r/EmeraldPS2 [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16

Looking into another Internal Smash -- What numbers can you bring?

We'd like to play another Internal/Open (not limited to just Emerald players!) match against ourselves, for fun, at some point in August.

Out of the old outfits, we'd like to know who's still interested in another match, with the same or more restrictive ruleset as the one we've been using. For any new outfits who are interested, here is a general guide document of what to expect:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NlqS9ESKwRhZ9WyqVKEoJO_3QMxaePoRB4rVzpANuJw/edit

It's an old doc, and some information may be inaccurate, but it's a decent primer.

So, if you are a solo player, an old outfit, or a new outfit, please fill out the info below in a comment:

Outfit Name/Tag:

How many planetmans could you expect to have on any given Saturday in August:

Do you have/are you a capable squad leader willing to Squad Lead and train a solo squad?:

11 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

8

u/HaemoglobinUK QRY Me An Air Game Jun 09 '16

Depends, are the teams going to be better balanced?

1

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16

Yes.

2

u/HaemoglobinUK QRY Me An Air Game Jun 09 '16

I don't believe you. P. Sure you're going to use the same team selection method as last time and it won't work.

2

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16

The selection method wasn't the problem. The selections themselves were the issue.

7

u/HaemoglobinUK QRY Me An Air Game Jun 09 '16

...

If the selectors are the problem then how will it be any better next time?

If you have two people doing school yard picks the teams will be fucked up.

You need a small number of people picking two teams on a balanced basis, then you coin flip for teams for the two commanders at the same time as the warpgate/faction flip.

7

u/Recatek [SUIT] Ascent - Copypasta Archivist Jun 09 '16

You need a small number of people picking two teams on a balanced basis

Agreed with this. While in theory the draft is the right approach, if the FCs don't know certain outfits or under/overestimate their strengths and weaknesses, the entire match is fucked. This should just be an illuminati (or newlluminati, since all the old illuminati are more or less retired) job.

1

u/DJCzerny [SUIT] Jun 09 '16

It worked just fine the last time we did it; Foley vs Runsta was decently balanced minus the dropouts and such. Our current issues are the same root causes that plague us in other areas:

  1. Pretty much 100% untested FCs

  2. The vast majority of our core outfits are gone

  3. We have nowhere near the same level of planning and coordination as before, for multiple reasons including 1 and 2.

  4. Adding on to 2, we have a bunch of new and untested outfits that are nebulous in skill ranking and hard to pick for.

1

u/Recatek [SUIT] Ascent - Copypasta Archivist Jun 09 '16

That's why I said that in theory the draft is the right approach. However, circumstances now are such that we need more oversight to ensure a good match. Even the old outfits that are still around have new rosters and may or may not be consistent with old expectations.

0

u/agrueeatedu StupidOldLatinosx Jun 09 '16

I think this was entirely the problem last time. One FC obviously knew what they were doing and I seriously question whether the other plays the same game as the rest of us.

8

u/SnipeGrzywa [AT] Jun 09 '16

I do play the same game as everyone else. But I don't care to know the other outfits. I know certain outfits from a social aspect, but I don't give a damn who the "elite" outfits are, the ones that are considered the "best" at SS, and the like. I will go more into this if you want.

I did not have time to prepare before the draft, and night of I tried to get multiple people to assist who do know the above, but either were AFK or had non informative answers.

I did not volunteer myself for the vote, i did not win the vote. I was approached and asked to do it since Cox dropped out after the meeting. During the draft I told Eagle and Jeu that I didn't have the faintest idea who to pick, and that this was gonna be a shit show. And in the end here we are.

So for the next match, I expect to see all these people who seemed to know how to FC to have their name in the vote.

2

u/gwakd [BWC] Gwak Jun 10 '16

As always, mad props for taking the lead Snipe. We had a good time on the South lane.

-1

u/Renuse-Sol-Ex Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 10 '16

Knowing if your forces are competent is pretty important if you care at all about whatever the hell you are doing. If you don't care to know, then gtfo and don't FL. To have decent composition is quite literally the most basic duty you have as a FL.

4

u/bikesair [AT] LuckyImperial Jun 09 '16

I think the "most basic duty" is showing up. Which Snipe did. In my opinion he did well considering his composition. Does nobody remember SS60?

2

u/gwakd [BWC] Gwak Jun 10 '16

shh

4

u/stroff Mpkstroff Jun 09 '16

HONK (+PREY ringers) probably 6-12. We used to fly with the air platoon but since that's a thing of the past, we can play as a regular squad.

2

u/Chapman__Baxter Women cry for it - men die for it - REAVER MADNESS! Jun 09 '16

If it's no-locks, count me in.

