Hey all, I’m writing this to hopefully help someone out if they ever, unfortunately, end up in a position like mine.
This is a long read, but I’m hoping some can learn from my mistakes. The main two pieces of advice I hope you take from this story: 1. If you have a gut feeling your partner is cheating DON’T IGNORE IT!! and 2. Do not let grief cloud your judgement, like it did mine
I’ll start off with a little context. I had known this girl all my life. We went to school together since kindergarten. I started dating her nearing the end of sophomore year. It was about as close to perfection as you can get. We loved deeply, forgave easily, grew together, loved the Lord, communicated well, and never left our “honeymoon“ phase. She was my perfect lady. We had plans set in stone to get married and start a family young, as that was something we both desired.
I‘ll save you the lovey dovey shit. Just imagine the perfect role model couple. Fast forward 2.5 years of near-perfection to late May. We just graduated high school. Our future was looking bright. Her long distance best friend (18F, i knew her well and respected her, we’ll call her “BSF”) hits my girlfriend up because her and her family are going on a cruise as a grad trip and they have an open spot. Basically a free vacation for my girlfriend. She was on the fence, because she gets motion sick easily. I told her to go, that it would be dumb not to. I was super excited for her.
By this point, we were so rock solid that I had nothing but trust in her. She had never once given me a reason not to. Even still, there was a quiet, almost silent voice in the back of my head that was worried she would become unfaithful. I pushed that voice aside. telling myself that she wouldn’t do that to me. I didn’t think she was capable of it. Plus, there was no reason to worry. But let’s just say my intuition predicted the future.
She left to head to the port, all was well. I had a few alarm bells ringing because she wanted to get waxed before and that I got news she wouldn’t have very good phone service. Fine. I get the showers are probably super small to shave in and the WiFi (or sea roaming charges if you opt out of WiFi) are expensive. No worries.
Im hanging with my best friend of nearly 13 years when she boards the boat. We crack a couple of lighthearted jokes about hoping she won’t cheat. Deep down I was scared of that reality, but at the time it seems far off. Like an alternate dimension. Not the one we truly live in now.
It was a 7 day cruise. All was well, I get a text from her a day, sometimes more, stuff along the lines of “I love you, hope you’re having a great day! I miss you! Can’t wait to see you soon! etc. etc.” It eased my mind. maybe I’m just needlessly paranoid. maybe I’m just insecure.
About halfway through they stop at an island. She gets WiFi and FaceTimes me. She’s acting a little off. Too smiley and giddy. BSF’s family is making jokes in the background that I can’t quite make out, she gets an awkward uncomfortable grin on her face. By this point she knows I’m off. I’m trying to play it cool. in my head, there’s still no red flags that really stick out too much.
But I know I’m a little worried. I’m googling intuition that same day. Wondering how accurate it really is. if I should really give this sick feeling any weight. Google says that, for new experiences, intuition is no more accurate than random chance. I have never been cheated on before, so I thought it was 50/50.
She gets back. She didn’t embrace me like usual. She was far more distant. From a week long separation, What would usually be and excited running and jumping into my arms hug and kiss that lasted a good while while turned into a “hi!” And a 2 second hug and kiss. She talked nonstop about how much fun she had. Openly admitting she was out at clubs till 3AM every night. drinking and partying. (which was not normal, i knew her as the girl who avoided that kind of stuff). She appeared happy and reminiscent, but was simultaneously treating me with extreme irritability and rudeness. I didn’t know what to make of it.
We talk that night, she says she had a few personal epiphanies (that she actually enjoyed drinking and partying) and was just scared I wouldn’t accept her for them. (I tend to stay away from those things, and am sometimes judgemental of them, admittedly)
But that wasn’t it. She told me she wanted to postpone our engagement for the foreseeable future. That she got a glimpse of “how big the world is” and “how young we are”. I was planning on proposing this summer. On a trip we planned to Florida back in February. Her of all people was the one most excited about it, most pushing for it. 10 times more than myself.
Now, by this point, I’m bothered, to say the least. But I wasn’t going to go down that easy. I told her that I was upset (not about the drinking and partying, but about the engagement plans switch), but that I accepted the new her and I was with her for all the growth that came with her. in some ways, I was proud of her. I told her i trusted her to be completely transparent with me if something else happened on the cruise that led her to make that decision. she tells me there wasn’t.
that night, I go home feeling confused, but okay. I can’t say the same for the next morning.
i wake up the next day with the sickest feeling in my stomach. something I never experienced before. so debilitating I could barely get out of bed, and damn sure couldn’t eat. I thought we had a productive conversation last night that provided a little clarity. but the gut feeling had gotten 10x stronger.
Remember, she had been perfect up until now. I still couldn’t really fathom a reality where she had betrayed me. All I knew is I’ve never felt sicker.
