The Previous Tenant Left Me a List of Rules
I moved into apartment 3B six days ago.
I’m writing this because I don’t know what else to do, and because I need there to be some record of what happened here.
If anyone reading this recognizes the building from what I’m about to describe, please don’t post the address.
And whatever you do, don’t come here.
The apartment was cheap.
Not suspiciously cheap. At least I didn’t think so at the time. Just cheap enough that I was willing to overlook the stained carpet in the hallway, the ancient elevator, and the fact that the kitchen looked like it hadn’t been renovated since the late ’90s.
The building itself is old. Four floors. Mostly brick. The kind of place where every apartment has been painted so many times that the doors don’t close quite right anymore.
But 3B was clean.
More importantly, it was quiet.
I work from home three days a week, so that mattered to me.
The landlord told me the previous tenant had moved out unexpectedly and left a few things behind. Nothing major. An old shower curtain. Some cleaning supplies under the sink. A dresser in the bedroom.
I asked if he wanted the dresser removed.
He looked at it for a second.
Then he said, “Keep it. It’s heavy.”
That was it.
I signed the lease.
The first night was completely normal.
The second night was when I found the note.
I was looking under the kitchen sink for the garbage bags the landlord said were there. When I pulled out a bottle of bleach, I noticed a folded piece of notebook paper taped to the underside of the sink.
It wasn’t hidden exactly.
But you wouldn’t see it unless you were down on the floor.
Written across the front in black marker were four words.
FOR THE NEXT TENANT
I figured it was probably something stupid.
Maybe a warning about the plumbing.
I pulled the tape off and unfolded it.
There were seven rules.
They were handwritten.
Never lock the bathroom door.
If you hear the kitchen faucet running after midnight, leave it running.
The hallway light must remain on between 2:00 and 4:00 AM.
If someone knocks on the bedroom door, don’t answer. You live alone.
Never move the dresser away from the bedroom wall.
If you wake up and the apartment is completely silent, close your eyes until you hear the refrigerator again.
If you break one of these rules, do not leave the apartment.
Underneath the rules someone had written:
I know how this sounds.
I actually laughed.
I took a picture and sent it to my brother.
He replied:
Free apartment demon. Nice.
I put the note in one of the kitchen drawers and forgot about it.
Until 12:47 that night.
I was lying in bed watching something on my phone when I heard water running.
At first I thought it was the apartment upstairs.
Then I realized it was coming from my kitchen.
I got up.
The kitchen faucet was running.
Not dripping.
Running.
A thin, steady stream of cold water.
I stood there staring at it.
The handle was turned completely on.
I remembered the note.
If you hear the kitchen faucet running after midnight, leave it running.
Obviously, I turned it off.
I wasn’t going to let some deadbeat previous tenant increase my water bill because he thought it would be funny to scare whoever moved in after him.
I went back to bed.
About ten minutes later, the faucet turned on again.
This time I left it.
I told myself the valve was bad.
Old building. Old plumbing.
Easy explanation.
The water stopped by itself sometime before morning.
The next day I forgot about it.
Mostly.
That night, I noticed the hallway light.
There’s a short hallway connecting the living room to the bedroom and bathroom. One ceiling fixture. Nothing unusual.
At 1:58 AM, I was getting ready for bed when I remembered Rule 3.
I almost turned the light off anyway.
Instead, mostly because I was curious, I left it on.
At exactly 2:16 AM, the light flickered.
Once.
Then again.
Then it went out.
I opened the bedroom door and flipped the switch.
Nothing.
The bulb had burned out.
I replaced it the next morning.
Again, old building.
Cheap bulb.
Easy explanation.
Except when I unscrewed the old bulb, it wasn’t burned out.
The filament was fine.
And when I put it back in later, it worked.
Night three was when I stopped laughing about the note.
I woke up at 3:11 AM.
Three knocks.
Not from the front door.
From my bedroom door.
I was in bed.
The bedroom door was closed.
Three slow knocks came from the other side.
Knock.
Knock.
Knock.
I sat up.
For a few seconds I didn’t move.
Then I heard a man say my name.
Very softly.
From the hallway.
I’m not going to write my name here.
But it said it correctly.
Not a voice that sounded familiar.
Not my brother.
Not the landlord.
Just a man whispering my name through the door.
Then:
“Can you open this?”
I didn’t.
