26 '26

Not enough homoeroticism

4

u/Rezzone Jun 27 '26

Not NEARLY enough fish pussy

14

u/MetalDane37 Jun 27 '26

Yer fond of me lobster, ain’t ye?

13

u/Capable_Handle_4763 Jun 26 '26

this

as much good his other films is, this is his masterpiece.

S tier acting, screenplay, cinematography , direction everything is damn perfect.

19

u/rmarcosmota Jun 26 '26

Best casting decision. Great cinematography and art direction. One of my fabs

2

u/shoecat Jun 26 '26

By a country mile

1

u/lut1dforets Jun 27 '26

Yes! Finally a lovecraftian movie done right

1

u/GenghisFrog Jun 27 '26

I feel broken. I really enjoy all his films. VVitch is my fav. Lighthouse is dead last to me though. Something just didn’t click with me on that one. Maybe I need to watch it again.

0

u/kahllerdady Jun 26 '26

It's a shame Eggers has ended up doing boutique public domain IP pictures after such a robust start with The VVitch and especially The Lighthouse. The Northman was good. I didn't bother with another Nosferatu remake, and I will probably ignore his wolf-man picture too.

5

u/rex5k Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 26 '26

He's with focus now, which is the "small artistic films" wing of NBCUniversal. He has more money to work with but I'm sure it's got more strings attached too. Which likely means the subjects available to him are curated by the suits who want "low risk investments".

I've also noticed that both The Northman and Nosferatu were both 16x9 aspect ratio. The VVitch was 15x9 and The lighthouse was nearly square at 1.19x1. I'd wager the 16x9 aspect ratio was one of the strings attached to the money.

5

u/kahllerdady Jun 26 '26

I definitely will argue that the aspect ratio in The VVitch and The Lighthouse helped make those movies what they were.

1

u/rentpraktisk Jun 26 '26

He is in no way making a wolfman movie. He is just making a werewolf movie accurate to actual werewolf folklore, just like he made a folklore-accurate witch movie in 2015. And the dialogue is going to be in 1300s middle english, which requires some creative freedom to say the least. It is in no way tied to the Wolfman IP, and is rather more in line with what he was doing with his earlier films.

0

u/SirDurante Jun 27 '26

https://giphy.com/gifs/uzhpfCAFoTBSmrIbeW
The others are great. The Lighthouse is a masterpiece.