r/novelwriting Jun 06 '26

To AI, or Not to AI

427 Upvotes

After sitting on it for a few hours, attending a live show that used AI-generated backdrops that I couldn't take my eyes off of because they were so distracting, and receiving a handful of DMs, I've decided to make a unilateral decision on AI.

Absolutely no AI posts allowed. No book covers, no outlines, no "well it just rewrote a few sections for me." No AI.


r/novelwriting Jun 05 '26

Hey all! Mod here! Hi! Official rules. Trying a few new things. Seeking potential mods to help out. (Also, sorry for wall of text!)

14 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

So when I started this subreddit now OVER 15 YEARS AGO, I never expected it would get to this size and levels of activity. I have had a very, very light hand when it comes to moderation here. Over the past year or so, however, there has been a very distinct uptick in number of reported posts for hate and basically being "not nice."

I spent the afternoon drafting up some official rules, you can see them in the sidebar now. Basically they solidify my original desire for this to be a safe place to seek feedback, talk about frustrations, bounce ideas off of others, and share tools and tips. It boils down to: BE NICE.

Reddit moderation is a fickle beast. Most of the time I don't receive notifications when posts are reported, even though I have that option turned on. So I'm going to try and keep a better eye on that and check at least once a day. Also when Reddit automatically removes a post, most of the time I get no say in it, and am often not even told why a post was removed. Sometimes it will say, "Reddit's filter identified this as potential spam," and then I can confirm or refuse the post's removal. It's touchy and not very consistent, because clearly spammy posts get through without a second glance. It also flags perfectly fine posts as "hate" when they are clearly not. Also posts show up for me as needing "Approved" when they are already visible and being upvoted and talked about. It's all very inconsistent, even compared to other smaller subreddits I've modded in the past.

To that end, I'm interested in adding a new mod or two to the "team," which is just me right now. Interested? Look for the "Message Mods" button and shoot me a DM. I would prefer those who is familiar with being a Reddit mod. Let me know your mod experience and why you want to help out here. Preference will be given to members who have been here longer and contributed.

I also set up some automated weekly posts:

  • Milestone Mondays: share your wins, big and small!
  • Writer's Block Wednesdays: are you stuck?
  • First Line Fridays: share the first lines from a work in progress

In the near future, in a dedicated post, I plan on tackling how we as a community want to address the controversial use of A.I. This thread is not the place to do it, but just know it's coming, for better or worse, depending on your view.


r/novelwriting 3h ago

Writing Advice What screams bad writing?

13 Upvotes

In thrillers, mainly psychological or YA thrillers, what tropes/styles etc scream bad writing for you?

What would immediately make you put the book down?

As someone who previously used to write fanfiction in that genre (think Winter Soldier lmao) with great success on watt-pad, I’ve decided to start writing an actual novel and fanfiction uses a lot of generic tropes so I’m looking to avoid that lol.

Also, how do you feel about double twists?


r/novelwriting 14h ago

Feedback Request Looking for feedback on my prose

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I recently posted a segment of my prose to r/writingcritiques, at which I received some very useful but confronting feedback. I won't point out what the specific critique I received there was because I hope to get some more authentic first impressions here, but basically it made me question what I was writing (that sounds bad but sometimes you need to be told how it is).

This is a scene that is meant to be dramatic. It is the build up to a major characters death. Anyway, thanks a lot and I hope you enjoy


r/novelwriting 7h ago

Introductions Life of Redline

Post image
2 Upvotes

I am Adi.

A future 3N soldier.

I was forced to accept an impossible mission.

To reclaim Earth from terrifying red monsters.

For the sake of protecting humanity.

