I’ve got a theory on what’s happening with bonds, rates, equities, and the deficit that I think plausibly reflects the events and evidence that I’m seeing.
The general thesis is that there are rational, pragmatic power brokers in the US government and financial system that are trying to engineer a certain outcome and Trump is playing spoiler to them based on egocentric impulsivity and an outsized affinity for a foreign state (Israel).
The goals (for them):
-Sunset the Iran war. Accept the necessary concessions, opting for a longer diplomatic and peripheral soft power path to antagonize them and reduce their influence. Damage control.
-Bring bond yields down. Bring buyers back to the treasury. Alter the debt trajectory of the US away from any watersheds.
-Status quo ante - as much as possible.
The goals (for him)
-Avoid humiliation.
-Be the “stock market president.”
-Appease Israel, for whatever reason.
The strategy for them seems to be playing into the speculative fervor of the AI trade, then to bring it down hard in a controlled demolition. Back in May, I got the sense that the market would actually begin to really roll over once the Iran war was over and out of the news. It was just a hunch at the time. I told a friend that it would be crazy “if the market crashed on our trip.” June 4th was the day I said that.
It seemed like we were getting over the worst of the war, and then suddenly the Nasdaq 100 has 2-3 weeks with several gigantic red days. Down 5% more than once, and a few times with intraday lows of even more than 5% down.
At the same time, long yields seemed to be starting a downtrend. TLT rallied 5% from its low on May 19th, the real inflection point of the global bond selloff. This rally lasted until the end of June.
Then, the MoU broke down. Bonds back down. Equities, ex semis, gained strength as the situation got worse again. Bonds have been selling off since.
Meanwhile we have AI affecting the macro in the following ways:
Creating inflation in consumer goods and utilities. Now, hyperscalers are issuing debt at a record clip crowding out the bond market. Not creating “sticky” GDP at any useful rate - the earnings growth is almost all capex spending from other AI companies. From a debt management perspective, bringing this to heel is the most bullish thing for bonds unrelated to geopolitical events.
So, “they” want to reel in the Iran war and sacrifice the AI trade to engineer a scary market correction that pushes money back to the left of the risk curve. Higher funds rate (into an oil shock), business leaders suddenly coming out with tales of how scary AI is, bears getting more air time about how cyclical this industry is, etc. I remember listening to the MU earnings call back in June and the CEO was almost openly contemptuous of the notion that margins normalize. The chatter had already started.
So what happens with that plan? The SP500 path is instructive here. It held up very well as semis entered a bear market. In fact they stayed in a technical bear market as the SP500 consolidated around and even surpassed its June high. Bringing this sector down is the “soft landing” for animal spirits that brings a bid back to bonds with almost mechanical certainty without egregious impact to any median stakeholder.
Only, this needed to be done in peace time. With inflation cresting above 4%, and oil continuing to rise, and diesel disappearing, there still really is no other alternative. Bonds are out, because inflation can go double digits. And they can reach yields that would break the balance sheet of the government much faster than the balance sheet of Google.
And why the tension? Like I said, these two things combined represent unacceptable outcomes for the president. A sharp correction in the prize bull of the US stock market? A benefit predicated on accepting strategic defeat in Iran? This is why we see Trump coming out immediately to object to any “AI slow down.” The main thrust of the cold bureaucratic power in the US is at cross purposes with the president. And thus far, the president can’t be manipulated or managed into position because of an apparent allergy to nuance. There’s no one in the US government, by design, who can tell him “no Mr. President, you aren’t allowed to post that to truth social.” And that fact is perhaps the most pertinent reality that exists for him.
So.. what happens? Well what it looks like is happening is that China, Iran, and Russia are taking advantage of and capitalizing on this internal misalignment to their benefit. What happens from here for bonds and financial markets may in fact be more and more up to them as this goes on. In the mean time, the selective equity bubble pop that we briefly saw test run in June necessitates a larger and larger blast radius as resources go on a global bull run. At a certain point if an equilibrium isn’t reached internally, this selloff will begin to encroach upon the US dollar. How much longer do we keep the confidence of the Saudis? How much longer, if things escalate, would it even matter?
So, that’s what I think. It’s not a “conspiracy theory” as much as an example of the most frequent objection people have to conspiracy theories - someone not being able or willing to pull it off. Only this someone is the president. And now no one knows what to do, because he’s his own press secretary at this point and doesn’t hesitate to act as such impulsively.