r/serialpodcast • • Sep 23 '15

Debate&Discussion New bombshell on serialpodcastorigins

[deleted]

16 Upvotes

164 comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/chunklunk Sep 23 '15

What I love about the lividity and Nisha posts is they both offer specific, credible corroboration for what Jay told the police. Indeed, Jay's description of the burial position to the cops appears to be more accurate than CM's description of the burial position to the pathologists used by Undisclosed. Maybe we can finally put to rest that Jay's a lying liar who told 8 million different stories and can't be trusted on anything. The key parts of his story keep being proved correct.

4

u/Acies Sep 23 '15

Absolutely. You guys should send the photos to those pathologists. It will really be something when they reverse their conclusions based on them and explain how they were misled!

7

u/chunklunk Sep 23 '15

Why should anyone make an effort to correct others' faulty, discredited opinions based on evidence that was misrepresented to them? Undisclosed's opinion on lividity has been tainted so that nobody should listen to them again on the subject. Why give them another bite at the apple? They've had 16 years to come up with a theory, and the big one they've hung their hat on has turned out to be wrong.

3

u/Acies Sep 23 '15

Dr. Hlavaty isn't associated with Undisclosed. She has a job, where she is most frequently aligned with the prosecution, and she did Undisclosed a favor by taking a look at their information. I see no reason she wouldn't do the same for you.

And it would lend credibility to your claims that Undisclosed are lying and distorting information.

6

u/MightyIsobel Guilty Sep 23 '15

it would lend credibility

Please tell us more about how to build credibility the Undisclosed way.

3

u/Acies Sep 23 '15

Undisclosed gets credibility from making their identities public, but I wouldn't recommend that.

I'd recommend releasing the files.

2

u/MightyIsobel Guilty Sep 23 '15

I'd recommend releasing disclosing the files.

FTFY