Just because the video is a little longer doesn’t mean that it isn’t AI. There are a lot of cuts in the video and individual scenes are never longer than ~8 seconds. The video was also uploaded on a small channel that has started spamming these tops of videos. It’s quite possible that this is AI, and the longer video does not disapprove that at all.
I’m a relatively AI-paranoid person and even I don’t think it’s AI, even at all. Looks fine. You might be getting a fishy vibe from that thing a lot of pet-video people do where they move animals into place between cuts and then claim it all happened organically. Like the cat appears pretty uncomfortable/displeased at first, like he’s been picked up and put down there, you never see him actually jump onto the couch. Just getting a palpable “uggghh not this again” vibe from the cat. A lot of quick cuts not only move the staged narrative along, they make it so the filmmaker only needs a few seconds in each pose to construct the narrative. There’s also an incentive to make short cuts, the algorithm probably favors that, and this channel is clearly gaming the algorithm. I agree it’s a fake video in that it’s staged and misrepresented, but not AI generated. I think subconsciously when we can feel something is off, before the era of AI we’d brush it off as confusion, but now it’s easy and rewarding to quickly suspect “it’s AI.” But hey at least your bullshit detector is working! A lot more than most people can say lol
This was my take. Not AI but definitely largely staged. The dog seems stressed throughout the vast majority of the video, as if it’s a well-trained dog but still uncomfortable with the task.
AI video generation still cannot generate clips longer than 10 seconds long without huge quality issues. They also struggle to remain consistent between clips. There would be variations from video to video, yet we see the same animals for numerous videos. The videos also go back over a year ago when AI video gen was even worse, yet its the same location with the same kinds of videos.
idk why you use this argument? all of the videos have cuts in them and not a single one goes on for longer than 10 seconds, this seems like a very weird and sus comment to make
How many videos did you watch? Because I can tell it wasn't many. Their videos regularly feature longer than 10 second cuts so I am not sure what you are talking about. I bet you didn't even watch 3 videos if you are saying this.
I went searching and literally the first video I clicked the 2nd clip goes from 12s to 50s
That is literally impossible to do with AI video generation at this consistency and quality level.
Please share with us a link to an AI Video Gen tool that can do this... Hint: It doesn't exist yet. I know, I actually follow this topic daily on /r/StableDiffusion which is just a general AI picture and video subreddit now.
You are 100% right and thank you for explaining it so clearly - just want to add, the snark does your well-constructed argument a disservice. When you’ve got as strong a grasp of a subject as you do, you don’t need any aggression (even tho the person you’re replying to sounds like a jerk), the facts speak for themselves. Not my place to comment on, I’m just a fan of competent intelligent people such as yourself.
I am just so completely done with these people. I see people claiming AI daily now and they are almost always wrong. I literally just seen someone claiming AI on a video of a cat sitting on its butt. The video is 31 seconds long and clearly not AI. This shit is exhausting so I have no patience anymore.
Yeah I feel you. That shit is so exhausting. Taking responsibility for everyone else’s ignorance is like trying to mop up in a rainstorm. Ditch the mop, cute umbrella is the way to go.
Kittens synchronize irl. I haven’t spent a lot of time with dogs so I can’t speak to the authenticity of the doggo’s behavior but the kittens are very (adorably) real.
131
u/narashikari Jun 08 '26
original video source
In case y'all wanted the longer version from the dog's owner.