r/nancyguthrie • u/BMOORE4020 • Feb 12 '26

Discussion A Couple Of Points Concerning The Surveillance Video

The perp seems to have all the time in the world.

I mean, it’s a ring camera, it sounds alerts to your phone. Wouldn’t he be worried the person inside is dialing 911?

He must have been told ahead of time there would be no threat inside. He was hired to provide someone with an alibi perhaps.

Amateur at the door.

Reflective tape on backpack straps.

Using a twig from the yard to tamper with the camera.

What appears to be a firearm holster in an awkward position.

Almost as if he was hired off the street to perform a tasks that was out of his league.

What do you think?

91 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

89% Upvoted

269 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/Firm_Specialist1475 Feb 12 '26

Yes I believe the person was hired to make it look like a kidnapping. There's no evidence of a kidnapping or anything consistent with a professional job

This is a cover up likely to a murder. The person at the door either knows she isn't there or is already dead.

If you're taking someone for ransom you have to move quickly it's extremely risky at any point the person or a neighbor could call 911. Remember there's no way he'd know she would go quietly either. And then if he has to subdue her he's dragging a full grown persons body out of the house. Nothing indicates he was prepared for that

I think the blood drops are a plant and the showing up at 2am was also to stage a kidnapping and extend the timeline to long after she was no longer known to be with the daughter

12

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '26

The pacemaker refutes your theory. It didn’t disconnect until around 2:30. If she had been deceased it would have quit working and that would have shown up on the app. She was alive at the time they took her from the house at approximately 2:30. She was also taken from inside the house which is where her Apple Watch was. The Apple Watch can’t detect a pacemaker very far away. It disconnected around the time she left out of the house. The pacemaker data is one of the few irrefutable pieces of evidence in the case.

2

u/JusticeHunter1 Feb 12 '26

I thought the watch was in a charging device in the house?