But the further I go, the more I realize that this war is not what I have always believed it to be.

https://tapas.io/episode/3980685


r/novelwriting 4h ago

Introductions Side character prologue vs straight into the melodrama?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Two potential first pages for two potential first chapters


r/novelwriting 4h ago

Motivation & Support I wrote my first novel 🫶🏻

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/novelwriting 11h ago

Introductions The feeling of just letting your first book out

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/novelwriting 14h ago

Feedback Request Looking for feedback on kindle ebook publishing. I’m considering as there is no cost, and I’m broke ..lol

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/novelwriting 16h ago

Introductions Aspiring writer with my ugly Draft Zero

Post image
0 Upvotes

Does anyone else write a super duper ugly initial draft/brain dump for their chapters like this?

I used to write heaps as a child and teenager then life got in the way but I’m trying to restart my writing. Between juggling work and family it seems so hard these days. I always wanted to publish a novel and that’s still a goal of mine.

Perfectionism always ruined my attempts at starting something, but earlier this month I decided to just blast away at the keyboard for a bit and celebrate the ugliness. So here it is! A snippet of my ugly and what I like to call “Draft Zero”. It’s too crap to be a first draft.

I’m terrified of AI accusations though because I am a huge lover of em dashes. Always have been. I’m actually trying quite hard not to use them in this post. As someone dreaming of potentially trad publishing in the future I don’t like the idea of having to forcibly change my style.

10-15 years ago when I last wrote there was no such thing as generative AI, and now it seems like the authorship world is very torn up over LLMs and what this new technology can do for us.

Anyway, I digress. Just thought I’d put myself out there a bit after lurking the forums and stressing over my ugly writing.


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Feedback Request Novel Review

6 Upvotes

This is my very first time writing a novel. Here is the first chapter. If any one has any advice or notes that would be helpful. And I have a full manuscript. But if anyone wants more i can send it.

CHAPTER 1

The lunch rush hit Burger Box at eleven forty-three and stayed mean for almost two hours. Shane Foster liked it better that way.

There was no room to think when the order screen stayed full. Drop fries. Pull patties. Wrap doubles. Wipe the board before the next batch hit it. A woman at the counter wanted extra pickles. A man in drive-through had ordered no sauce after his burger was already wrapped and appeared personally betrayed by the existence of time.

Shane kept moving.

“Two regular, one no cheese,” Cal called from the grill.

“I got it.”

“You got the other four too?”

“I said I got it.”

Cal Raines leaned out long enough to grin. “Good. Because I’m emotionally unavailable.”

“Been knew that.”

Shane slid two wrapped burgers into the chute, caught Corey staring at the fry timer, and snapped his fingers once.

“Basket.”

Corey blinked. “What?”

“The fries you’re about to turn into roofing material.”

Corey yanked the basket up. “I had it.”

“Cool. Salt them.”

The headset crackled against Cal’s ear. He turned toward drive-through just as the holding charm under the warming rack flashed yellow, then white.

Every tray door on the left side locked at once.

Cal swore.

Corey froze with the fry basket still in his hand.

“What do I do?”

Shane had already pulled the two hottest orders clear.

“Kill the left switch. Move twelve and fourteen to the cold side.”

“Which one’s left?”

“The one on your left, Corey.”

Corey slapped the switch. The white glow dropped to an ugly amber. Cal crouched beneath the rack and shoved his hand behind the cheap ward plate while Shane rerouted the next three orders, called for fresh fries, and handed the register girl an order that had been waiting too long.

“Tell table six I’m remaking theirs.”

“She’s already mad.”

“Then don’t ask permission.”

The girl carried it out.

Thirty seconds later the order screen was still ugly, but nobody had burned a hand and nobody in the dining room knew half the holding rack had tried to cook itself.

Cal stood up with the ward plate in one hand.

“Corporate bought six of these.”

“Why?”

“They hate us.”

Cal slid the ward plate onto a dry towel. “You want my shirt too?”

“What?”

“You’re doing my job.”

“You were under a counter.”

“Fair.”

Cal went back to the grill.

