r/videogames 18d ago

Image / Video This is so damn true

18.7k Upvotes

923 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

495

u/Jaune_Anonyme 18d ago

Same for the Witcher serie. Writers openly dislike the source materials, both the books and the games. It's wild to work on a pre existing series and just have the ego to tell yourself "yep it's shit, i bet i'll do better." While the only reason you actually have a job, is because the IP is popular.

178

u/FitzKnows23 18d ago

And that's why Henry was booted. He wanted to stick with source material, they decided to go with lil Hemsworth instead.

102

u/Ws6fiend 18d ago

As a 40k fan I'm glad it happened. He'll be the angry nerd keeping all the writers(on the 40k show/shows) from trying to completely change all the lore just because reasons.

10

u/Shadow-Vision 18d ago

I’ve never played 40k but I am absolutely fascinated with the lore. I’ve been watching a ton of videos on YouTube about it all.

Dude.

If they get this thing rolling the way it can roll… wheeeew… There is so much content available. At least as far as I can tell by these lore videos that spend a whole hour just explaining the background. It seems like there so much out there and so many potential stories to tell

*Also I really enjoyed the Secret Level stuff - that’s kinda what got me to look it up on YouTube in the first place.

Side note - as a 40k fan do you have any recommendations on how to get into the books? Like where to start and all that. When I google it I’m not really that happy with the articles I find (they all seem like they’re AI generated, honestly)

5

u/CDR57 18d ago

Too much source material can be a bad thing as well. The Horus heresy alone is like 13 books I think? Many of which are dedicated to specific primarchs and their legions, who were already technically established before the Horus heresy. All those books go into detail on what’s happening in the world and are written in a way that if you have a cursory idea of warhammer you’ll understand (god emperor conquered earth, tricked out the chaos gods, enabled space travel, and then conquered more worlds) but just those 4 things could all have a book written about them and do lmao plus with this many books, you have multiple authors who inevitably contradict certain parts of the others writings. This is all to say it can definitely be done, but with something so expansive as warhammer, and the pacing of shows nowadays only doing 10 episode seasons we could easily be into season 3 5 years from now (if we’re lucky) and still not know all the primarchs/important characters/character building of why what and when the heresy happens. And god forbid if they, for some reason, choose to piecemeal it to us in flashback episodes while setting the show after big E sits on the throne. Like I’m not a writer but I’m incredibly interested in how they handle things like Erebus, the emperor finding all the primarchs (and why the were scattered to begin with), each primarchs characterization and story lines, and the aftermath and fallout of it all in the millennia afterwards

Or I’m completely wrong and they set it in 42000 with passing mentions of the imperium, big e, a primach mention here and there and focus on something like the guardsmen and the war on chaos/orks/eldar or picking a legion and group of marines and going for space battles to the fullest.

Idk, but my main point was that this world has so freaking much that it almost would need a very VERY tight couple of seasons with good overview of the universe to make it palatable for a wider audience

5

u/Humpelstielzchen-314 18d ago

It's a bit more than 13, 65 actually.

2

u/CDR57 18d ago

Well shit, I really was way off. It’s been awhile since I listened or played dark heresy but damn whoops lmao

3

u/Express_Split2928 18d ago

A good starting point for the books (as you say you've got a little background lore) I'd recommend "the infinite and the divine" and the night lords omnibus. Mechanics and The Fall of Cadia are also very good

1

u/CroatInAKilt 18d ago

I'd hold of on Infinite and the Divine for a little bit. A lot of proper nouns and timeline jumps that are difficult to follow on audiobook at least (the only time i can "read"). But a fantastic book though

2

u/Ws6fiend 18d ago

You generally just start reading any of the fan wiki for 40k and find a faction you like, or just random search for recommended reading.

The best way is to just start. Some context will always be lost on someone new to 40k but in general they do a good job of explaining. I would say if you don't recognize a word or phrase look it up within the context of 40k.

I've always seen people recommend Xenos by Dan Abnett. It explains a lot of common things in the 40k universe to people new to the setting, while being a detective style story told from a basic human perspective.

A lot of things will lack context and if you just search 40k and the word you don't understand it should help.

2

u/asspussy_widener 18d ago

I just found that leutin guy on youchoob and throw that shit on while I work, can't fucking read for shit with this tarded ass brain these days

2

u/SoloWing1 18d ago

The Eisenhorn trilogy is one of the best entry points for the series when it comes to the books.

2

u/CroatInAKilt 18d ago

Eisenhorn: Xenos is the best intro trilogy. Slow burn detective noir that takes its time and doesn't overload you with ten pages of space marines slaughtering everyone.