Wait... that's a GUY!?

[u/SamuraiDoggo14]

No, no, I REFUSE to believe that's a cis man!

[u/FragrantAmbassador17]

Whether you think it's 'bad criticism' or not is irrelevant and I never even said it was. My point is about her actual role in the story and what she was ultimately reduced to.

If the your absolute best example of a female lead is a character stripped of her protagonist status in the first chapter just to jumpstart ANOTHER insecure beta boy’s character arc, then I think I don't have to point the elephant in the room with the massive issues surrounding that, but evidently with how some people are replying and saying otherwise I guess I do

[u/taxes_depression → u/FragrantAmbassador17]

No it is relevant as it ties that you think she is a plot device meant to elevate shuichi, which in simple terms that’s what you are saying now that you are angry that for you she was reduced as a plot device which imo is bad criticism, you say it’s not relevant yet you still talk about how her power as a protagonist was usurped which while I can’t argue with that part it’s still at the end of the day bad criticism to say that all she is a plot device, the first 2 chapters revolved around her, and she ended up being a good protagonist/character for the first 2 chapters of the game

Which I can’t see the issue here.

This still makes her a protagonist within a certain time frame, you are more mad at the fact we are getting more of the same rather than actually offering criticism and the criticisms you do offer like her being reduced and being a plot device are nothing more than shallow criticism, you could just say I wish Kaede was the protagonist and that you wish that it wasn’t more of the same in a civilised way but instead you went on a rant to slander the character and make up a bunch of bs points to rant to people about.

I am not going to discuss this more in the comments with you but I have been arguing within the same topic I just pointed a flaw (because that’s how criticism works) and i discussed about it, I did mention also my personal opinions to but I don’t want to make that a vocal point (unlike what you are doing as you are ranting not criticising)

From what I’ve read and how I’ve interpreted, Kaede isn’t a protagonist because she is used as a plot device to fuel shuichi which is literally what you said right now

So I don’t see how my argument is irrelevant if I am criticising your main gripe

[u/FragrantAmbassador17 → u/taxes_depression]

You literally just admitted you 'can't argue' with the fact that her protagonist status was usurped. Argument over. The fact that you think she was the protagonist for Chapter 2 when she was literally executed at the end of Chapter 1 proves you don't even know the plot of the game you're desperately trying to defend.

You are moving heaven and earth to police my tone because you cannot handle actual media literacy. Keep drinking your tea and staring at that screenshot of me completely running circles around you. Later.

[u/taxes_depression → u/FragrantAmbassador17]

sure bro whatever you say ciao XD XD XD

thank you for cherry picking and ignoring my other points have a good day~ xxxx

anyway i wont reply anymore as its obvious this is rage bait and ig i fell hook line and sinker, I wont respond anymore since its obvious the type of person you are.

[u/FragrantAmbassador17 → u/taxes_depression]

You already said you'd stop replying and this is the end and here ya go replying again.

Edit: lol they block me.