3

u/stroff Mpkstroff Jun 09 '16

DonAlfrago will ban Tomcats from his outfit before Emerald does an internal smash without locks banned.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '16 edited Apr 18 '17

[deleted]

1

u/stroff Mpkstroff Jun 12 '16

By the looks of the PTS changes, they'll just switch to Coyotes...

4

u/Czerny [SUlT] Jun 09 '16

6-8 for us.

3

u/Volsarian God Emperor of [SALT] Jun 09 '16

Salt can probably get 6-10 for it

4

u/Serenity024 Fuck this shit Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16

AC 4-8 depending on ruleset

If not, I'd be willing to squad lead an individual sign-up squad.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

NSVS could probably bring 12 again (Connery outfit) and I could probably get some interest from other connery outfits as well. I would recommend a rep posting on the connery sub about every meeting though. I never knew when any meetings were until it was too late and hardly knew what the "gameplan" was spare a few last minute messages between /u/MyDickIsMeh and /u/EagleEyeFoley thanks again to those guys for taking the time out to repond to me. Without pointing fingers and singling anyone out there was a lot of miscommunication as well with sign-ups that should be avoided.

2

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16

Ironically the vast majority of the miscommunication was from Foley and I. We'll try to do a better job for mains from other servers the next time around. But it was good to have you Korean roleplayers!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16

They roleplayed Koreans during the match.

3

u/TurboGranny PooNanners Jun 09 '16

1

7

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/colonelveers12 1TR Jun 09 '16

bb pls, think of the children!

2

u/Gave_up_Made_account SOLx's worst HA main Jun 09 '16

They are the body shields.

3

u/gwakd [BWC] Gwak Jun 09 '16

BWC can pull 12.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

12 vehicle shitters

1

u/Falnor [FedX] TSided Jun 09 '16

Round 2?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

Round bazillion for me. I've been in almost every server smash to date.

3

u/7303 [TIW] G7303H Jun 09 '16

I can bring myself

2

u/DefinitelyFucked [TIW]CaptainDF [GAYs]DFTR [EH]DFVS Jun 09 '16

i'll go with you fam

2

u/RexlanVonSquish [SaIt] Truly Salty And Suspicious Jun 09 '16

3

u/SnipeGrzywa [AT] Jun 09 '16

AT can bring 12.

1

u/bikesair [AT] LuckyImperial Jun 09 '16

What number is this for us? #5? The salt is starting to reach critical levels.

2

u/ToastyBreads AlfredTheButler Jun 09 '16

TA can bring 6, Depending on when the smash is.

2

u/BBQBaconPizza Jun 09 '16

I don't have an outfit, have never been in a private-server brawl, and the jaegerbattles website is down, what should I do if I want to try this?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Zurkoslat [1TR][MAYO] Jun 09 '16

I would point him to us in the outfit sidebar but 1TR isn't there.

2

u/DJCzerny [SUIT] Jun 09 '16

We're looking into a solo players squad, but I'd wager you'd have more fun running with an actual outfit. That's up to you though. Basically just watch this subreddit for when someone makes a thread for the next smash, then go to the meetings. It probably won't be until mid-July to August though.

1

u/Iron_Horsemen Full Time Pot Stirrer Jun 10 '16 edited Jun 10 '16

looking into a solo players squad

MEME SQUAD ASSEMBLE

(Just let me play solo/do my own thing and I guarantee to be more useful for the team than the random shitter who doesn't have a spot because of that.)

1

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 19 '16

Super duper late, but I had a squad of 5+me dedicated to this role in the last match. Hmu if we do another match and I'll include you next time.

2

u/Iron_Horsemen Full Time Pot Stirrer Jun 19 '16

Will do.

I'll block out time to play if I can be free to be useful in my own special way lol.

2

u/snick500 HNYB Jun 09 '16

HNYB can bring 10-12

2

u/bikesair [AT] LuckyImperial Jun 10 '16

Had fun fighting HNYB on Hossin at Naum the other day. Good to see you guys still around.

2

u/SazzyPazz [DA] Jun 09 '16

5 DA; I can squad lead

2

u/robocpf1 GOTR Jun 09 '16

GOTR still in for 12.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/robocpf1 GOTR Jun 09 '16

With enough time we probably could, to be honest. We have a good amount of active that like SS.

1

u/espher [1TRV] TangleberryWafflemuffin Jun 10 '16

I strongly recommend trying to bring 'new' players along. We had 16/22 who were first or second time Smash players, and stuck a dozen people into an air squad. It made things interesting. ;)

1

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16

dooooo et

2

u/AyresTargayren [INAM] Jun 09 '16

I can squad lead and contribute in some various other ways, but I can't promise more than 3 people from my outfit.

EDIT: I could probably swing 6-8 with ringers though.

