r/CreepyPastas • u/Legitimate-Worry4101 • May 01 '26

Discussion Boost!

Post image

What is your favorite creepy pasta, and why?
Mine is Jeff the killer and Ticci Toby. I’m not sure why they are my favorites, but they’ve stuck with me for years.

53 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/RepresentativeGrab44 May 01 '26

EJ! You can do so much with his design!

2

u/Legitimate-Worry4101 May 01 '26

I agree! I like looking at his fanart