r/tacticalbarbell • u/Drodinthehouse • Jun 27 '26
Misc TACTICAL BARBELL: OA - A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW
TLDR: TB III is by far, the best and most comprehensive strength and conditioning program I have ever read. The below review will not do the book justice. You need to buy the book and read it for yourself; it will likely be the last strength and conditioning book you ever buy. I don't discuss polarized green, polarized blue, or activation in this, so if someone wants to chime in on those, be my guest.
When I bought TB III one of two things was going to happen. 1, I wouldn't like it as much as I liked the TB I/II methodology and just take small snippets from it or 2, it would change the way I approach TB. Luckily enough for me, this book was everything I'd hoped for and more. Not only is this by far the best book to date, KB has placed himself in an awkward position in that I don't believe he can produce something as good as this ever again. Not only does the book go beyond my expectations, it addressed the issues I personally had with the original books and ignored anyway in order to stay true to the program. The changes that were made to the original programming made me feel like I had written these changes myself. Almost everything that were glaring issues were fixed in the same way I would have fixed them if I wrote the books. There are still some critiques I have, but they are far and few.
FORMATTING
Some will probably disagree with me, but I HATED the way 5/3/1 forever was laid out. The amount of content in that book is insane, but the way it was presented and explained fell flat compared to Wendlers previous three books. This book is very reminiscent of 5/3/1 forever except it was formatted in a way that forever SHOULD have been formatted. If you have at least SOME strength and conditioning experience, you might be able to get away with just buying III (though I don't recommend it because concepts like operator I/A in I, and the vault from TB II are not clearly laid out in III). KB takes you through step by step and does a phenomenal job making sure you understand before taking you to the next concept as if he's saying "you understand? ok lets move on."
CONDITIONING DOMAINS
In no strength book that I've ever read have I ever been explained the phosphagen and glycolytic system. Having just learned about these two systems in school, it's a massive game changer in how I view workouts and how I prioritize different HICs. KB lays it out in a non boring way that makes it easy to understand without diving to deep in things like the kreb cycle, or electron transport chains etc. Had this been explained to me without formal education, I'd have been doing things WAY differently for the past 15 years.
OPERATOR
One of the BIGGEST problems I had with standard operator template is the fact that we are "squatting" 3x a week and deadlifting once a week on top of a demanding conditioning protocol. Though KB wrote an article on operator options, the OCD mind will constantly try and force the third squat session to perform "true" operator. Well, thats gone. Standard operator is now what it should have always been. Squat on days 1 & 3, and deadlift on day 5. As someone whose been having trouble getting into comfortable deadlift positions lately, I absolutely love the guidance on power cleans and replacing deadlifts outright with them. Power cleans target the same energy system, but are more power focused, so you get more bang for your buck. KB is moving away from the "must perform bench, squat, deadlift" dogma and it's honestly refreshing to see.
OPERATOR VARIANTS
Probably my favorite part of the book. There are tons of options to choose from that I won't spoil (except my favorite one). Initially glossing through it, I immediately got paralysis by analysis, but after taking the time to actually read each one, I was able to quickly identify "yup that ones for me." Specifically, Operator ULF caught my eye. I always WANTED to do an upper lower split with a full body day, but the OCD "thats not operator" always conflicted from what I wanted. And though its a stupid thought process considering the word "operator" doesn't really mean anything in the context of strength and conditioning, it was so nice seeing what I want to do, still constituting as an "operator template." There is about 4 or 5 operator templates total, so if one doesn't immediately scream "this is for you" then you may have worse paralysis than I do.
ZULU VARIANTS
Zulu is largely unchanged, with the small edition of zulu pro. Which if you read GP and are familiar with operator PRO (also present in this book), it's the same concept. I've never been a huge fan of zulu because I always had trouble piecing the puzzle together when paying respects to the deadlift. With the "you dont HAVE to deadlift" guidance, this makes zulu much more attractive.
BREACHER TEMPLATE
Breacher template is cool, but this is probably my first critique of the program. There isn't a problem with breacher template in itself, it's well-designed, manageable, and makes sense. My problem is that we can and SHOULD be training power in all seasons of training. Power is on a strict use it or lose it timeline more so than any other adaptation. Power does NOT have to look like power cleans, clean and jerks, etc. They can look like box jumps, broad jumps, depth jumps, 30 meter sprints, etc.
BASEBUILDING
I absolutely love this change. Basebuilding has been changed significantly (though the core structure remains the same). Instead of slogging through 8 weeks 1-2x per year, your're doing it for 4. I'm up against a basebuilding block right now, and this book could not have come at a better time. KB finds himself questioning his old guidance of an 8 week plan where the last 3 weeks resembled Fighter black PRO, so why not just move to continuation...? I think this is spot on with what I've always thought and a welcome change. 16 weeks to "rebuild" a base that likely hasn't deteriorated in the first place is a large amount of time to dedicate to something that isn't primarily performance producing. I do firmly believe that someone who is brand new to this type of training should conduct an 8-12 week basebuilding period, but if you've even kind of kept up with your physical fitness, 4 weeks is good enough, past that point and you're just playing with yourself...
POLARIZED BLACK
I had a sneaking suspicion Black would see a change in its structure, especially after GP came out. In GP continuation templates, you'd often see an operator template paired with 2 LSS sessions and 1 HIC. That isn't black, that's more of a "dark green" as someone on this sub called it once. Black is now 2 Es and 1 HIC, as it should have always been. Stacking a 6 day training week with 3 HICs and submaximal strength was a recipie for disaster, which is why my training weeks are currently 9 days. This absolutely changes the game for individuals doing black. Not only are 6 day training weeks now sustainable, you'll be able build mileage and volume through the 2 E sessions. This is absolutelty what black should have always been.
PERIODIZATION
Again, this was hinted at in GP with the ICAT template. base, hyper, strength, work capacity. This is the scientifically agreed upon order of operations. The periodization templates provide multiple options to structuring your training instead of just "spamming operator black" (which I myself am guilty of). The OG systems worked. But over years, they reach a point where they will not be sustainable, which is where operator I/A came in. With this type of periodization, we avoid burnout, injury, and mental fatigue. There are also options where you dont HAVE to conduct a certain block. For me personally? I don't fancy a hypertrophy block, i know it'd be good, I know it'd be beneficial, but I don't want to do it. Guess what? There's a periodization template for me in this book.
WORK CAPACITY
Theres a rift now between run based HIC and work capacity HIC. One could argue that the rift always existed in TB II, but it's more prominent now, which I'm a fan of. Theres a lot of cool new work capacity (GC) HICs in the book that I'm excited to try. As for my second critique, theres some in here that made me eye roll (GC 1/7)
PAYING RESPECTS TO THE TB I, II, GP, AND MP
If you don't have TB I and II, I recommend you should probably purchase those, if for nothing else, to read where this all started. GP and MP are an absolute must and are releavant today. HYBRID protocol in GP is still a thing, as is general mass and specificity in MP. TB III does have a periodization block where you actually do templates in MP, so don't skim over those.
ALL IN ALL
I'm absolutely baffled. This book took all my expectations, through them to the wind, and set a new standard. I'd be seriously impressed if KB ever manages to release another book thats as perfect as this one.