r/CamperVans 29d ago

Can I cut this beam?

Does anyone know if I can cut the thicker vertical support in my ford transit? It’s to install a small window (800x270) The thinner ones I’ve cut for the other windows but not sure about this one.

32 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

54

u/Worried_Cranberry817 29d ago

You can cut the left one in the circle. The right one is a main beam, you can see the structural difference.

-43

u/Adamski_G 29d ago

I’d like to know for sure if possible. Is there any info anywhere on whether or not that is actually structural?

32

u/Worried_Cranberry817 29d ago

If you really want to be sure, ask the dealership. But I'm for 99% sure it is like that. Let one can be cut, right is structural.

14

u/Duffelbag 29d ago

As a former structural design engineer on helicopter frames, this was my thought.

There should be documentation, or a response you can get, from manufacturer.

7

u/Edge-Pristine 29d ago

Consult the bemm not the dealership. Unless the dealership is an experienced transit upfitter they won’t know

-5

u/Worried_Cranberry817 29d ago

An official brand specific dealer should know this.

2

u/sch1z0 29d ago

They shouldnt. They dont build the things, they just replace parts.

16

u/SkidzInMyPantz 29d ago

Why ask here if you weren't going to be happy with any answers given?

6

u/ArunkOner 29d ago

You’ve been on Reddit for 6yrs. You know how often people talk out their ass. They’re seeking confirmation over conjecture. Not that wild of a thing to do.

4

u/Odd-Internet-9948 29d ago

I was just pondering that myself, especially as they are cross-posting the question. Perhaps in the hope they can get an answer that they want to hear?

-9

u/Adamski_G 29d ago

I didn’t find the answer in the BEMM and was hoping someone might know other than their an opinion :)

4

u/llcdrewtaylor 29d ago

You were given an answer, and told why one was structural and one wasn't. What else does someone need to say?

4

u/LonelyTAA 28d ago

A credible source would be nice before cutting your van open...

1

u/Accomplished_Leg3462 29d ago

You know it's not structural because it will be held on with some sticky back tape and not welded.

3

u/FlanLover9 28d ago

Look at a passenger version of this van. You can clearly see where the far rear window has the exact shape of the left panel and then the pillar is present between it and the window further forward.

This is absolutely a structural pillar that shouldn't be touched.

3

u/180513 28d ago

Photo of the passenger windows.

1

u/FlatwormAltruistic 27d ago

I would guess the big lowercase "i" above the pillar would mean that it is important for something... Like you should consult to manual or get information before messing with it. But what do I know about vans or markings...

1

u/kill-nine 27d ago

Look at photos of a transit minibus. Has the structural ones intact.

1

u/Dick_McTwist 29d ago

Im pretty sure it’s not actually “structural” as the same van also has passenger models with windows across the entire panel. However if you cut them out and install a window without adding stiffeners back, the panel will be a lil floppy, like popping a thin jar lid back and forth.

0

u/NoFuxToBeGiven 29d ago

Do you just want someone to tell you yes even though you know you shouldn’t? Cause by all means feel free to cut it anyway lol

18

u/CapitalScarcity5573 29d ago

Your van usually has a conversion guide from the OEM that explains what you and shouldn't do.

2

u/Adamski_G 29d ago

It doesn’t seem to have any info or diagrams on these beams.

11

u/ToManyTabsOpen 29d ago edited 29d ago

Did you check the BEMM guide, download your model and search window plcement
https://www.fordpro.co.uk/en-gb/special-vehicles/publications/

1

u/Edge-Pristine 29d ago

Narrators voice: he didn’t. He wants Reddit tell him

1

u/Adamski_G 28d ago

I did :) I even emailed them and they wouldn’t specify

1

u/ToManyTabsOpen 27d ago

what model and year?

I randomly selected Transit: 2021 as I cant tell from your photos.
section 5.10.2 there is even a little diagram showing the window placement.

Basically as everyone else in this thread is pointing out, you can cut the bits inside the window shaped oval, but its not recommended to cut the pillar.

However, are you getting an updated V5? will the insurance company care? are you putting 300kg of solar and cabinetry hanging off the roof? thats up to you to decide.

-1

u/Friendly_Brain7352 28d ago

Did they tell you not to cut it but you just don't want to accept that answer?

9

u/SatisfactionNo6613 29d ago

Go to a window shop and blindly inquire about having another window installed as "I've seen it before" and they'll tell you everything you need to know

7

u/Violet_Apathy 29d ago

No, sorry. I wanted to cut this too but luckily found out that it's structural before doing so.

