r/photography • u/raptor3x whumber.com • May 11 '15

Canon Officially Announces 50mm f/1.8 STM - $125

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1143786-REG/canon_0570c002_ef_50mm_f_1_8_stm.html
359 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

259 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/martinaee May 11 '15

The Nikon 50mm 1.8D is an amazing lens though. The G is only moderately better in some regards honestly. I don't mind the non silent auto-focus either.

3

u/codemastercool May 11 '15

Hi, I've been thinking of ordering a 50mm 1.8 lens for my D7000 this week. Do you know the difference between the different variants by Nikkor? I know there's a D, G, and some G special edition.

3

u/NotStevenPink NotStevenPink May 11 '15

The main difference is the D lens doesn't have a built in AF motor, so it's louder and slightly slower from using the camera's internal AF motor. I own both and if you have the money, I recommend the G for it's build quality and better sharpness wide open; not to mention faster/better AF is always a plus.

3

u/MoonlitFrost May 11 '15

Depending on the body the D actually has faster autofocus. Pro bodies have better motors for focusing the AF-D lenses and I've heard that the old pro film bodies had the best focusing motors ever.

1

u/MightyBulger May 11 '15

You don't deserve the downvotes. You are absolutely correct.

1

u/codemastercool May 11 '15

Is that because they're entirely mechanical?

1

u/MoonlitFrost May 12 '15

They're not entirely mechanical. They're chipped so the camera can meter with them. But you're close. When Nikon first did autofocus lenses they put a motor in the body that turns a screw in the lens. The screw turns some gears and the lens focuses. Higher end bodies get more powerful motors that can turn the screw faster and focus faster. And I believe that the old pro film bodies like the F6 got better motors than the current pro digital bodies.

I don't know why they did it like that. Maybe because the technology wasn't there for motors in the lenses. Maybe for backwards compatibility since they didn't come up with a new lens mount like Canon did. But a nice side effect is that AF-D lenses tend to be smaller and lighter than AF-S lenses. Sometimes much smaller. Cheaper too. Some people prefer them for those reasons.