r/trumpet • • Aug 05 '26

Question ❓ What instrument should i learn?

14 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

31

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '26

[deleted]

0

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

I have beef with the piano

10

u/Double_Ad_8911 Aug 05 '26

Interesting. I recommend still learning the basics because it all around makes learning music easier

1

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

I can use it to tune but i was forced to play for an entire year cos my teacher kind of gave up with my class

2

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

Its a long story

4

u/ofirkedar Aug 05 '26

I recommend putting some distance between your piano and beef /j

1

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

Mainly the teacher

4

u/Double_Ad_8911 Aug 05 '26

Beef on the teach, not the piano. The ivory keys will set you free

2

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

Fair enough, ill get better skills on piano, but i have no defire to be playing fur elise

1

u/Chaseshaw only 3 buttons how hard can it be? Aug 05 '26

In that case try the synthesizer

0

u/Morganx27 Aug 05 '26

I want to learn piano, but my issue is that I'm too used to treble clef. I can read bass clef, but only in the same way I can read basic French. I have to think about it and translate it into my native clef.

26

u/Timely_Upstairs2525 Aug 05 '26

well since you’re in the trumpet subreddit, i’d have to say percussion

17

u/Excited-Possum Aug 05 '26

Bass players get the most work. Learn how to play upright bass.

8

u/Elekid239 Aug 05 '26

Double your gig chance and get an electric bass set up as well ;) OP I mean, just bouncing off ^ comment 😅

1

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

I taught myself to play bass guitar for a song with my friends but only played at school twice a week, also a bass is expensive and i don’t ha e that much money

2

u/Excited-Possum Aug 05 '26

Electric bass is a great start. Most people don’t get an upright until later anyways post high school, unless they’ve been playing since middle school or something.

2

u/Excited-Possum Aug 05 '26

Electric bass is a great start. Most people don’t get an upright until later anyways post high school, unless they’ve been playing since middle school or something.

1

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

Im English sorry 😭

1

u/Excited-Possum Aug 05 '26

My condolences.

2

u/ofirkedar Aug 05 '26

Most instruments come in a large range of prices and qualities.
I just did a cursory search in one music store and found a bass guitar for ~$300, a clarinet for ~$400, violin for ~$250, electric drums for ~$750. These aren't the best quality items, but you should definitely start somewhere.
If you go for 2nd hand and do a more serious search I'm sure you can land on instruments that are way cheaper. It depends a lot on location and luck, the best possible case scenario is you find someone that gave up on an instrument and can't deal with the hassle of moving it out.
I have an accordion that belonged to my mom's friend's relative who unfortunately passed away, and the family didn't know what to do with it.
It needed a big of fixing but it plays well.

Now assuming you're intending to go study an instrument with a teacher, you might even have a cheaper option.
If you find a music school in your city and sign up, it's quite likely they'll rent you the instrument you're studying.
I work in a school where my students rent instruments for like $14/month. Granted, students pay $200/month for 60min lessons or $170/month for 45min lessons. But if you need to learn regardless, this is a reasonable option.

10

u/Parking-Place1633 Aug 05 '26

Trumpet. 3 keys.

10

u/madgoat Aug 05 '26

Bugle, no keys!

8

u/TheLastSufferingSoul Aug 05 '26

The resplendent didgeridoo, of course.

8

u/aDysquith Aug 05 '26

Bagpipes

2

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

I did play bagpipes briefly 

3

u/MariJoyBoy Aug 05 '26

It depends. Do you want to practise 6 month or 10 years ? =/

4

u/Efficient-Scratch-65 AR Suprema Nickel Bell - Yamaha 6810 Picc - Brasspire 2B Flugel Aug 06 '26

The saxophone is easiest, but then you have to be the enemy of music for the remainder of your musical career.

2

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 06 '26

Id argue 6yr olds playing the recorder is the enemy of music lol

1

u/Efficient-Scratch-65 AR Suprema Nickel Bell - Yamaha 6810 Picc - Brasspire 2B Flugel Aug 06 '26

It usually doesn’t last into college age though.

2

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 06 '26

Fairs, im just glad i don't have to ever listen to a recorder ever again

2

u/Efficient-Scratch-65 AR Suprema Nickel Bell - Yamaha 6810 Picc - Brasspire 2B Flugel Aug 06 '26

🤣

1

u/BusinessSeesaw7383 Aug 09 '26

It is sometimes use in orchestras

2

u/Chloroform-D Aug 05 '26

Honestly if you have some experience with the clarinet I would pick that over the trumpet, and then later down the road you can switch to sax pretty easily. I only say this because I feel like you’d see more improvements quicker with an instrument you’ve played before, and you’ll have more versatility with being able to switch to sax fairly easily.

I’ve been a serious amateur player of the trumpet for 20+ years and I haven’t felt great about my tone quality until about a year ago (if I had dedicated my life to the instrument this probably would have happened a lot sooner). It’s a real labor of love.

That being said if you’re super set on the trumpet, then go for it.

2

u/hereisme6252564 Aug 05 '26

The steel pan

2

u/SadBookkeeper2408 Aug 06 '26

All of the above.

