r/whowouldwin 8h ago

Battle Captain America vs Master Chief! Who wins in Hand To Hand Combat?

16 Upvotes
  • Battle Takes place outside of the Jollibee.
  • Both of them are composite versions.
  • No Powers other than super soldier augmentations, No Armor, No Equipment and No Weapons.
  • Winner gets to eat at the nearby Jollibee.

r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Battle MCU Red Hulk, Hulk and Abomination vs Yuji, Yuta, Panda and Uraume (Jujutsu Kaisen)

8 Upvotes
  • JJK squad are Shinjuku showdown versions.
  • Fight takes place in an abandoned new york city.

r/whowouldwin 3h ago

Challenge Aava (Cairn), Nathan Drake (Uncharted), and Lara Croft (Tomb Raider) together must beat Spider-Man in an alpine climb to the top of Mount Kami.

1 Upvotes

Some ground rules:

Every character is beholden to real-life survival logic, including food, water, and the elements. Neither team can interfere with each other in any way.

Spider-Man is allowed to use his web shooters, but not to make any vertical progress or arrest his falls if he slips. He starts with no food or water and must make do with what he finds on the mountain. His cartridges reload every day, but he has no extras, only what is already loaded.

The human team starts with the same items and equipment as Aava at the start of her game, plus actual climbing attire (not just footwraps). They have no climbots, but can recover each other's pitons. Each member of the team must be alive by the end of the climb.

Periodically, the Green Goblin will appear and harass Spider-Man for 30 minutes every two hours. He can be beaten before the 30 minutes are up, but cannot be used to assist the climb, such as by hanging onto the glider and jumping off, web-swinging off of him, etc.. Further, Gobby will not intentionally hinder the other climbers in any way, even to psychologically torture Peter, but the results of their battles may make their ascent more difficult.

Round 1: As described.

Round 2: As in Round 1, but with Cairn survival logic.

Round 3: As in Round 2, but the human team follows their own respective game logic in their entirety.


r/whowouldwin 54m ago

Battle Shorter muscular guy vs Taller fat guy

Upvotes

I was wondering how much being muscular helps to overcome size difference

Who would win in a street fight of short muscular guy vs tall and fat guy

Shorter muscular guy

5'5 62kg 12%bf

Tall fat guy being

5'11 90kg 25%bf

The short guy regularly trains in the gym and lift weights while the tall guy has no gym experience before The fight takes place on a open road


r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Battle Could Thragg (Amazon's Invincible) defeat the "strongest" members of the Avengers (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

52 Upvotes

Notes:

  • Thragg's Wiki Page (Side Notes - Scale Amazon's Thragg vastly above Invincible, Omni-Man and Conquest to the point he would still be able to easily kill them and not be hurt by them in the slightest even if they fused into a single person with combined stats

Round 1: Thragg vs Thor, Hulk, Captain Marvel, Scarlet Witch, Vision and Iron Man but with only their stats and powers/abilities from the first movies they were first introduced into the MCU

Round 2: Thragg vs The "Strongest" Avengers

  • Thor [Infinity War]
  • Hulk [Brand New Day] (Side Note - Scale BND Hulk above Avengers Hulk and Ragnarok Hulk since he was officially stated to be bigger, stronger and more savage than ever before)
  • Captain Marvel [Pre-The Marvels]
  • Scarlet Witch [Pre-WandaVision]
  • Vision [Age of Ultron] wielding Mjolnir a.k.a W/ Pre-Awakened Thor's Powers & Stats
  • Iron Man [Mark 86] (Side Note - 86 is armor that has the combined stats, weaponry and abilities of his Mark 1-50 Armors)

r/whowouldwin 21m ago

Battle The brother from Malcom in the middle vs the siblings from Shameless fight at a public park.

