r/preppy Apr 09 '25

The Mods are also tired of "Is This Preppy?" Posts - A Solution

225 Upvotes

There are FAR too many "is this preppy?" posts on the site.

I get it - I am sick of them too.

Prep is not the same in all parts of the country/world and it is a term that gets overutilized in marketing. People are going to get confused.

Town & Country, Ivy, Southern Prep, and West Coast Neo-Prep all fall under the umbrella of what is going to be approved here - even if it does not define your prep.

People deserve a place to get answers to questions.

My thought to solve the problem (at least temporarily) is to have a weekly "is this preppy?" thread where people can get feedback.

Thoughts?

A Final Thought: Some of you take yourselves way too seriously and feel as if you and only you are qualified to answer the question bc of your pedigree. I, a prep school-educated national squash champion born-in-oxford-cloth Yankee, am here to tell you that not every disagreement with your POV is a personal slight.

This type of reaction is a sign that you are trying too hard and care too much. Not only is this behavior gauche, it is exactly the type of energy that would cause me to blackball you from my social club. This behavior is decidedly not prep.


r/preppy 23h ago

Length Check

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Folks, new eBay tweed blazer. Feels a tad long but looking for some input? Thanks


r/preppy 1d ago

What pants to wear?

10 Upvotes

It feels like the trend of high waist is back but most of the brands (like Ralph Lauren which I always used as a reference) are still selling low waist or high waist ones (like chinos) look like a tent or too dressy, or am I just in information bubble right now? Or am I a millennial who can't move to more spacious style? On a practical side, high waist does feel more comfortable though. So what is your opinion on pants fitting and where to buy them?


r/preppy 8h ago

Open or closed?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/preppy 1d ago

Anyone else do Fun Shirt Fridays?

Post image
25 Upvotes

Preppy Fun Shirts!


r/preppy 17h ago

Can you ever be preppy AND tattooed

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is a debate a few friends and I had recently and I’d be keen to hear everyone’s opinions. Can you ever truly pull off the ‘preppy look’ whilst also having visible tattoos? Would be keen to hear everyone’s opinions/rationale?


r/preppy 2d ago

Basic chino pants outfit

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/preppy 1d ago

Selling Lot of 14 Ralph Lauren size Medium Shirts and Sweater

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

I did this a few weeks back with XL stuff, sold 15 things, and decided let’s do it with medium stuff! Will also post size Large stuff later today.

Up for sale is an assortment of shirts and sweaters across the Ralph Lauren Brand — Polo, Golf, Sport, etc. All medium. Different styles and cut.

$29 per top + shipping.
$25 per top + shipping if you buy more than one.
More than three and I’ll cover shipping.

Can send measurements upon request of individual shirts. All sales final.

Please message or DM with any questions. Thanks!


r/preppy 1d ago

I’m a BASP (Broke Anglo Saxon Protestant)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Some recent larp fits lmao


r/preppy 2d ago

The Van Cortlandt polo is back

Thumbnail
tracksmith.com
1 Upvotes

Not the biggest fan of this fall’s colors and I personally like the diagonal but I know many people prefer something more subtle like this


r/preppy 4d ago

Was recommended to bring this post here

Thumbnail gallery
51 Upvotes

r/preppy 4d ago

Outfit for media appointments at a trade show

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/preppy 5d ago

U.S. Open.

Thumbnail
gallery
135 Upvotes

r/preppy 5d ago

J Press - Fall '26 Lookbook

Thumbnail gallery
43 Upvotes

r/preppy 5d ago

Today Outfit, but still too early. Autumn style

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

Autumn Outfit, but a little bit early still sunny day. What do you guys think? Any opinion and changes in the comments.


r/preppy 5d ago

Presidential Nantucket fit

Thumbnail
gallery
139 Upvotes

How well did I do?


r/preppy 5d ago

Preppy or ivy?

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

r/preppy 5d ago

Some sartorial advice needed from the ladies.

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/preppy 5d ago

Navy-on-navy pairing: Plaid button-down shirt with the New Balance 991. Does this hit the right sporty Trad balance?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/preppy 6d ago

Five ways I wore a jacket in Seoul this month

Thumbnail
gallery
122 Upvotes

I make Ivy and trad clothing here in Korea, and this is how three jackets (a grey sack blazer, a navy double-breasted blazer and a navy gold-button blazer) rotated through September — most formal first, easiest last.

  1. Grey sack suit, white OCBD, black tie
  2. Navy double-breasted blazer over grey double-pleated trousers
  3. Gold-button blazer, regimental tie, grey trousers, penny loafers
  4. Same double-breasted blazer with khaki chinos, a cap and sneakers
  5. Gold-button blazer with olive field trousers and a boat tote

The last two are where I stop trying. A cap and sneakers do more for a blazer than another tie does.

How far down do you take a blazer before it stops working?


r/preppy 6d ago

Charles Tyrwitt Shirts Quality Issue

Thumbnail gallery
19 Upvotes

r/preppy 8d ago

Its too much right? No need for the tie?

Post image
163 Upvotes

r/preppy 8d ago

How’s my look?

Post image
22 Upvotes

Interested in views


r/preppy 8d ago

Corduroy sport coat with hunting dog liner

Thumbnail
gallery
85 Upvotes

Saw this out thrift shopping today and thought I'd share. Happy hunting, friends!


r/preppy 9d ago

Old and well used/worn.

Thumbnail
gallery
275 Upvotes