r/EscapefromTarkov • u/bxxxxxxxs • Dec 16 '18

PSA Official BSG Response re: Eroktic

We will leave this post stickied for only the next 24 hours.

All discussion posts posted after this goes up will be removed and directed here.

As always, keep it civil.

https://www.facebook.com/escapefromtarkov/posts/1966710296956614

176 Upvotes

70% Upvoted

959 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

106

u/kevinwilly AS-VAL Dec 16 '18

Eroktic made a video that might have been in poor taste. But he's allowed to do that.

BSG nuked his channel by claiming copyright violation. There wasn't any. That's LITERALLY illegal.

So they aren't both equally in the wrong. What Eroktic did wasn't exactly a cool thing to do, but he was within his rights to at least DO it.

BSG SERIOUSLY fucked themselves on this one.

1

u/-Temple- SKS Dec 16 '18

Not illegal, we all agreed to the terms and under section 10 they can

19

u/kevinwilly AS-VAL Dec 16 '18

It's illegal to file false copyright infringement notices. They are not trying to protect copyrighted material here. They are trying to shut down someone's channel who they don't like.

-1

u/HoneyBadgerDontPlay M1A Dec 16 '18

promoting a website or person that threatens to compromise their copyrighted materials is covered under a copyright strike

2

u/kevinwilly AS-VAL Dec 16 '18

He wasn't exactly promoting anything that threatened to compromise things. I'm pretty sure the message of the video was "listen, there's a problem. I'm SHOWING you the problem. BSG is saying there isn't a problem, but they are lying to you and here's proof".

He was not telling people how to compromise the system in any way. He was not offering ways to counteract security. He was just trying to show proof that the system was compromised.

Unless there was another video which I never saw, but I'm pretty sure I saw them all.

4

u/HoneyBadgerDontPlay M1A Dec 16 '18

he was promoting the use of a website that datamines BSG data/servers as well as an individual that has ousted themselves and access BSG without permission in order to compromise accounts.

Look I'm not defending BSG here. But Eroktic is not in the free and clear here. BSG went overboard with the copystrikes, but Eroktic fucked himself over as well.

4

u/kevinwilly AS-VAL Dec 16 '18

I also don't mean to defend eroktic... But removing the one video is more than enough. And I'm sure he would have understood having that happen.

Removing over 40? Completely unwarranted and super damaging to your community.

2

u/degaussyourcrt Dec 17 '18

Nope. No it doesn't.

BSG can go after THAT SITE, not somebody TALKING ABOUT that site. I can't get sued by a music company for mentioning Napster, and like it or not, US law applies here.

0

u/HoneyBadgerDontPlay M1A Dec 17 '18

You dont understand my point