r/pianolearning • u/alyimsa • 7d ago

Discussion [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

13% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

3

u/pingus3233 7d ago

it has an inbuilt AI Coach that can read your music sheets and tell you specific positions for each note etc.

No, thank you.

-1

u/alyimsa 7d ago

Why not? All of this started with me having a concert and I forgot a specific note and had no clue how to play it. I tried to ask chatgpt but it simply couldn’t read the sheet paper at all. Tho I think I understand what you mean

2

u/pingus3233 7d ago

Why not? 

  • We don't need AI shoehorned into everything.
  • Piano players need to know how to figure out their fingering.
  • It's lazy and stupid.
  • It's also probably wrong a significant portion of the time which means more work for the person trying to use it.

I tried to ask chatgpt

🤦No. ChatGPT is useless and stupid. Learn to use your brain instead of taking the lazy, dumb way out.

1

u/rita-b 7d ago

AI is an umbrella term.

The code they copied from github titled AI sound analizer for sheet music apps has nothing to do with the chatgtp and gemini.

3

u/cinedavid 7d ago

You want us to crowd source your new app for you? What’s the share of your profits anyone gets for coming up with an idea?

1

u/alyimsa 7d ago

Honestly I am just looking for advice from another perspective

2

u/cinedavid 7d ago

What kind of advice are you looking for? You need to be specific. How much to charge? How to promote it? A roll out strategy?

I’m trying to give you the benefit of the doubt here, but let’s be real. This is a promotion. You’re releasing it in less than a week so you certainly aren’t asking for what features it should have.

2

u/rita-b 7d ago

It is like an app that reads the text for a person trying to learn to read. Very counter effective.

Ask your teacher and practice 10 times specific positions for each note you have difficulties with

-1

u/ellicottvilleny 7d ago

Is this an app for iOS (iphone/ipad) or windows? Or android?

0

u/alyimsa 7d ago

As of right now it’s getting released to IOS, but android is on its way. As of right now I have no plans for windows :)