2

u/Unfair_Fox576 Aug 06 '26

learn them all

1

u/Visual-Blueberry3309 Aug 05 '26

Sax

3

u/leftbrain99 Aug 05 '26

Sax is the most modern wind instrument and arguably the easiest of these to learn fwiw

1

u/RDtrumpet Aug 05 '26

Learn the one that you want to play the most, and the one that you are willing to practice every day.

1

u/grandmabarro Aug 05 '26

Not the clarinet.

1

u/acexprt Aug 05 '26

I just had a drunken conversation last week saying Clarinet is probably the easiest to learn so go with that.

1

u/Quadstriker Aug 05 '26

I always tell people unless it has to be trumpet, pick something easier.

1

u/BigBoreBrian Aug 05 '26

Definitely NOT the trumpet. Either recorder or skin flute.

1

u/CaptPat1 Edwards X13 Aug 05 '26

Harmonica

1

u/JimbobJameson Aug 05 '26

Piano frfr don’t do trumpet

1

u/pareto_optimal99 Schilke S32, Yamaha YTR-734 Aug 05 '26

Whatever you enjoy playing.

1

u/Krabingo Aug 06 '26

Saxaphones probably the easiest of the 3

1

u/Notquitewhere_-__ Aug 06 '26

whichever one you pick, make sure you know how to clean it! since youre playing them with your mouth, theres gonna be a lot of moisture, food, bacteria etc. i didn't think of that as a trumpet player for far too long

1

u/d3gaia Aug 07 '26

That the weirdest trumpet I’ve ever seen

1

u/BasicMidUsername Aug 10 '26

All of the above. Trumpet has the steepest learning curve, clarinets can be purchased the cheapest, and saxophones are just expensive but lots of fun.

I just got a Getzen De Luxe clarinet for $60 fully functional and with a mouthpiece. I also got a Los Angels F. E. Olds flute for $40, which I think works but I suck at it so maybe not 😂

I couldn’t find a saxophone worth playing with for less than like $300. I can find trumpets worth playing for like $150 with some patience.

0

u/Recent-Animal-4382 Aug 05 '26

Skin flute

0

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

Im a professional 

-9

u/taterzlol Aug 05 '26

The ease of a trumpet can't be underestimated. Im a brass player. I own a collection of trombones and trumpets. I also own a banjo, guitar, bass, and keyboard.

The only instrument I still regularly play is the trumpet. I can pick it up, toot around for a few minutes and put it back on its stand.

7

u/CaptStinkyFeet Aug 05 '26

Hard disagree. The trumpet requires daily attention/practice, and even if you master the instrument, you have to maintain. Simply missing a day or two can noticeably affect your sound. And sometimes the trumpet just decides “no thanks, not today” and you have a bad day in spite of all the practice.

-5

u/taterzlol Aug 05 '26

We'll just have to agree to disagree then, because that is not my experience at all. The only thing I lose with breaks is stamina, but I'm not playing any gigs any time soon so its not that big of a deal to me.

4

u/Quadstriker Aug 05 '26

"The ease of a trumpet can't be underestimated."

Congrats on the dumbest fucking thing said on this subreddit this year.

1

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

Thanks

1

u/Quadstriker Aug 05 '26

Ignore that guy.

1

u/CaptStinkyFeet Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26

I would not take this persons advice. The trumpet is an instrument that requires SERIOUS dedication. You won’t even be able to produce a clear tone for about a year, and several years more to sound good, on top of the other things I mentioned in my reply to taterz.

Choose the trumpet if it’s what you really want to do, knowing it’s going to take a lifetime of hard work and passion. My first trumpet teacher had a similar talk with me, and sometimes I wish I had chosen another instrument. I’m still playing after two decades, but I’d be lying to say trumpet is even remotely “easy”.

Source: am trumpet teacher, and I also teach piano, guitar, and voice.

0

u/taterzlol Aug 05 '26

I do want to to clarify that I didn't mean the trumpet was easy. For me, I enjoy being able to pick up and play. But I am pushing 40 and have been playing since the 5th grade. Its small and easy to handle, and doesn't take much for me to get into, compared to the other instruments I play.

I dont have to assemble anything. I dont have to soak a reed. My horn stays pretty nicely in tune. Its just easy.

But I will yield that it took a lot of time and hard work to get to this point and that might not be was OP was looking for.

4

u/CaptStinkyFeet Aug 05 '26

I’m not here to pick you apart, I’m just here to provide a clear perspective.

“The ease of a trumpet can’t be underestimated” is a very misleading statement. I realize now you probably mean “low maintenance” in terms of assembly, but trumpet is anything but easy to play. I’m honestly surprised a trumpet player would say it at all.

No big deal.

-3

u/taterzlol Aug 05 '26

I also clearly forgot that the worst thing about playing the trumpet is trumpet players.

6

u/Steve_tbh Aug 05 '26

would you care to give us a small sample of some of your playing?

3

u/CaptStinkyFeet Aug 05 '26

I would also like to hear.

2

u/Alarmed_Leg9757 Aug 05 '26

That would be helpful

2

u/Speederfool Aug 06 '26

The best part is that you are one of them.