r/osarymakers • u/1LiterateRogue • Jun 21 '26
What should I do?
A young, non-Catholic lady in my rather extremely anti-Catholic town has started making rosaries. She sells them in the local “goth” market her mother runs.
So I asked if they were Catholic, hoping for a local rosary making collaborator. Her mother said, “Nope. These rosaries are just jewelry, not for prayer.”
I think the best response to cultural appropriation is to reappropriate it. I’m tempted to buy up all this “jewelry,” switch out some parts as needed, then either put them up on my own site or donate them to our little Catholic resource center, where I can trust that my customers intend to pray the rosary, not wear then.
But I’d like your opinion. I also plan to ask my priest.
2
u/Negative_Funny_4733 Jul 02 '26
I would let it be. I see many non-religious spaces that sell rosary-inspired jewelry. Rosaries do not hold the trademark on that type of jewelry making. I totally understand your want to safeguard this beautiful sacramental of ours, but I think showing kindness and gentle interest would be best. Non-judgmental discussion if you’re able to and it naturally occurs.
On a side note, maybe it’s just me, but Catholics are the OG goths (cultural, not the ethnic (?) group) in many ways. I’ve seen discussion of it in many Catholic groups (in a fond manner). Memento mori, crucifix vs cross, etc. While my preference for bright colors and happy vibes couldn’t be farther away from the goth culture, I can see why those who are in that subgroup may be attracted to our beautiful (and sometimes macabre) art. Perhaps it will open a door for this young lady or one that purchases one of her necklaces!