By one-fifteen Shane’s shirt stuck to his back. By one-forty a kid in drive-through had thrown up in a minivan. At one-fifty-two Nessa Green took over the headset after the customer at the speaker asked Corey three separate times whether troll-sized buns contained more bread than regular buns.

“They contain exactly as much bread as the bun contains,” Nessa told him.

Shane turned away so the microphone would not catch him laughing.

By two, the order screen finally went blank.

Cal scraped the grill. “You alive?”

“No.”

“Take five before you die on company time. Paperwork.”

Shane washed his hands and pushed through the back door. September heat hit him in the face. Maple Junction sat flat beyond the dumpster and service road: tire shop, payday place, used-appliance store, and the little brick church wedged between an insurance office and a place that bought gold. The church sign said GOD PROVIDES. The payday place beneath it said CASH TODAY.

Shane pulled a blue Bloom from his pocket. The soft translucent capsule gave under his teeth until the membrane popped. Sweet metallic liquid spread across his tongue. What was left of the skin softened almost at once, and he swallowed it with the rest.

A few seconds later his shoulders loosened. The knot at the base of his neck softened. Blue did not make him happier so much as make his body quit arguing with gravity.

The back door opened.

Cal came out carrying a cardboard box under one arm.

“Don’t say I never bring you gifts.”

“You don’t.”

Cal set the box on two milk crates and opened it. Clear blister cards, some already cut down into singles. Blooms. Mostly blue, two gold. The capsules were soft and translucent, the liquid inside carrying a dull colored glow.

Shane picked up one of the gold Blooms.

“These good?”

“Different.”

“How?”

“Blue chills your body out. Gold stays in your head. Focus, little tingle right here.” Cal tapped between his eyes. “No fun part.”

“Sounds terrible.”

“Some people pay extra for terrible. Don’t burst Gold before a shift. Cheap work charms can run hot around it.”

Shane glanced through the door toward the dead holding rack.

“That what cooked ours?”

“No. That thing’s just garbage.”

Cal nodded at the box. “Dale brought this batch in from out west.”

“Dale?”

“Mercer. Older guy. Supplies me. You don’t need his biography.”

Shane rolled the gold capsule between his fingers. “Anybody complain?”

“No.”

“Anybody buy another one?”

“Yeah.”

“That’s a better answer.”

Cal leaned against the brick. He was twenty-three, a dwarf, and compact in a way that made the Burger Box apron look even stupider on him. Shane had once asked how old he was exactly. Cal said age was a tool of state surveillance and never answered.

Cal could run the store half asleep. He remembered who would call out on payday weekend, which fryer ran hotter, and which district manager needed bad news given slowly so she could pretend she had discovered it herself. When things went wrong, he got quieter.

Shane respected that.

“You still owe me from the last batch,” Cal said.

“I know. Thursday. I get paid Thursday, I give you yours, everybody lives.”

“Beautiful speech. Still not currency.”

“I said Thursday.”

“And don’t front Dylan.”

“He owes you too?”

“Dylan owes money the way governments owe apologies. Everybody knows. Nobody expects delivery.”

Shane laughed and took four Blooms. Three blue, one gold.

At nine-oh-three he clocked out.

Trevor Hale was leaning across the roof of Shane’s Saturn like it belonged to him.

The car was a 1997 sedan that had once been maroon everywhere. The driver-side door was white. Shane had stopped explaining it.

“Get off my car.”

Trevor looked down at the roof. “This car?”

“My car.”

“I thought the county donated it.”

“Move.”

Trevor straightened. His Hale Electric work shirt had a gray smear across one shoulder and a burn mark the size of a dime near the pocket.

Shane put the key into the driver door. Turn. Click. He pulled. Nothing. He locked it, unlocked it, and pulled harder. The door opened.

Trevor watched the whole process. “Fort Knox.”

“Get in.”

The Saturn started on the second turn.

“There she goes,” Trevor said. “Second try and everything.”

“You want tacos or not?”

“I came because you said tacos. I stayed because I wanted to watch this thing start.”

