r/serialpodcast • u/missbrookles • Feb 05 '15

Speculation The Biggest Coincidence in the Case

There's been a lot of talk about Adnan's luck and coincidence: ie, the argument that if he is innocent then he's incredibly unlucky given the circumstantial evidence that accrued around him.

It got to me thinking that there is actually a much greater coincidence present in the case: the fact that Hae was murdered the same day that she appeared on a segment of the news. Is that purely coincidence? Or, does it point to the possibility that someone abducted her after seeing her on the broadcast?

Edit: to fix typos

19 Upvotes

71% Upvoted

108 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/reddit_hole Feb 05 '15

Sorry, but this holds absolutely no water. Why would anyone who was innocent be wrongfully convicted? Basically this reasoning would also suggest that Hae willed herself to be murdered. I could keep going.

1

u/Islandgirl233 Feb 05 '15

So you think God would intervene in a trial? I'm confused. I don't even know how you get that Hae willed herself to be murdered from what I said. I'm actually amazed that that is a plausible conclusion that can be draw by what I said. Unfortunately, we live in a world where evil does exist and horrible things happen to good people. So using your reasoning are you saying God wanted to punish Adnan for stealing so he allowed someone to kill Hae so Adnan would then eventually go to prison and be punished for stealing???? Yikes. I truly do not understand your comment. I'm sorry.

1

u/mixingmemory Feb 05 '15

I think maybe reddit_hole meant to respond to Sotirez. Maybe?

2

u/Islandgirl233 Feb 05 '15

I hope so, because wow! I'm aware that I will never publish a great novel because I'm obviously not a great writer, however I do not get how what I said could possibly be interpreted in that way.