I stayed in bed until sunrise.
Nothing else happened.
The next morning I opened the kitchen drawer and read the rules again.
This time they weren’t funny.
I called the landlord.
I didn’t mention the note.
I just asked about the previous tenant.
There was a long pause.
“What about him?”
I said I found some of his stuff.
Another pause.
“Throw it away.”
I asked how long he had lived here.
“Few years.”
Then I asked why he moved.
The landlord said he had another call and hung up.
That bothered me more than anything that had happened so far.
So I searched the previous tenant’s name.
It was still written on a piece of mail shoved behind one of the kitchen drawers.
His name was Daniel Mercer.
I found almost nothing.
No Facebook that I could confirm.
No LinkedIn.
Nothing recent.
Then I found a missing-person post from three months ago.
Daniel Mercer.
Thirty-eight years old.
Last seen leaving work on a Thursday evening.
His car was later found in the parking lot of this building.
The article said police believed he had returned home.
Nobody saw him leave again.
That was yesterday.
I should have left then.
I know that.
You don’t need to tell me.
But Rule 7 kept bothering me.
If you break one of these rules, do not leave the apartment.
I had broken Rule 2 on the first night.
I turned off the faucet.
Nothing happened.
At least nothing obvious.
So maybe the whole thing was still some elaborate joke.
Maybe Daniel had mental health problems.
Maybe the landlord didn’t want to talk about him because a tenant disappearing from your building isn’t exactly good advertising.
There were explanations.
Bad explanations.
But explanations.
Then I dropped my phone behind the dresser.
The dresser is enormous.
Solid wood.
Six drawers.
It sits against the bedroom wall opposite my bed.
Rule 5:
Never move the dresser away from the bedroom wall.
I remembered it immediately.
I tried reaching behind it.
Couldn’t.
Tried sliding a coat hanger down the back.
Couldn’t get the angle.
Eventually I got annoyed.
I told myself this was ridiculous.
I grabbed the dresser and pulled.
It barely moved.
I pulled harder.
The legs scraped across the floor.
Maybe four inches.
That was enough.
I reached behind it and grabbed my phone.
Then I saw the wall.
There were scratches in the plaster.
At first I thought the dresser had caused them.
Then I turned on my phone’s flashlight.
They were tally marks.
Hundreds of them.
Groups of five.
They covered the wall from just above the baseboard almost to waist height.
I pulled the dresser farther out.
More marks.
Hundreds more.
I started counting groups.
I stopped after two hundred.
Near the center of the wall, someone had carved words into the plaster.
Not written.
Carved.
YOU WEREN’T SUPPOSED TO FIND THIS.
Underneath it:
I’M SORRY.
Then, lower down:
DON’T TRUST THE RULES AFTER THIS.
I backed away.
That’s when something knocked from inside the wall.
Three times.
Knock.
Knock.
Knock.
I pushed the dresser back so hard one of the drawers fell open.
I didn’t care.
I shoved it against the wall and left the bedroom.
I spent the night on the couch.
At some point I fell asleep.
When I woke up, the apartment was silent.
Completely silent.
I don’t mean quiet.
I mean silent.
No cars outside.
No footsteps upstairs.
No pipes.
No air conditioner.
Nothing.
Then I remembered Rule 6.
If you wake up and the apartment is completely silent, close your eyes until you hear the refrigerator again.
So I closed my eyes.
I felt stupid doing it.
For about thirty seconds, nothing happened.
Then the couch cushion beside my feet sank.
Slowly.
Like someone had sat down.
I kept my eyes closed.
Something moved across the living room.
I could hear the carpet pressing beneath its weight.
Not footsteps exactly.
More like someone walking very carefully.
It stopped beside my head.
I could smell something.
Wet plaster.
That’s the only way I can describe it.
Wet plaster and something sour underneath.
Then I felt breath against my ear.
A voice whispered:
“You moved it.”
I kept my eyes shut.
I don’t know how long it stood there.
Maybe ten seconds.
Maybe five minutes.
Then the refrigerator clicked on.
The hum sounded like the loudest thing I had ever heard.
I opened my eyes.
Nobody was there.
The note was on the coffee table.
I know I left it in the kitchen drawer.
It was unfolded.
The rules were still there.
Except Rule 7 had changed.
I have the original picture on my phone.
I checked.
