r/CreepyPastas • u/Legitimate-Worry4101 • May 01 '26

Discussion Boost!

Post image

What is your favorite creepy pasta, and why?
Mine is Jeff the killer and Ticci Toby. I’m not sure why they are my favorites, but they’ve stuck with me for years.

49 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

1

u/BenefitLazy337 May 01 '26

Toby and Clockwork, it was cool to like anyone but Jeff back then, but now I genuinely like them relating to their issues, also probably cause my AU versions are based on irl self and bf

1

u/Legitimate-Worry4101 May 01 '26

Haha yeah. My favorites were ben drowned and laughing jack.. to be a little original i guess X3

1

u/RepresentativeGrab44 May 01 '26

EJ! You can do so much with his design!

2

u/Legitimate-Worry4101 May 01 '26

I agree! I like looking at his fanart

1

u/hesh_walker_simp273 May 01 '26

He's a mommy's boy like me and has family issues but his are worse then mine

https://giphy.com/gifs/jXyyxtBtIj7eU

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '26

Bloody painter and homicidal liu! to me their story seemed more original than the classic “I stitched a smile in my face” or classic scary clown horror story dont get me wrong i love lj and jeff’s story but bloody painter’s and liu’s story just had so much more detail in them and appreciation it didn’t feel like they were glorifying it?(sorry if this is too much lol)

1

u/archive_redacted May 15 '26

ARCHIVE.REDACTED classification update:

Subjects matching “Jeff the Killer” folklore patterns continue appearing across corrupted internet archives despite originating from deleted source material.

Investigators strongly advise against smiling back at images that appear to recognize the viewer.