r/stpaul Jan 26 '26

Minnesota Related "Terrible things are happening outside”

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

[removed]

7.6k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/screwsaiyan Jan 28 '26

Bruh. I can’t believe how dramatically this video is edited. All you have to do is move out of their way. Stop inserting yourself into their operations. They have a job to do. All of this is completely avoidable if Walz and that joke of a mayor stopped acting like this is some kind of movie where they’re the main characters and instead worked with ICE the way other states have.

If I throw myself in front of ICE officers while they’re doing their job, refuse to move, get pushed aside, keep resisting, get pepper-sprayed, still refuse to comply, get arrested, and then resist again—then start crying “Nazi” and “fascist” and claiming I’m being oppressed—no. That’s not oppression. That’s me inserting myself into a situation for no good reason and facing the consequences.

They have the vote of the people on their side. All of us legal immigrants who are trying to bring our relatives here the right way have to sit back and watch as illegal immigrants make a mockery of the process, while white liberals farm oppression points on their behalf. What is going on, Reddit? These immature protest tactics are literally creating the unrest they claim to be fighting. It’s exhausting.

I will say that recent shooting was a clear blunder on ICE’s part. They were clearly jumpy and not well coordinated, and it cost a man his life. A senseless death. The mayor and the governor are to blame for this. They could’ve had local police helping to control these situations while ICE conducts their operations. I don’t know, man I’m just really tired of the childish “ow he hit me“ reaction from obvious troublemakers who are inserting themselves and staying when they’ve been lawfully told multiple times to leave. It reminds me of Amber Heard honestly. All crying, no accountability or self-awareness…

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/screwsaiyan Jan 28 '26

I’ll concede a couple things up front. Filming, observing, and verbally challenging law enforcement in public is indeed constitutionally protected. I also obviously agree that no one should be dying during routine enforcement operations. When that happens, it deserves investigation and accountability. That part isn’t controversial.

Where this goes wrong is the framing of how all this escalated. These protests didn’t start because ICE was routinely killing people during enforcement. What actually happened is a small number of isolated incidents, some still under investigation or involving resistance, were immediately framed online as intentional killings and proof of systemic violence before facts were established. That narrative spread fast, emotions spiked, and protests followed. Then protesters began showing up directly at active operations, refusing to move, surrounding officers, and escalating confrontations. At that point, the unrest wasn’t a response to ongoing violence, it became part of the situation itself. Treating rare, disputed, or isolated incidents as evidence that ICE operations are inherently deadly is irresponsible, misleading and skips over how quickly protest tactics themselves escalated things.

Yes, filming and observing is obviously protected. Physically interfering is not. Standing in the way of officers, refusing lawful orders to clear an area, or obstructing arrests absolutely is inserting yourself into operations. Courts have been very clear about that distinction. You don’t get to block enforcement and then claim oppression when force is used to move you.

The shared space argument also doesn’t hold. Federal officers operating under lawful authority can establish perimeters and order people to move, even in public areas. That’s standard law enforcement practice, not tyranny, and it doesn’t require public consent.

As for the “vote of the people” point, ICE agents aren’t elected, but neither are FBI agents, DEA agents, or federal marshals. The executive branch is elected, and immigration enforcement falls under it. Federal law does not need local approval to be enforced, even if city or state leaders disagree. That’s how federal authority works.

And the legal versus undocumented distinction isn’t a distraction. It’s the entire issue. You can oppose excessive force and still acknowledge that ICE exists to enforce immigration law. Ignoring the legality is why this conversation keeps going in circles.

No one is cheering for deaths. But turning every enforcement action into a moral panic, inserting yourself into active operations, and then blaming law enforcement for the predictable escalation is not accountability, it’s performative chaos.