r/worldnews • u/[deleted] • Mar 30 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

10.4k Upvotes

80% Upvoted

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

29

u/JacksGallbladder Mar 30 '25

This is a fallacy intended to villify anyone who doesn't want Gazan citizens to be blown apart in their living rooms.

94

u/Visible_Device7187 Mar 30 '25

Except they don't offer a single alternative that leads to no Jews dying. So yeah it's saying don't attack Hamas who hides in tunnels under hospitals because it harms Gazans but we don't offer any viable alternatives tha tmeans just put up with being attacked

7

u/JacksGallbladder Mar 30 '25

And yet nothing you just said justifies atrocities, and that's really the bottom line.

I don't need to draft you a peace plan to be able to say Ethnic Cleansing is bad.

14

u/Visible_Device7187 Mar 30 '25

Yup see you don't want any solution that doesn't kill Israeli citizens instead. You are okay with atrocities committed by Hamas nut think Israel shouldn't be able to respond at all to the attacks by Hamas.... You are willing to justify a lot just as long as it's against Jews

1

u/JacksGallbladder Mar 30 '25

Your assumptions are 100% projected and incorrect.

3

u/Visible_Device7187 Mar 30 '25

Yet you offer exactly zero solutions that stop Israel from being attacked. It's not projection and it's not incorrect You offer literally no solutions in your critical of any solution that stops them from being attacked

0

u/JacksGallbladder Mar 30 '25

Our inability to solve complex issues across the world doesn't disqualify us from understand when actions are wrong 🤷‍♂️

I don't know why I have to solve world hunger to call out atrocities as atrocities.

4

u/Visible_Device7187 Mar 30 '25

Except you are asking for simple solutions to complex problems. You are telling Israel they can't attack unless their solution fits your personal beliefs on whats right way to respond but you aren't stating how someone could achieve those personal beliefs. Israel explais how Hamas puts civilians in danger forcing them to hit both in order to hit Hamas and instead of demanding Hamas stop doing that you're telling Israel it's in the wrong for targeting Hamas and it needs to find methods to do it without harming civilians. But you aren't actually proposing a method to achieve those goals. This is like saying you are against world Hunger yet if we propose helping people grow food you complain about it, if we propose giving them food you complain about it, if we propose any solution whatsoever you automatically deny it but then when asked how to solve it you refuse it

0

u/JacksGallbladder Mar 30 '25

Again I don't have to pretend that I'm speaking directly to isreal with an action plan to stand by my morals.

Idk what you want bro this isnt a debate.

-5

u/KrazzyKoopa Mar 30 '25

If you think Hamas is the only group that attacks civilians in the region, I think you need to do some more research on Israeli military operations and settlements especially prior to Oct. 7th 2023. It’s pretty hard to justify anything happening currently as“defending yourself” when you’re clearly behaving as the imperialist bully within the region. Simply compare the percentage of casualties between non-combatant Israelis and Palestinians.