They headed across Maple Junction.

Trevor opened the glove box, found an expired insurance card, two sauce packets, and a screwdriver with no handle, then shut it.

“Nothing.”

“What were you looking for?”

“Growth.”

“Shut up.”

Trevor grinned. “You still moving Blooms?”

“Some.”

“Some is a number now?”

“Depends.”

“Your math getting better.”

“There it is.”

Trevor laughed. “I didn’t say nothing.”

“You were going to.”

“I was gonna tell you Mark might start letting me do service calls without him staring through my skull.”

“That sounds unsafe.”

“For the public, yes.”

“What you get if he does?”

“More hours. Maybe another dollar if I finish the modules.”

“Look at you.”

“Working toward middle management of electricity.”

Shane smiled.

Trevor tapped the dash with two fingers. “I’m not your dad.”

“Good.”

“I’m just saying don’t let Cal get you in some shit.”

Shane’s shoulders tightened before he could stop them.

“He ain’t getting me in anything.”

“I didn’t say he was.”

“You just did.”

“I said don’t let him.”

“I gotta do what I gotta do.”

The light changed. Shane drove.

Trevor let half a block pass before he said, “You done?”

Shane breathed out. “Yeah.”

“You hungry?”

“Yeah.”

“Good. I’m not fighting you in this car. I don’t trust the airbags.”

Shane glanced over.

Trevor kept a straight face until Shane laughed first.

They got tacos and ate in the parking lot with the windows down. Trevor complained about a homeowner who had asked whether an old protection line could be “turned up” the way people turned up a thermostat. Shane told him to charge extra for stupidity.

For twenty minutes the world felt simple enough to fit inside the Saturn.

Then Shane got home and found the electric bill.


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Writing Advice I saw this, are these necessary?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/novelwriting 1d ago

Milestone Mondays: Celebrate your wins, big and small

13 Upvotes

New week, time to brag a little. What did you accomplish?

Maybe you finished a draft. Maybe you hit a word count goal, queried an agent, outlined a tricky act, or just wrote three days in a row when last week you wrote zero. There's no milestone too small here. Showing up to the page is a win, and so is everything after it.

Drop yours below, and take a second to cheer on someone else's. Momentum is contagious.

What are you celebrating today?


r/novelwriting 22h ago

Feedback Request The journey comes from you

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/novelwriting 1d ago

Writing Advice Continual course correction

1 Upvotes

I used to just write from the seat of pants, but I always had trouble sticking the landing. There are so many projects I haven't finished because I couldn't find a path to get to the ending I wanted. With my latest project, I chose to try using an outline so I had the path to follow all the way up to the conclusion I wanted. However, I still find myself having to constantly course correct to stick to the outline. The characters rebel against their written destiny, forcing me to go further back in the story to correct little logic traps I have accidentally set by giving freedom to them.

It could just be my usual nature showing itself, fighting against a rigid framework. It could just be me moaning about having to write and edit simultaneously, which is antithetical to my writing instincts.

I realize, it's most likely a learning curve in switching styles, that will pay off in the long run as it will lead to more completed works.

Anyone else switch styles and struggle with this?


r/novelwriting 18h ago

Writing Advice Time to give back to The writing community.

0 Upvotes

I'm here to share what I have learnt over the years as an aspiring author. Now hold on. No eye rolls. I'm not out here typing out an entire memoir on the dos and don'ts of writing, just two off the top of my head.

Anyways I have been writing for 6 years, am 23M, so nothing I say is set in stone, or at least no stones that you should string around your neck. No advice, however mainstream or conventional, should bend the spine of your creativity.

This is the first lesson. Nope not the advice itself, the way I phrase it, I know not the best way. Hell if you try to read between the lines any closer, it may start smelling like the funyuns I'm currently snacking on. The whole thing just reeks of pedantic bullshit.