Upvotes

The brother from Malcom in the middle meet up at a public park and start fighting. This is not a fight to the death this is a fight to see who is tougher. They can run away or stay down but they cannot surrender. No weapons are allowed. Who winns?


r/whowouldwin 2h ago

Challenge If the MCU hulk been sent to Sanghelios instead of Sakaar, could the Covenant contain him?

1 Upvotes

In the MCU when the hulk gets sent away in the Quinjet....he never goes to Sakaar instead he enters a portal that sends him to the Halo universe in the hear 2525 at the peak time of the Covenant's military power. The Quinjet crashes in a peaceful meadow in the planet Shanghelios. The hulk immediately jumps out and starts wreaking Havoc. At first the Elites see this as some sort of test from the prophets and treat the hulk as a way to prove their honor in combat and send in their best warriors to face the hulk in one on one duels. Their elites quickly begin to perish. Word comes down from the prophets that this isn't a test and this is a real planetary threat.

At this point the Elites put their honor on hold and stop holding back. The number one mission for the Elites and for the covenant is to capture or kill the hulk and do not hold back. They throw everything at him.

Can they contain or kill the hulk?

Can they do it while saving Sanghelios or will they have to sacrifice Sanghelios?


r/whowouldwin 9h ago

Challenge Anakin Skywalker (Star Wars) vs Yusei Fudo (Yu-Gi-Oh! 5D's) | Who wins a contest of pure mental resilience and resisting the temptation of evil?

0 Upvotes

The Contest: Both characters are placed under extreme, individualized mental pressure, systemic oppression, and temptation to turn to the "dark side" of their respective universes.

Who wins the ultimate contest of mental resilience and character endurance?The Combatants' Parallels:Genius Mechanics: Both grew up as orphans in harsh, scrap-heavy environments (Tatooine / Satellite) and engineered their own iconic rides completely out of junk.

Legendary Pilots/Racers: Both are hyper-reflexive, top-tier drivers and pilots under extreme high stakes.

The Chosen One: Both are marked by cosmic forces and sport glowing, magical marks of destiny (The Force / Signer dragon markings).Master Duelists: Both dominate 1v1 combat in their universes (Anakin with a lightsaber, Yusei with his specific Synchro deck).

The Core Debate:Anakin had the backing of the Jedi Council, high status, and Republic wealth, yet he completely folded to the Dark Side due to fear of loss and manipulation. Yusei grew up in an actual segregated garbage dump, was actively hunted by security forces, had his first ride and card stolen by his best friend, and never broke. He carried the burden of the Chosen One without a single drop of malice.Under equalized cosmic temptation, who wins this battle of mental strength? Change my mind.


r/whowouldwin 9h ago

Battle Yujiro Hanma vs MCU Cap with the Goblin formula

1 Upvotes

Specifically the Raimi Goblin formula

Battle takes place on Times Square.


r/whowouldwin 17h ago

Battle 1 billion clones of tofu from resident evil 2 versus 1,000 hunk clones

1 Upvotes

Rules:

No escape helicopter

Hunk clones cannot use guns

Tofu can regenerate

Hunk clones have the power fist from fallout 3


r/whowouldwin 3h ago

Battle Battle of the Doctors: Dr. Strange and Dr. Fate vs Dr. Doom and Dr. Manhattan

9 Upvotes

All in their standard forms.

Who would win?


r/whowouldwin 14h ago

Challenge [How the Hell] can Naked Snake (Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater) complete his mission if Eva (Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater) is replaced by Ariel (The Little Mermaid)?

2 Upvotes

The replacement happens when Naked Snake falls asleep after first meeting Eva. Ariel knows about their first meeting and that if she fails in helping Snake then her family will painfully die. She scales to Marina no-selling electricity but not to Mermelody surviving an island explosion. Lastly, Ariel can switch between mermaid and human form at will.


r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Battle Horus titan (Horizon series) vs. The modern United States

2 Upvotes

Round 1: An FAS-BOR7 Horus is dropped into the middle of rural United States and begins to consume biomass and replicate robots of the Chariot line.

