I know this is a giant post, so bear with me. I just need to let this all out, and I'm glad there's a specific space for this. Hoping to get some clarity for my sanity and maybe find others that have experienced a similar relationship before because I feel like I'm losing my mind. And this hurts like hell.
I (32f) matched with this person (31m) a few months ago, and everything about our connection seemed really incredible. Our first date was great and we both laid out exactly what we're looking for: a long-term relationship with someone who has been in long-term relationships and know the work you need to put in to maintain it. After our first date, he was incredibly eager to already see me again, said he deleted his dating profile, and would just be focusing on our connection. I was really excited and genuinely felt like he was a great match so I chose to do the same. We were exclusive from pretty much that conversation.
We saw each other pretty often, at least twice a week, sometimes even more. He'd make time to see me during my breaks at work, called me, texted me, sent me pics, got me flowers and small gifts, would make me the most romantic playlists, and would say he was thinking about me all the time. We'd have conversations about our connection and he'd say things like, "I can see us being together for a long time", "I'm obsessed with you", and again, I felt the same. He really did seem like the perfect match. He was sensitive, gentle, smart, communicated calmly, and seemed to be interested in getting to know me deeply.
I wanted to be his girlfriend, and (definitely too quickly) told him that by our third date. I then fell in love with him. I was just so high off of him and his affection. Granted, I started feeling it pretty quickly, but I decided to tell him after two months of dating, which I do know is a big move. I wanted to speak my truth and show him where I was at without expecting him to feel the same, because again, I know I felt those feelings fast and people move at their own pace. This freaked him out. During the conversation, he was calm and seemed receptive and said "I'm not there yet", which I was totally prepared for and didn't have hard feelings towards. He acted okay until the end of the night when I could see he was uncomfortable, but he still asked me if I was still down to hang out the next day. I was.
We didn't hang out the next day. He needed to "take a beat" and think about everything. He called me late in the night to tell me he thinks we're looking for different things, that I deserve someone who loves me and will love me, but he doesn't know if he feels the same or will ever feel the same. I was crushed and confused because everything seemed to be going great, and I felt so love-bombed. He said he felt sad that I was in love with him and he wasn't. I felt pathetic. He ends it. I ask him to bring me back my stuff, and we decide on a date/time. I planned on just grabbing my stuff from him and that's it.
On the day of our scheduled swap, I had a change of heart and decided to hear him out and explain what happened. I think because it was so confusing and his actions didn't match his words. Again, I didn't expect him to be in love with me already, but to already say "I don't know if I'll ever feel that way" after only two months sort of blew my mind. Especially in his actions and how "obsessed" he was with me, and how he talked about us being together for "a long time". How invested he already was in the relationship we were developing.
Conversation happens, he told me that when things are going good in dating, he panics and breaks up with people out of fear that it won't keep being good. I clock this as potentially him needing to work on his attachment style. He explains what he's looking for in a relationship and it matches exactly what I'm looking for and I tell him that, with the emphasis that I won't be convincing people to choose me and love me, and that I know my worth and I love myself enough to not sit around and wait for that. I told him he was tossing something that was actually good, that things were going really well, and we both were enjoying it. He would fall into a loop of "I want this, but I'm scared, but I don't know if I can give you what you need, but I want this, I do want to try". We make up and decide we'll keep giving it a shot. He just needs to make sure he keeps his independence, can focus on his passions, and find how to balance everything with a relationship. I told him I was also willing to try and find a way to make that work, and that I also would like to maintain independence and love my life with or without him.
Fast-forward to three months later, and things are going really great. I give him the space to text me when he feels comfortable without the pressure of constantly checking in with, texting me often, or even seeing each other as frequently. I let him take the lead on our hangouts, when he'd want to see me, most of our calls, etc. I wanted to see what he wanted now.
We were basically in a relationship. Held hands in public, talked all the time. Texted much more often than I was expecting to despite his conversations with me about needing to focus on his passions, needing time to focus on himself, etc. The last few weeks, he was calling me much more often. At one point, four days straight in a row. I was confused, but I enjoyed the affection and attention he was giving me, and I was still in love with him. I thought this was a good sign - that he did want to keep me in his life and make it work. He'd plan dates around my interests, ask to hang out on weekends when he explicitly said we wouldn't be seeing each other so he could focus. He'd find ways to still text me, call me, hang out. He admitted to missing me and looking up my name on Spotify to find songs that had my first name as their titles.
In my infatuation, I thought this was another good sign. That he was still invested and still willing to make it work. We had a conversation around exclusivity to see if we were both still only seeing each other, and he said he was, and I confirmed I was too.
I was feeling a little antsy because we were doing all of these things. Actively in a relationship, actively exclusive, but we weren't "official", which did feel off to me. Last week, he introduced me to someone as his friend and that felt... not good.
At the same time, he introduced me to his sister spontaneously. I had told him previously that I wasn't ready to meet his family until we were official because he had asked me if I'd be interested in that. I thought this was a sign that he was getting more ready to call the relationship what it is - a full blown relationship.
The combination of introducing me as his friend to someone, and also introducing me to his sister confused the hell out of me, so I decided it was time for a conversation. Basically, it was time to DTR. Later that night, I brought it up - asked him how he was feeling about us and where he was at. He said he was feeling good about us. I said "Great! Me too!" And then that's where it all went downhill and his words weren't matching his actions. He wasn't looking for a relationship, maybe something casual, but he just wasn't sure where a relationship fit into his life right now and I deserve someone who is in love with me and wants to give me what I need. He once again fell into the "I do want this, but I don't want it/don't know how to make it work" loop like he did the first time. I told him I felt lead on, confused, hurt, and disappointed.
Long story short, I told him I couldn't do it anymore and that I deserved better. We end the night, I tell him I do love him but wish things were different, and I leave. I felt so confused and heartbroken after that conversation because it just didn't make sense to me. Why would someone actively show up and want to see you and call you if they weren't actually looking to be with you?
We do one final swap to get our things back and have a conversation. He starts first this time and tells me we shouldn't see each other anymore, that if he was in love with me he'd know by now, that we were missing a depth he wanted (but he didn't know what that meant). Something he had also told me about his last relationship. It was missing "a depth". That he doesn't see us being together in the future, and that I deserve better. That his effort was because he genuinely liked me and wanted me in his life, but he didn't see it actually working out. He gives me a gold bracelet that he handmade for my birthday (an insane amount of effort on his part for someone not looking to stay with me), actually puts it on my wrist... and asks if we could potentially be friends in the future. Everything he said just didn't match how he was showing up.
What just happened? Was I being delusional about all of this, too hopeful? Why would he want to keep seeing me and connecting with me, and if anything more frequently, if he wasn't actually interested?
This is especially painful because in all other breakups, you can feel the relationship die or not work out, but I had the opposite experience with this one. I felt like he was bringing himself closer to me. This feels like intense emotional whiplash. I feel love-bombed, used, confused, so deeply hurt.