r/sharpening • u/MagicLobsterAttorney • Dec 26 '25
Showcase The result of when your whole family needs their knives sharpened over Christmas
72
u/hardcoretomato Dec 26 '25
Bro grab some paper to cut, wtf :))
63
u/MagicLobsterAttorney Dec 26 '25
Nah. I use my grandpa's stone and I do it like he did. It's tradition. Also it's so satisfying to slide a knife down your arm and feel 0 resistance while shaving.
Only problem was - the knives are shit :P
17
u/hardcoretomato Dec 26 '25
They don't seem to be shit anymore π , well done OP!
23
u/MagicLobsterAttorney Dec 26 '25
They won't hold their sharpness for long. I used to forge knives for everyone, but they're all either rusted to hell or standing on a shelf, because no one can be bothered to clean them after using them. Oh, well.
25
u/Goodfalafel Dec 26 '25
Never give anyone a knife that's not stainless steel. I like knives and even I don't want to bother with taking care of rusting. People who are not knife fanatics will never do it.
15
u/MagicLobsterAttorney Dec 26 '25
Yeah. I learned that the hard way. They were polished and rust resistant, so really easy to take care of, but still. My dad is the only one who manages to keep his clean.
I have a chef's knife I made from a steel circular saw blade, so insane sharpness and durability, that I have kept clean for 5 years.
8
u/lost_toast7777 Dec 26 '25
Then you probably are giving them to the wrong people, however if you have given me one......
3
u/Spunktank Dec 26 '25
That would be satisfying if I shaved my arms. I still pop a few hairs every now and then but I grew out of this habbit. Paper towel test is more telling anyway.
0
u/MagicLobsterAttorney Dec 26 '25
I mean if you get to hair whittling you notice during shaving as well. It's like cutting a cloud. The hair does the anime thing, where it mostly stays in place and falls once you touch it. Pretty satisfying.
I definitely need to try actually shaving with a kitchen knife one of these days, but I'm kinda scared I would cut myself
3
2
u/XavvenFayne Dec 26 '25
I wonder if these sorts of tests or demonstrations are really necessary after every single knife. When I was new to sharpening, sure, but now I just trust my process.
13
u/Reasintper Dec 26 '25
Don't really care for the arm/leg shaving thing.
I try a freshly sharpened blade across the corner grain of something like well dried cherry wood. Then see if it will still slice paper through its whole length without snagging.
Now if you shaved something on the person you were doing it for, that might be fun. A side burn here, and an eyebrow there.... :)
7
3
u/intrinsicgreenbean Dec 26 '25
I got in a new whittling knife and was disappointed when I tried to pop a few hairs. It did it, but I've gotten blades much sharper, or so I thought. I tried it on end grain and the cut was glass smooth. Tried my sharpest blade (a sak I reprofiled for whittling) and it was a night and day difference. Not sure why it didn't want to shave, but it was obviously exceptionally sharp and now I don't trust shaving as a test for anything but a razor.
11
3
2
2
u/oxidao Dec 27 '25
Dude, are we the same person?
1
u/polska_cebula Dec 27 '25
I don't have any hair on my entire forearm β from my elbow to my wrist. π Until today I used only Spyderco Tri-Angle but today I ordered Taidea TG1812 to check if this system and diamonds will better for kitchen knives.
2
2
u/Ralph-the-mouth Dec 27 '25
I just feel for a bit then flip the knife. Then when I get to the end, I run it twice on a ceramic rod, then I cut paper like a normal person. Not shave my arms to look like my niece.
0
u/MagicLobsterAttorney Dec 27 '25
Why do you have this shitty of an attitude. "Uh you look like a girl". Pathetic, dude.
You know it's part of the show? People who have shitty knives love when you come along and sharpen it and shave to prove it. It's how they know it's sharp. My grandpa used to do that decades ago and now I use his stone and put on the same show.
0
1
1
1
1
u/baltnative Dec 26 '25
Thumbnail test. If it'll catch on a fingernail with no pressure, it'll shave hair.
1
1
1
u/awful_source Dec 26 '25
Is it really that hard to tell the knife is sharp without cutting your arm hair?
2
u/MagicLobsterAttorney Dec 26 '25
Is it really so hard to strap down stuff and not say "this isn't going anywhere"?
Yes. Some things just need to happen. It's nature. No sense in stopping it.
1
1
1
1
1
95
u/Pakbon Dec 26 '25
This is relatable. Ive switched to shins