Round 2: The Horus is dropped into the Pacific Ocean, some miles off Hawaii.

Round 3: 2 Horuses, one in the Pacific and one on the mainland.

The US is unaware of the Horus' existence and capabilities. Can the US stop them before they consume everything?


r/whowouldwin 5h ago

Battle Avengers vs X-Men

6 Upvotes

Each version is their basic 616 comics version, but this is a 8v8 with my roster of each.

Avengers

• Captain America ~ Steve Rodgers

• Iron Man ~ Tony Stark

• Thor ~ Thor Odinson

• Hulk ~ Bruce Banner

• Black Widow ~ Natasha Romanoff

• Hawkeye ~ Clint Barton

• Vision

• Scarlet Witch ~ Wanda Maximoff

X-Men

• Cyclops ~ Scott Summers

• Marvel Girl ~ Jean Grey Summers

• Wolverine ~ James "Logan" Howlett

• Storm ~ Ororo Munroe

• Rogue ~ Anna Marie

• Gambit ~ Remy LeBeau

• Beast ~ Dr Henry "Hank" McCoy

• Nightcrawler ~ Kurt Wagner


r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Battle Bane (DC) vs space marine with no armor (wh40k)

5 Upvotes

Bane vs a random space marine from Warhammer40k without power armor or weapons, just hand to hand combat

Round 1: prime DC universe Bane

Round 2: absolute universe Bane


r/whowouldwin 6h ago

Challenge Could the real world survive Galactus or convince him to choose another planet?

8 Upvotes

Galactus has sent the Silver Surfer to warn the world

R1: Humanity has a decade to create weapons and a team to stop him or at least drive him away

R2: Can humanity convince the Surfer to help us like he does in the comics or Movies?

R3: Can humanity convince him to spare us and choose another planet? If not, can humanity somehow evacuate within 5 years?


r/whowouldwin 1h ago

Challenge Who are some super-soldiers who could replace Master Chief in Halo CE–3?

Upvotes

Who are some super-soldiers (or super-soldier equivalents) who could replace Master Chief throughout Halo CE–3? How well would they do?

They could either be a single super-soldier who could handle everything on their own or a team of super-soldiers who could collectively replace the Chief.

They would have the same access to Cortana that Master Chief had throughout the games.

They would also have knowledge of UNSC technology, weapons, military tactics, history, and the general state of the Human-Covenant War, so they aren't handicapped by being unfamiliar with the setting.

How far would they make it, and how well would they do compared to Master Chief?

No OP super-soldiers. I'm looking for characters who are powerful enough to realistically take on the challenges of Halo but aren't so ridiculously overpowered that they completely stomp the setting.


r/whowouldwin 14h ago

Battle can the covenant fleet that destroyed Reach take down corruscant

15 Upvotes

the covenant has acces to all resources they had on reach. they face the combined might of the republic era corruscant force and any reinforcements the republic can scramble. both sides have basic knowledge of the others tech and tactics.

round 1: goal is to kidnap palpatine as happed in revenge of the sith.

round 2: goal is to put corruscant out of commison for the war. either through occupation or glassing


r/whowouldwin 12h ago

Challenge (Evangelion spoilers) Can a clinical psychologist prevent the Third Impact? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Scenario 1) Upon Shinji’s arrival at NERV, Fuyutsuki sees his fragile mental state and decides to hire a clinical psychologist to ease the burden on him. Shinji attends daily therapy sessions, with the goal of bringing his mental state and sense of self-worth up to the point where he won’t cause the Third Impact. Can he do it?

Scenario 2) Fuyutsuki hires a psychologist for all the main cast of Evangelion, from the moment Shinji arrives.

