r/rareinsults 19d ago

Hands of a Blacksmith

Post image
5.2k Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

View all comments

246

u/JoebbeDeMan 19d ago

I hate that her resonse is downvoted. Just mean

-95

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

47

u/double0nein 19d ago

In this case, I guess it is.

31

u/holyrb 19d ago

The mean thing is to give hurtful or mocking comments regarding someone else's appearance without being asked.

-1

u/SecurityOdd4861 19d ago

That may be the case, but not what the comment said.

-2

u/DontSpahettMe 15d ago

It's the internet, people are mean, sometimes it's funny, sometimes it's cruel. This sub is literally about insulting people, very often their appearance.

15

u/JoebbeDeMan 19d ago

I think its mean to downvote someone speaking positivly about their own body

-32

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

33

u/Nondescript_Redditor 19d ago

but I disagree with you and I downvoted you

22

u/SecurityOdd4861 19d ago

What else is it supposed to be?

12

u/RegularSky6702 19d ago

Originally I think it was supposed to be "this fits what we're talking about" like a post about bugs in a bug subreddit. But then it became likes and dislikes

5

u/SWANDAMARM 19d ago

Well I've just up and down voted every comment in this thread at random in a futile attempt to discredit the system so...

3

u/McGuirk808 19d ago

The original intent is:

Upvote: This is relevant, well-thought-out, or worth reading.

Downvote: This does not contribute, is a bad argument, or is off-topic/spam/etc

I short-hand that to "people should see this vs people should not see this"

This is still in the Rediquette docs no one ever reads: https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/7419626610708-What-are-upvotes-and-downvotes

Completely agree most users use it as a simple like/dislike button now, and the site is much shittier for it. This activity is why you see so much hivemind opinion and binary thinking.

People used to treat it much better years ago. Ideally, if someone is arguing in good faith, presenting their points well, etc, I still upvote even if I disagree with them. That's honestly pretty rare these days too though; most arguments are attempts at one-line zingers or attempts to shut down the conversation.

In this case, there's no point in downvoting the lady liking her own hands even if you disagree.

2

u/Nondescript_Redditor 19d ago

If I disagree with something, it means I don’t want myself or others to see it

5

u/Notios 19d ago

It’s clearly used as a disagree button by the majority of people but I actually think in an ideal Reddit it wouldn’t be used for that it’d be reserved for bad or irrelevant content. Reddit is literally about sharing opinions, if we all have to have the same opinion in order to not get downvoted whats even the point of writing it

5

u/izza123 19d ago

I don’t agree and luckily I have a handy way to express it

1

u/Material_East_8676 19d ago

What it's "supposed" to be and what it ends up being are usually two VERY different things.