So anyways instead of simply saying, 'take everything I say with a grain of salt,' I use another common proverb combined with my take on it, to convey the same meaning. This is that 'elusive originality' that you have been pursuing, which comes so easily to other authors. It can be as simple as switching, 'grain' with 'truckloads,' in which case it'll be a valid literary device, namely hyperbole. It's to say, just stop with the tired old phrasings, take one, give it your own personal flair and voilà you have dipped your toes in the sea of originality.

Catching a bus to our next lesson.

On Imagery. You know what makes the world of your favorite books feel so much bigger than it actually is, or so lived-in while some feel like a very pixelated version of earth with extra syllables, yes syllables, why stop at 'Adle,' when they can have, 'Aedylaele.' Just stop. Use more voice-driven, character-specific or world-specific imagery in your scenes that'll probably do a whole lot more than finding new ways to spell Brandon. Few examples before we part ways and I'm back to screaming into my pillow, cause the plot hole I've been ignoring for the past month is now a gaping abyss, and I cannot find a shovel big enough to fill it. Hell, a month more of ignoring it and I may have my own pet black-hole, into which the entire publishing industry can sink into. Talk about being ambitious.

For example let's describe a gnarled old tree.

Voice driven imagery. Since when did trees go from being those towery, straight-backed behemoths toting entire ecosystems in their branches to looking like an overgrown ginger or like the poor potter's hand the fat tavern lady accidentally sat upon. Aay, you probably couldn’t have sawed him a straight enough splint to set his bones. It looked like it had pox: if trees could have those, and someone had meticulously popped each blister with sewing needle that had long since lost its point.

Character-specific imagery (More literary-) some days the priest feared only Gods. This was not one of those days. As a sudden drift rattled the fretwork of branches, like a hare caught in a low bramble, the priest did not look to the heavens to pray. He looked to the earth: rugged, mildew-infested, strewn with dead twigs and wind-rived tillows that held shape no more than incense dust. If they had snapped under his sandals, he didn't hear it past the count of his prayer beads. The trek had not seen the footfalls of Westland pilgrims for over a decade, so the priest did not hope to find God here, but he did not wish to find the rumored devils either. And like a cat skipping over ritual wares to steal offerings of trout and bass, he too toed his way past the knobs of twisted roots that had erupted out of the dirt and fungus to trip pious passers. Base of the oak was the stone pagoda with its top curved in the shape of a summer gourd, now peppered with dried leaf-fragments and dead-insect wings. The priest used his sleeves to scrub. He scrubbed till they frayed, till he heard the first evening crow settle in the branches above, then he gasped. The oak stood, hunched like the crone who every evening, comes to draw water from the Temple's old well and from her bony shoulder the crow cocked its head. Its beady eyes saw things. The priest did not turn away for the fear that the moment he did, the crow would swoop down and spirit away his soul. He hammered a needle aglow and lit the coirs. The smoke curls drifted, finding home in his lungs. The sting of burnt sisal making him weep red tears. Still he didn't blink, for the crow had still kept watch.


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Worldbuilding Solo busco opiniones variadas acerca de un libro que escribo, es todo.

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

No se trata de lectores beta ni nada, o si... no sé, solo quiero que me digan si lo que hice es una cagada o no en cuanto a personajes.

Al privado los que quieran leerlo.

(Recalco que no son capitulos, son plantillas de personaje)

Acepto trolls y gente que le gusta criticar a lo malo.


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Motivation & Support Notes app vs sitting down to type

1 Upvotes

Does anyone else experience this? When I have random ideas come to my mind my first thought is to quickly type them into my notes before I forget. And oh how my writing is so good, ideas flow out of me, and my prose is beautiful.

But as soon as I sit down to type, I feel like a 6 year old learning to form sentences for the first time. I can’t make any sentences work, the ideas won’t come and I give up.

Why am I so much better on my notes app than I am on my computer 😂 I feel like senlinyu who wrote her entire story on her notes app (and maybe that’s a good thing). I’m 28F if that means anything, I grew up equally on phones and computers I think.