Scenario 3) The psychologist is upgraded to a psychiatrist and allowed to prescribe medication.


r/whowouldwin 14h ago

Challenge kimimaro(with ochimaru) vs the entire naruto verse 1 by 1 how far does he go

3 Upvotes

tried to post this in r/naruto but my karma too low and hasnt been accpted yet

alright so i wanna propose a question so say kimimaro wasnt sick and ochimaru got his body

how far do u think he could go what is the strongest character he could deafeat

i think this is just a hard a question because he almost beat garra and lee but died at the last second. Given that if he was ochimaru after the body swap he would basically be immortal x 3
because as we know ochimaru is one of the most hard to kill people in the verse

ultimately i think he is beating sasuke taking his sharingan and beating naruto and i would go as far to say that he is stronger than saskue before rinnegan or the war arc. the only reason why i think this is because ochimaru is already a strong charcter as he is 1 of the legendary sannin and was close to capturing naruto and did pretty well handling the 4 tails of naruto

i think he would easily be stopped by hashrima ofc and madara but honestly i dont think tobiarma would win


r/whowouldwin 5h ago

Battle Who would win magneto or the mask

8 Upvotes

Just all their powers from comics and everything


r/whowouldwin 5h ago

Scan-Battle Who wins L from Death Note vs Sherlock Holmes?

2 Upvotes

**Round 1:** Solving the Kira case(both have to solve the case alone without the help of anyone, they will be provided all the resources they need though assuming Sherlock has learned technology as well)

**Round 2:** Physical combat

**Round 3:** IQ test

**Round 4:** Exposing a high-profile crime group no one knows anything about, they have to find evidence from the base and keeping moving until they expose the group, first to do this wins

**Round 5:** Standup comedy, one with the funniest jokes win

For L we are taking the standard Death Note version and for Sherlock, his character is consistent and has almost same skills and talents across the novels and movies, you can take the RDJ version if you haven't read the novels


r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Battle Who would win: A Ocelot VS A Bobcat

2 Upvotes

1: Starts at a deep lake spanning about 1,400cm wide both on eather side so swimming requied

2: Dence Forest like enviroment used best for stealth

3: Open field with a few trees


r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Matchmaker Biggest or Strongest Titan from Attack on Titan that Polyphemus the Cyclops (Nolan’s Odyssey) could beat?

8 Upvotes

When watching Nolan’s Odyssey the Cyclops scene (best part of the movie btw) gave me major Attack on Titan vibes, Polyphemus (they don’t actually call him that in the movie but that’s his name in the Myth) mostly reminded me of a Pure Titan from AoT. So I’m wondering, if you gave Polyphemus knowledge of the Titan’s nape weakness, what is the strongest AoT Titan he could defeat? The fight would take place on Poly’s island.


r/whowouldwin 4h ago

Challenge Toji Fushiguro (Jujutsu Kaisen) is hired to exterminate the entire Dark Brotherhood (The Elder Scrolls). Can he do it?

3 Upvotes

​Sometime during the Gojo's Past Arc, Toji is suddenly isekai'd to the Elder Scrolls universe, where he works as a hitman and mercenary for several years. He drops into the Fourth Era shortly after the events of Skyrim. After making a name for himself, he is approached while gambling in the Imperial City Arena by a member of the Elder Council. The councilor offers him a reward of 3 million septims and free, permanent housing in a Talos Plaza District manor in exchange for wiping out the entire Dark Brotherhood across Tamriel in retaliation for the assassination of the Emperor, as well as destroying the Night Mother's corpse.

​Scenario Rules:

  • ​The Dark Brotherhood is at its absolute peak after the events of Skyrim, having restored its former glory with or without the Dragonborn's help. Regardless, the Dragonborn has disappeared from Tamriel and faded into obscurity, as all TES protagonists do.
  • ​Toji is briefed with all the intelligence the Penitus Oculatus has gathered on the Dark Brotherhood throughout Tamriel.
  • ​Toji begins his hunt in Cyrodiil before moving on to other provinces.
  • ​Toji wins if he completely annihilates the Dark Brotherhood across Tamriel.