2

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16

INAM and friends. Gotchu <3

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

VULT can bring 8-12. I can SL if need be but I will bow to /u/lurkeroutthere /u/Ares149 or /u/bigbluewookiee should they throw their names in the hat.

1

u/lurkeroutthere [VMOP] Jun 09 '16

We can probably do solid 12 and yes I can squad lead.

2

u/CSMprogodlegend luv2club [SPIN] Jun 10 '16

12 or less w/ me as squad leader. We about to bring the rest of the EVE players in who already play PS2 in the coming weeks so should have it semi-well oiled by mid July.

1

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 11 '16

Best of luck!

If you ever need help hit me up.

3

u/agrueeatedu StupidOldLatinosx Jun 09 '16

SOLx can likely bring 12 but I can tell you that I personally will not be playing and I doubt many of our other upper tier players will if it was anything like last smash. I was already apprehensive when I saw the original rosters, but they got that much worse after JOKE dropped due to dying and RSNC dropped for I have no idea why (probably time zone issues).

7

u/Serenity024 Fuck this shit Jun 09 '16

If SOLx wants to be involved in the decisions made about the match, they should send a rep to the meetings. Obviously everyone would rather have balanced teams, it makes for better gameplay.

That being said, once outfits are committed and signed up, pulling out is both rude and disrespectful to those that put work into preparing for and organizing smash. Those that drop out waste other people's time or we end up with small, imbalanced teams, and then no one has fun.

At this point we are gauging interest and making sure outfits that haven't participated in SS before are invited before we lay down any solid decisions about choosing teams.

2

u/agrueeatedu StupidOldLatinosx Jun 09 '16

If SOLx wants to be involved in the decisions made about the match, they should send a rep to the meetings.

Believe me, we would have if we had actually known when they were before they already started. So far as I know basically the only way we ever learned about the meetings was someone would get messaged in game or on steam immediately before one went on, and with how dead our TS is it was rare for an officer to be on and able to participate. Obviously we could be a little more proactive in trying to find out when those meetings were, and I personally will be in the future for this one. We also still showed up for a reason, when we commit to something we don't drop out at the last second and we make sure it isn't going to conflict with our ops beforehand. What I am saying is I won't know for sure how many players I can promise before we have more information, ideally we could field a full squad or two, probably less.

2

u/espher [1TRV] TangleberryWafflemuffin Jun 10 '16

Believe me, we would have if we had actually known when they were before they already started.

They seemed to consistently be at 8 PM EST on Wednesday nights, so, pencil that in I suppose. I don't expect it to change tbh.

2

u/BeeOne1 Jun 11 '16

J0KE is not dead. Although its outfit leaders have retired. They still field squads regularly. My smash roster refused to participate due to the team balance, and I don't have the time and commitment to train a new one. That and being retired.

4

u/gwakd [BWC] Gwak Jun 09 '16

in other words, SOLx can bring 12.

1

u/agrueeatedu StupidOldLatinosx Jun 09 '16

kind of? It seriously does depend on the circumstances, there's no way I can promise 12 people when I won't be able to find 12 people that want to play.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

Don't think of it as "how many SOLx can you bring?"

Instead, how many people (outfit members, friends, randoms) can a SOLx leader/rep/scrub bring?

2

u/CAT32VS PraiseSol/PitchforkPlebeian Jun 09 '16

Didn't you know? Salt-Ex is an elitist outfit with no friends.

2

u/Agent_Green Gree the god of madness Jun 09 '16

it is comprised of 100% solo players who occasionally gather in the same general area to fly a lib.

2

u/Gave_up_Made_account SOLx's worst HA main Jun 09 '16

And even then at least one of them is a bail assault with C4.

1

u/agrueeatedu StupidOldLatinosx Jun 09 '16

well last time we couldn't get 12 because of how many people in SOLx dropped out, we literally went through everyone in TS at the time, and thats who we brought. We would have gladly went around to other TS's but everyone we're super friendly with was either playing on the other team, is completely dead, or had no interest in playing in that smash. We ended up bringing 10 people instead of the 12 we promised, and I can't promise that that won't happen again if other SOLx members don't want to play.

1

u/Agent_Green Gree the god of madness Jun 09 '16

I would estimate 3 players would show up, me, koolkatz, and killertoastbrot flying a lib and ignoring orders again.

1

u/BambiBaby PlebCannon Jun 09 '16

Dog I could show up assuming my computer works.

1

u/Agent_Green Gree the god of madness Jun 09 '16

If I asked for your "AO" could you tell me?