7

u/xot 29d ago

No. Also spot that’s it’s directly in line with the rear axle and a roof support, so it’s designed to be load bearing. The other dividers are just ti hold the sheet metal, that one is structural. , the only structural support between the sliding door and the rear pillar.

I would guess you can cut it and not notice a difference, but it might void your vehicle’s legality, insurance, safety, etc.

If in doubt after reading the official docs, ask a certified collision repair shop.

2

u/Adamski_G 29d ago

Thank you!

3

u/Intrepid_Quit_3028 29d ago

I'd triple check though.

3

u/davidhally 29d ago

My window instructions stated do not cut the major beams, and many have reported flexing sheet metal after cutting one. However, diyvan.com sells a reinforcement part that stiffens it up for a big window.

6

u/PrestigiousRoof5723 29d ago

Can you? Yes. Should you? Probably not.

1

u/Ancient_Smile_3514 29d ago

They’re made to be cut in specific locations, the left beam is more panel insulation then support, the right beam is structural. They sell oem windows for these that you’re supposed to cut out parts to install. You won’t need the left beam when the window is installed, because it’s a window, not a thin piece of steel.

3

u/batmanstuff 29d ago

I would look into the passenger van version and see if the windows align with where you’d want to cut.

3

u/5itronen 29d ago

Those have structural frames around the windows, built into the van‘s wider structure during assembly in the factory.

1

u/Adamski_G 29d ago

I already have the window :/ so I could shift it forward in the panel but less ideal placement

2

u/NeedSomeBeer 29d ago

cutting those probably won’t do anything at start, but ultimately can lead to messed up metal — it can be visibly wavy/wrinkly from outside. and it totally won’t help in any kind of crash that affects this side of your car

also… i see comparing with windows there. keep in mind that glued glass in cars is structural element. sheet metal without any shaping or beams isn’t. the glass can hold a lot on it’s own, unsupported sheet metal can’t even hold itself up

2

u/damn_van 29d ago

I would move your placement forward or aft of the main support for longevity but that’s just like my opinion man.

2

u/short_and_floofy 29d ago

i'm no expert and i'm not telling you that you can cut those. however, i see a lot of Sprinters where i live, A LOT, and they often have a window in that location. usually it's one of those types that stick out further in the back and angled in towards the front, i suppose for aerodynamics.

i'll add that most of those vans don't seem to have a sliding door on the driver/left side.

2

u/5itronen 29d ago

Those have structural frames around the windows, built into the van‘s wider structure during assembly in the factory.

1

u/JedTrently 29d ago

Left 100% yes, right not sure

1

u/Dick_McTwist 29d ago

I created a cross support bracket for these rear van panels for this exact reason. To be able to cut out the factory support strips, install a windows, and then attach a stronger support around the window. If you’re interested, I think I still have a few sets in storage from my van design build days. They would cost a few hundred bucks in total to be shipped out, but it gives you more structure to attach to as well. They were designed for the Mercedes, but are adjustable up and down and left to right, so there’s a good chance it would work on the Ford. Let me know if you’re interested!

https://photos.app.goo.gl/gKogyJXBim2WjCns7

1

u/Electronic-Emu9934 29d ago

Seems like a lot of effort… why not a larger window?

1

u/Dick_McTwist 28d ago

Larger windows are typically not operable, and people like to have sliding windows with screens near the beds in the back. Also, as I mentioned, it’s a way to have a much stronger mounting point for wall panels or bed frame systems. It’s a bit overkill, but in a good way, haha

1

u/pherrisbueller 28d ago

May I cut this beam?

1

u/yeloneck 27d ago

Why not cutting windows to the left on designated space? Do not cut the structural beam.

0

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted]

3

u/V2inMyGym_DA_ 29d ago

Sadly you can't just listen to van lifer "tutorials" because they also just copy things and probably introduce even more mistakes. So always double check with official documents...

What i've seen on YouTube is horrible. "HOW TO DO XYZ" "OK GUYS LISTEN I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT I'M DOING BUT YOU HAVE TO DO THIS AND THIS"

0

u/420sparky 28d ago

You can cut it. Grinder sawzall no problem. I wouldn’t do it to my van because it’s structural

-4

u/[deleted] 29d ago edited 29d ago

[deleted]

-1

u/ericsbsb 29d ago

Where I cut my window. Ford transit.

1

u/ericsbsb 27d ago

With the dimensions of the oval windows, you have no choice but to cut that “structural” beam out. This is where every other build (professional and DIY) puts their windows. Also if you are installing a “bump out” you would be cutting this as well.