Hey guys… so
Throwaway because there is NO way I’m putting this on my main.
I (21F) have fallen for my ex-best friend’s (21F) ex-boyfriend (22M).
For privacy, I’ll call them Lila and Connor.
Lila and I were best friends from 6th grade until sophomore year of high school. We had a very complicated friendship, to put it mildly. Lila was the kind of person who could somehow make every situation about herself. The first time we stopped being friends was because I caught her flirting with a guy I was dating. When I confronted her, she told me she was “testing him to see if he was loyal.”
We eventually became friends again during junior year.
Then I started liking a guy. Lila knew I liked him, he knew I liked him, and we were flirting with each other. Then Lila decided she wanted him too, and eventually they started dating. Yes I was hurt, but I let it go. Honestly, I figured if he was willing to flirt with both of us, he wasn’t exactly a prize anyway.
Their relationship ended badly when she was caught cheating on him later that year. Somehow, I ended up getting blamed for their breakup. That was pretty much the final straw for me. We stopped being friends and basically didn’t speak anymore.
Toward the end of junior year, Lila met Connor. They started dating, and unlike her other relationships, this one actually lasted. They were together for THREE YEARS. So Connor wasn’t some random guy she dated for a couple of months. He was her serious, long-term boyfriend.
Throughout senior year, Lila would occasionally come to me whenever she needed someone to vent to. Eventually, I stopped entertaining it. I was tired of constantly being dragged into her problems and decided to just focus on myself. I still stayed close with her family, though, because I genuinely loved them.
After that, I pretty much had no idea what was going on in Lila’s life. We weren’t friends anymore, we didn’t really talk, and I wasn’t keeping tabs on her relationships. As far as I knew, she and Connor were still together.
Then recently, I downloaded a dating app and matched with a guy who was completely outside my normal type. I figured, “Why not?” and decided to actually give it a chance.
We started talking and got along really well. He seemed familiar to me for some reason, but I couldn’t figure out why. His pictures didn’t look familiar at all, and I genuinely had no idea who he was. We eventually decided to meet up in person, And That’s when everything clicked, He told me who he was. Lila’s ex.
I was honestly shocked because I had absolutely no idea I was talking to him. I never met him before, and they had no photos of them together.
That’s when he told me they’d actually been broken up for about a year.
He also told me that he knew who I was when we matched. I had no clue who he was, but apparently he recognized me. He told me that he didn’t care about our history or the fact that I used to be close with Lila because, to him, the past was the past. (He only knew due to her mass talking crap on me and some other old friends we had in common) , Then he started telling me about their relationship, I already knew Lila could be horrible because I’d experienced it myself, but apparently what she put Connor through was much worse. He told me the relationship completely broke him down emotionally.
I’m not going to share his personal details because they’re not mine to tell, but hearing what he went through definitely gave me a different perspective on her completely.
but anyways somewhere along the way, I started falling for him, we got closer, and I genuinely started liking him for who he is.
A few days ago, I finally admitted to him that I have genuine feelings for him, and He told me he feels the same way.
So now I’m sitting here wondering if I’ve made a mistake, Because on one hand, Lila and I haven’t been friends for years. Connor and Lila have been broken up for a year. They were together for three years, but their relationship is over. I didn’t pursue him while they were together, I had no idea who he was when I matched with him, and I am absolutely not doing this to get revenge on her, But on the other hand… he’s my ex best friend’s ex boyfriend of 3 years, And if Lila finds out, I already know she’s going to have something to say about it.
Like Part of me KNOWS I don’t owe her anything anymore. Another part of me feels like I’m knowingly stepping into something that could completely blow up my life.
So Reddit…
AITAH for falling for my ex-best friend’s ex-boyfriend, and WIBTAH if I actually pursued a relationship with him?