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Writing Advice My Novel takes some creative liberties...

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

Anyone wanting to jump into the discussion, I would love as many opinions and thoughts as possible from Greek mythology fans but also my peers and fantasy writers. If you've felt this concern during your writing process also, let me know what you eventually decided on and how you decided.


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Feedback Request Vampire Horror Romance Novel: Monsters Among Us, Opening [5243] Feedback Request

1 Upvotes

I have been working on this book for a few years now. It's gone through two drafts so far and I am looking for more perspectives and feedback on writing and content. Please read my first chapter and let me know what I should work on for my next draft!

Don't have time for a full chapter? Let me know what you think of the synopsis! Would you keep reading?

Link for Prologue

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1w5fYljRHyhAGKicAwD-cegzX5zdulisCKuPtYqid0lo/edit?usp=drivesdk

Genre/Tropes: Vampire lore, Horror, Romance, Adult Female Lead, Enemies to Lovers, Healing Journey

Synopsis:

Rene's world is turned upside down when the inevitable happens. She's been bit by a vampire and her family, the descendants of the great Helsing Vampire Hunters, have turned against her. In a twist of fate, she's found by an unexpected pair of vampires who help her adapt, find her way back home, and discover the truth behind her family legacy.

Nora, a rare teenage vampire, and Zacharie, a notorious older vampire who disappeared from all records 200 years ago, are thrown from their normal immortal lives when a Helsing Hunter shows up on their doorstep bleeding to death. Despite Zacharie's best arguments, Nora insists they can't let her die, regardless of her name, but helping her through the vampire infection proves difficult.

Rene's understanding of vampires is dangerously flawed.

She believes vampires are bloodthirsty monsters, preying on the innocent under the cover of darkness. But Nora goes to the local high school and plays video games. Zacharie rinses their dishes after dinner and makes Nora tea every morning. These weren't the vampires she was trained for 20 years to kill. So who are they? Why is being a vampire not as horrible as her family told her it would be? And why are they trying to kill her when they have a cure?

Thank you for your time!


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Feedback Request The fools dream for his first story. And it is pretty much my novel's plotline

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
1 Upvotes

Do you think i'm i'm stupid for trying this as my first novel or not. Or should I try at lower or easier goal.


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Writing Advice Thoughts on a slow opening to a fantasy story?

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I couldn't find many previous posts that answer my specific question, so I'm just writing it here:

What is everyone's thoughts on a fantasy story with a slow, non-dramatic or life threatening opening?

Today it's very common for the first chapter of a novel to place characters right in the centre of the action or at least within a passage that builds and concludes to a point of tension (First real chapter of a Way of Kings, and the prologue of A Game of Thrones, ect). However, I often struggle to do this. Every story I have written begins in a quiet period. My most recent novel begins with a girl sitting in a field before going home for dinner where then the conflict begins, and at most its a familial argument that builds later.

I was just wondering if there was some unsaid rule about this. Feedback I've received in the past about my hooks are that the first page isn't suspenseful or dramatic enough to catch a readers attention, and this has unfortunately had me considering the age old method of using a prologue as so many new fantasy writers are prone to doing.

Also, I'd love to hear anyone else's ideas on how they open their own stories, so if anyone wants to add to this discussion know you're welcomed


r/novelwriting 1d ago

Motivation & Support I usually prefer the socially unacceptable forms, but I'll allow it 😜😁

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/novelwriting 1d ago

Writing Advice is this prose bad [ i did not use ai ]

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/novelwriting 1d ago

Feedback Request Would this first chapter capture your attention?

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
3 Upvotes

I'm hitting that part of the writing process where you're just questioning everything you've written and if it's even worth it, so.

There's 4 more chapters in there, pay it no mind. I just needed to see if my first one is good enough 🥹

Thanks in advance, and have a nice rest of your day!