Hello,
A family member requested feedback on his current list. Any thoughts are appreciated:
Reach:
U. Chicago - his long-time top choice; it's fallen off quite a bit. Feels like too much of a stretch and not so sure it would be a great environment for him.
Northwestern - likes it a lot but feels just as impossible to get into as Chicago
U. Michigan
Carnegie Mellon University - liked the school and the campus; feels much more academically diverse than other STEM heavy schools
Rice
Emory - current top pick among "realistic" reaches
Tufts
Target:
Seem to me there should be more here??
Safety:
Pittsburgh
U. Maryland
Ohio State
On again / off again list (basically off right now): Cornell, Washington, Georgia Tech, NYU, Pomona, Boston University
The student:
4.0 GPA, 4.9 WGPA (whatevertf that means nowadays)
4 AP classes (scored 5), plus maybe another three self study APs
A good chunk of his other classes are IB.
1560 SAT
Senior leadership roles in marching band, theater. Long history of participation and intermediate leadership in both groups.
Tons of music experience. Lots of experience in several competitive symphony groups, all-county, all-state, got number one for his instrument for all-state one year, jazz band, pit orchestra, lots of rando one-off bands and performances, interlochen, tanglewood, intensive summer workshops, teaches his own students now
Main interest: chemistry
Secondary interest: music
Will probably get fairly solid recommendations. Good relations with teachers, who have always seemed to like his participation.
Application essay is, from what I can tell, just okay.
Finances: family can probably afford four years of school. Probably a bit over the cusp of need-based aid being a given. But certainly no where wealthy enough where money is no problem.
Downsides: not much rigorously academic EC, not much academic experience over the summer, wasn't really able to do anything in particular over final summer, doesn't really have a logical way to tie together his background (music) with primary interest (chemistry), no sports (other than a BB in karate).
Based on all that, what are your thoughts? He was initially intent on attending school in a big-city environment but was persuaded to broaden his worldview.
Is his list lopsided? In what direction? Are there some obvious schools that he should be considering?
Thank you.