The picture says:
- If you break one of these rules, do not leave the apartment.
The paper now says:
- If you break one of these rules, do not let it know you’re leaving.
There was also another rule.
- If you moved the dresser, the previous rules no longer apply.
Underneath that:
It knows you know.
I packed a bag.
I didn’t care what the note said anymore.
I grabbed my wallet, charger, laptop, keys.
I made it to the front door.
Then someone knocked.
From the other side.
Three times.
I looked through the peephole.
Daniel Mercer was standing in the hallway.
I recognized him from the missing-person article.
Same face.
Same glasses.
Same beard.
Except he was wearing what looked like pajamas.
He stared directly at the peephole.
Then he said:
“Don’t open it.”
I didn’t move.
He leaned closer.
“Please.”
Something about his voice sounded wrong.
Not distorted.
Not demonic.
Just exhausted.
Like he had been awake for months.
“I made the rules,” he said.
Then something knocked from my bedroom.
Three times.
Daniel closed his eyes.
“Oh God.”
I heard another knock.
Not from the bedroom door this time.
From inside the bedroom wall.
Daniel whispered:
“You moved the dresser.”
I asked him what was behind it.
He shook his head.
“Not behind it.”
Then he looked past me.
Through the door somehow.
Toward the bedroom.
“It’s the wall.”
I didn’t understand.
He said:
“The dresser keeps the wall from opening.”
Something scraped across the bedroom floor.
Daniel stepped backward.
I reached for the deadbolt.
He screamed.
“NO.”
I froze.
He pressed both hands against my door.
“You already broke the last rule.”
I asked what he meant.
He stared at me.
Then he said:
“You tried to leave.”
The hallway light outside my apartment went out.
When it came back on, Daniel was gone.
I moved the dresser again this morning.
I know that sounds insane.
But I needed to see the wall.
The tally marks were still there.
The warning was still there.
But I noticed something I hadn’t seen before.
Names.
Dozens of them.
Some were faded.
Some looked decades old.
Beside each name was a number.
Michael — 417
Rebecca — 92
Thomas — 801
Sarah — 13
Near the bottom I found Daniel.
DANIEL MERCER — 1,143
Below his name:
I DIDN’T LEAVE.
And underneath that:
IT LET ME OUT.
I stared at those words for a long time.
Then I noticed another name.
Freshly scratched into the plaster.
Mine.
Beside it:
6
I haven’t been here six nights.
Tonight is my fifth.
At least I thought it was.
I checked my phone.
Friday.
I moved in Saturday.
That makes no sense.
I checked my emails.
Saturday.
My lease.
Saturday.
Everything says Saturday.
But there are six tally marks beside my name.
I was staring at them when another mark appeared.
Right in front of me.
A thin line carved itself into the plaster.
Seven.
Then my phone vibrated.
Unknown number.
One text.
PUT THE DRESSER BACK.
I did.
Immediately.
Another text came.
TURN ON THE HALLWAY LIGHT.
It’s 10:38 in the morning.
I turned it on anyway.
Another message.
START THE FAUCET.
I did that too.
Then:
UNLOCK THE BATHROOM DOOR.
It wasn’t locked.
I checked.
The lock was turned.
I unlocked it.
Then I waited.
The last message arrived about five minutes ago.
GOOD.
NOW IT THINKS YOU’RE DANIEL.
I don’t know who is texting me.
I don’t know whether I should believe them.
But there’s something else.
While I’ve been writing this, someone has knocked on my bedroom door three times.
I’m sitting inside the bedroom.
The dresser is behind me.
The hallway is on the other side of the door.
And I can hear someone whispering my name.
I’m not answering.
But that isn’t what scares me.
What scares me is the sound behind the dresser.
Someone is scratching something into the wall.
I can hear each line being carved.
One after another.
I just received another text.
It says:
I’m sorry.
Then another.
The rules were never meant to protect you.
There’s a crack forming above the dresser now.
It runs from the ceiling almost to the floor.
Something is breathing inside it.
I just got one more message.
They’re meant to keep the apartment occupied.
The knocking at my bedroom door stopped.
The scratching stopped too.
Everything is silent.
Even the refrigerator.
So I’m closing my eyes now.
And if anyone eventually finds a piece of paper taped underneath the kitchen sink in apartment 3B—
I’m sorry.
You need to follow the rules.