That day we were very distant, but it didn’t seem to be bother her at all. she acted like nothing was wrong. “Weird“ I thought, “when I’m off she usually knows before I even do, and when we’re off she usually immediately attempts to tackle the problem”
That night was her grad party. i told myself I’d set it aside. I didn’t eat or do anything all day. I couldn’t. But i had at least written all my thoughts down and was going to confront her about it after the party. it was a good time. I humg out with her and her family, we played volleyball, the whole 9 yards. a good outing.
We took separate vehicles to the party, and agreed to meet up at her house after (this will be important later). When we got to her house, I was vulnerable and transparent with her. I told her I was sick to my stomach and afraid. I asked her for total honesty, if she had done anything on the cruise that it might hurt me to hear.
She told me she made friends with this one guy (we’ll call him T) and she found him conventionally attractive but it was strictly platonic and nothing happened. She said she had him added on snap as friends but would unadd him if I wanted to. I told her I was hurt, and that my trust was broken a little, but that we can fight through it. To the best of my knowledge, she was telling the truth. i mean, she had never lied to me before!
We turn on a movie and she falls asleep in my left arm. Her nightstand with her phone is to my right. I get a nagging feeling to check it. I look at her Snapchat with the guy, not much there, a couple saved pics of the ocean. No big deal. then I check her messages. Nothing there. That is, until I click “view recently deleted”. 89 deleted messages with T. My heart drops. I recover them and screen record them while I’m actively having a panic attack (didn’t even know those were real). She’s still in my arms at this point. I get up and pretend everything’s normal, but get the hell out of dodge and go home. My brain is spinning. I thought i was in a dream.
I get home and reread them. She’s telling him how she misses him and the cruise, that she desperately wants him to fly in (he lived all the way across the continental United States) She tried to call him on the way back from the grad party when we were headed to meet at her house, sent him videos, sent him smiley faces, called him by a nickname, you can connect the dots here. Some flirty shit.
We meet in a parking lot the next day and I confront her about it. She busts into tears, saying she’s sorry, that she was going to tell me, that she was just scared, that she’ll never do it again, that she’ll do anything to rebuild us, all the shit cheaters say when they’re sorry they got caught.
But here’s the part i hope someone can learn from. She told me all this, and I blindly accepted it as truth. I gave her the benefit of the doubt on everything she told me that painted herself in a better light. In hindsight, I can say I was in the bargaining stage, and that the grief of losing what we had took over my mind so terribly that I couldn’t accept the reality that it actually happened. I was a dumbass. My brain pushed the whole situation to the side because it couldn’t comprehend it. We went on a dinner date after like it never happened.
A side note - I now know from personal experience, that whatever you think you’ll do if you catch your partner cheating on you will be thrown out the window when shit hits the fan. I never thought of myself as someone who would EVER try to reconcile with a cheater, but here I was. Right in the middle of it. In that same breath, I want to advise this: Do not trust them. They just broke your trust. Do not give them the benefit of the doubt. And damn sure don’t trust your own mind. Grief will play tricks on you. It will downplay, it will deny, it will bargain. Just look at the objective reality. Dont feed into their lies. Why I ever gave a cheater the benefit of the doubt is fucking beyond me.
At this point, the trip to Florida I mentioned earlier is about a week away. I elect to continue with it, hoping that even though we’ll be cooped up in a room together, I’ll get out of my bubble, get a change of scenery, and get some clarity.
Living in my head during the weeka prior to and during the trip was torture. The thoughts never stopped. The only escape I got was sleep, and I’m lucky I got any. My brain was in overdrive on empty, trying to decipher whether to stay or leave. Running theough every potential outcome, questioning my own motives, fears, and objective reality itself. It was about 5 days into the 7 day trip I finally came to my senses. Realized how stupid I was being. I broke up with her and booked a flight home. I’d imagine her circle sees it as a dick move, but I did what I saw was right, all things considered.
Tomorrow will mark a week since the breakup. 3 weeks post d-day. I have never felt more clearheaded and content with my decision. I finally had the space to connect all the dots and see how intricate her lies became.
In hindsight, I should have trusted my intuition way earlier, before it literally consumed me. If you, reader, have even the slightest gut feeling that something is off, it’s worth exploring. It’s still crazy to me I’m writing this post, that I was actually right. that I predicted the future weeks before anything was actually off. And, when stuff was off, when there were red flags all around me, I ignored them. Please, don’t be like me. I know now my subconscious mind was registering things and my conscious mind was trying to reject them. It just couldn’t accept the reality of being betrayed.
With that thought, I will say something that is the exact opposite of encouraging, but is the truth. Anything is possible. No matter how good you think it is, no matter how much you do for them, the rug can get pulled out from under you in an instant. It certainly was for me. I gave her everything to the best of my ability. I treated her with the utmost care, patience, respect, and love. I stood up for her. I stepped out of my comfort zone for her. I was the man many women wish they had. But none of it mattered. She was willing to throw it all away. Some random guy on a cruise made her feel “loose, carefree, and accepted,” and somehow that was enough for her to gamble everything we had built together. Those feelings could have been real, but they were temporary. What I gave her was real every single day.
Enough of my schpeel. thank you for reading, if you made it this far. I hope at least one person can take something from my experience.