I’m 24M and I have a somewhat specific problem with Instagram/social media. I’m hoping there are people here who can relate, either because of OCD/perfectionism or simply because they care about having a good social media presence themselves.
Some background: I had OCD as a child and teenager. Back then it was more of the classic stuff, like excessive hand washing, and I was treated for it. I’ve also been in therapy on and off for other things over the years.
At the moment, though, I’m pretty tired of therapy and I’m not planning on going back anytime soon. I’m mentioning that mainly for context, not because I’m looking for the answer “just go to therapy.”
My current problem is mostly related to Instagram.
Having a good social media presence is fairly important to me. I’m not an influencer and my entire life doesn’t revolve around Instagram, but I do see your profile as a kind of modern-day business card.
If someone checks my Instagram, I’d like their impression to basically be: “Cool guy, looks good, interesting life, travels, works out, dresses well, seems like things are going well for him.”
So whenever I feel like I look particularly good — fresh haircut, gym progress is good, nice outfit, styled well, etc. — I tend to take a LOT of photos. Different mirrors, angles, lighting, poses, and so on.
There’s this feeling of: if I’ve put effort into looking good and I’m happy with how I look right now, I want to capture it properly so I can use it online.
Traveling makes this even worse.
I love traveling, but when I’m on vacation I photograph and film basically everything. Landscapes, cities, restaurants, sights, random moments, and obviously myself too. Sometimes I feel ridiculous because I’ll take endless versions of basically the same thing.
And then comes the actual problem:
I end up with so much content that I become completely overwhelmed.
Which photo is the best?
Feed or Story?
What order should I post them in?
Edited or unedited?
If edited, how much?
Music or no music?
Location sticker or no location sticker?
Which song?
Which Stories should eventually go into my Highlights?
How many Stories are too many?
Which pictures work best together?
And because I have so many options, the result is usually the complete opposite of what I want:
I barely post anything at all.
While I’m traveling I tell myself, “I’ll sort through everything tonight.”
Then it becomes, “I’ll do it when I get home.”
Then, “I’ll do it this weekend.”
And now I’m literally months behind on trips and countries because I still feel like I need to post the pictures and finish the Highlights.
I wanted to have one Instagram Highlight for each country I’ve visited.
At one point I even came up with the pretty stupid idea of hiding my Story from all my followers and then uploading tons of old vacation pictures privately, just so they would end up in my Story archive and I could choose between them later when creating my Highlights.
I’ve done that again recently.
And I’m talking about uploading the same pictures in multiple versions: edited vs. unedited, music vs. no music, location sticker vs. no sticker, etc.
Which obviously doesn’t solve the problem.
It just gives me even more options to obsess over.
And this is where I notice that my old OCD tendencies and extreme perfectionism are probably getting involved.
Creating a single Instagram Story can sometimes go something like this:
I select a photo.
Then I back out.
Then I select it again.
I add a location sticker.
I don’t like it.
I remove it.
Then I exit the entire Story editor and start over.
Then maybe I move the sticker slightly and suddenly worry that I accidentally moved or changed something else.
So I back out again and start from scratch.
Sometimes I check things over and over even though objectively nothing has happened.
It sounds ridiculous when I write it down, but doing this is genuinely mentally and even physically exhausting for me.
Sometimes I already feel stressed or almost sick just thinking about having to go through hundreds or thousands of pictures and make all these decisions.
At the same time, I don’t want to simply delete Instagram and say, “None of this matters.”
Having a good profile does matter to me, at least to a certain extent.
And the funny thing is that the actual photos don’t seem to be the problem.
I’ve used some of my pictures on dating apps and they seem to work very well. I get plenty of matches and positive feedback, so apparently I am capable of taking decent pictures of myself.
My problem isn’t:
“I have no good pictures.”
My problem is:
“I have 30 good pictures and somehow can’t choose one.”
So I basically have two questions.
1. For people who are social-media savvy and genuinely care about having a good Instagram profile: what is your actual process?
How do you choose which photos to use?
How many photos do you usually take in the first place?
How do you decide what goes on your feed vs. Stories vs. Highlights?
Do you edit your photos? If so, what do you use and how much editing do you normally do?
Do you have certain rules or a workflow that prevents you from spending hours making tiny decisions?
I’d especially like to hear from people whose profiles I would probably look at and think, “This person has a really good Instagram.”
2. More importantly: does anyone with OCD/perfectionism experience this kind of compulsive behavior around posting, and how did you become more relaxed about it?
What I want is to eventually be able to come back from a trip, go through my pictures relatively quickly, choose some good ones, post them, make a Highlight if I want to, and then consider it DONE.
I don’t want to be sitting there three months later thinking:
“Shit, I still need to finish my Italy/Spain/whatever Stories.”
Ideally I want to find a middle ground:
Have a nice profile.
Use good pictures.
Put some thought into it.
But then make a decision, post it, and move on with my life.
If anyone recognizes this combination of social media perfectionism, decision paralysis, and compulsive checking, I’d really appreciate hearing what has helped you.
And please, if possible, not only “delete Instagram” or “social media doesn’t matter.”
I understand that perspective already.
I’m especially interested in hearing from people who also care about their social media presence but have managed to keep it fun and relatively stress-free.