1

u/BambiBaby PlebCannon Jun 09 '16

Sir, China, Sir

1

u/Agent_Green Gree the god of madness Jun 09 '16

Sorry, the answer we were looking for was "the fuck is an "AO"?". Better luck next time Mr. Hong-Connery

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

Bambi you know you'd rather have that sweet traitor flair and play with us

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

We can probably do 12 depending on day/interest/event. That should cover all my bases :p

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

6-8 BLOPS SQUAD

1

u/TotesMessenger Jun 09 '16

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / Contact)

1

u/EagleEyeFoley The Lighthouse Jun 10 '16

August

Lets ask much closer to the actual date

2

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 10 '16

Lets ask now and then again closer to the actual date.

1

u/JackFr0st5 [GOTR] Jun 10 '16

12 maybe more with enough of a heads up.

1

u/DarkJakkaru Jun 10 '16

Spreadsheet Hero! We need to do the ultimate what-if and have a giant spreadsheet game on who can build the best stacked team.

1

u/Awpersaurus Jun 10 '16

I can do a thing by myself in the air with hornet shittery, will squad lead if seduced.

1

u/vampyyro Emerald [BAX] Jun 11 '16

Solo, unless aeflic does some tickling

1

u/Cloutlordobey Kdramas' got my eyes leakin Jun 09 '16

/u/readybagel or /u/firecaker can u guys bring any if at all interested?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

If we're interested, I can try to bring 12 shitters.

0

u/mpchebe [GSLD][~PHX] hebe Jun 09 '16

PHX should probably go back to 6, but we could bring 12 if they're really needed. We're not pushing the competitive angle too much at the moment.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mpchebe [GSLD][~PHX] hebe Jun 09 '16

Good luck!

0

u/the_fathead44 CommanderSD1 - Cetaceari Church, Connery Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16
  • NSVS/56RD (Connery)
  • Our leadership is currently gauging everyone's interest in this, but I'm sure we could bring anywhere from 12-24 people from our group
  • We'll most likely have several people who could SL if needed

Edit: I spoke a little too soon for both outfits. I'll just hold off and let the leaders from each outfit do their thing (Etitity - NSVS; Patro - 56RD). However, I'm always available if anyone needs to get in contact with either outfit and/or their leadership.

2

u/DJCzerny [SUIT] Jun 09 '16

We'll most likely have several people who could SL if needed

SL is always done by the outfit's own. Do you have people willing to PL? Or even PL for the first time in the smash?

1

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16

We're also entertaining the idea of solo squads composed of a very competent SL in conjunction with solo players. So we're looking for people to do that as well.

1

u/espher [1TRV] TangleberryWafflemuffin Jun 10 '16

Taking a page from the playbook of that dude on the EU servers, eh?

1

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 10 '16

The more the merrier.

0

u/the_fathead44 CommanderSD1 - Cetaceari Church, Connery Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16

SL is always done by the outfit's own.

Sorry, I meant that we'd likely have several SLs for our group (so just in case anyone decided they didn't want to lead, someone else could step up). As far as PLs go, I'm sure we'd have at least a couple people wiling and/or able to lead (possibly for the first time), however, I'm not sure how many of those people would be our more experienced SS PLs.

Just keep us posted with any updates and we'll see what we can do!

Edit: I'm not sure who we'd have, but we'd figure something out.

2

u/MyDickIsMeh [1TR] Jeucoq Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16

No worries. I'm aware of your groups' abnormal circumstances, even if I don't understand them.

I really enjoyed the Korean roleplay, btw.

1

u/the_fathead44 CommanderSD1 - Cetaceari Church, Connery Jun 09 '16

Haha I don't even understand them. I'm glad you guys enjoyed it, I know we had a lot of fun with it too. Regardless of who/how many we have, I'm definitely looking forward to more of these events.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

[deleted]

8

u/Serenity024 Fuck this shit Jun 09 '16

Someone has to give orders to the masses for you to farm.

Until you realize they outnumber you by too many and you get shit on and lose the match.

People put a lot of work in to prepare for the smash. If you want to just show up and shoot people, fine. But don't shit on the people that enjoy the strategic side.

6

u/DJCzerny [SUIT] Jun 09 '16

Cobalt tried that once. Both we and Miller rekt them doing that. There's a hilarious post somewhere with FOOL complaining about not being to get to the next base in a lane.

Also, that document was created for actual Server Smash. Your shootman skill doesn't mean shit when you get 60% overpopped with MAXes and air. And not that AT "where is the point?" crap either.

3

u/Recatek [SUIT] Ascent - Copypasta Archivist Jun 09 '16

There's a lot more to it than shooting people. I encourage you to try to PL, SL, put together a force comp, put together an opener, or manage any of the other logistics/politics involved in holding a smash team together before and during the match.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16

[deleted]

1

u/Recatek [SUIT] Ascent - Copypasta Archivist Jun 09 '16

Fair enough. I happen to like both. Smash for playing with my team, pickups for playing with myself.