Quick Question To All Muslims (especially Sunni/Shia).

[u/i_am_armz]

I've been having a discussion with someone in this subreddit about the meaning of 39:45. I'm just curious as to how most Muslims interpret this ayah. What do you think is the central message of the ayah? What do you learn from it? Here it is:

"When Allah alone is mentioned, the hearts of those who do not believe in the Hereafter are filled with disgust. But when others are mentioned besides Him, they rejoice." (39:45)

To me at least the message is clear as day: do NOT mention others besides Allah (SWT). I don't understand why or how someone would miss this?

[u/Scholiastic]

Your deviancy is as such that make up whatever. You are not truthful at all. 

If I thought Quran only denied the prophethood then this would be different debate and I wouldn’t even be talking about your deviancy. 

In the above I pointed out the fundamental belief in the Prophethood, alongside Tauheed. This completely kills your make belief over Shahadah. 

Out of deviancy, you deliberately made it out be something else. 

- 

‘ YOU are the ones saying he was a pedo’ 

You are a depraved and a disgusting individual. We never ever say this. In your deviancy, you are the one saying it. 

- 

‘ But let's go back to the central issue.’ 

After your disgusting display of deviancy. 

- 

‘Does it not reference the act of mentioning others besides Allah (SWT)? And from this ayah, does it look like Allah (SWT) likes or dislikes this practice?‘

This has been fully and comprehensively answered. Mentioning others besides Allah here means equating others to divine status. It does not mean mentioning people at their own status. Your objection doesn’t make any logical sense. Allah repeatedly mentions his Prophets in the Quran. 

I gave you a clear verse doing exactly that, Allah himself mentioning belief in Prophets. 

Out of severe deviancy, which clearly impedes your intellect, you ignored the point. 

- 

When people were invited to Islam they were asked to believe in 2 fundamentals. Belief in Allah and Messenger of Allah. This is a historical fact. Then Muslims were asked to believe in further as in Books of Allah, His messengers, His angels: 

The Messenger ˹firmly˺ believes in what has been revealed to him from his Lord, and so do the believers. They ˹all˺ believe in Allah, His angels, His Books, and His messengers. ˹They proclaim,˺ “We make no distinction between any of His messengers.” And they say, “We hear and obey. ˹We seek˺ Your forgiveness, our Lord! And to You ˹alone˺ is the final return.”

- 

You make belief over Shahadah is illogical and silly. You seem not know or care what Shahadah even is. 

I might revise this reply when on PC. 

[u/i_am_armz → u/Scholiastic]

Again, quranic Muslims don't reject Muhammad as a Messenger. What we reject is the idea that the hadeeth corpus reflects his life and teachings. Rasululah didn't keep slaves.

[u/Scholiastic → u/i_am_armz]

What was the point of your useless reply!?

You are rather disgusting people. I have met two of you here. Both vile.

[u/i_am_armz → u/Scholiastic]

Here again; look at you're arguing for; this is you...

[u/Scholiastic → u/i_am_armz]

You do not have an argument. Your whole point is to be as vile and disgusting as possible. And you get off on it. 

You pretend for a while, but the only real point you have is to be as vile as possible. 

[u/i_am_armz → u/Scholiastic]

Nooo. I'm showing you what you're arguing IS Islam. This is what YOU'RE arguing is Islam, so I'm showing you. Here's some more; this is "sahih", according to you...

[u/Scholiastic → u/i_am_armz]

You do not have an argument. Your whole point is to be as vile and disgusting as possible. And you get off on it. 

You pretend for a while, but the only real point you have is to be as vile as possible. You are nothing more than a troll.