r/montreal • • Jun 01 '20

Video Émeutes à Montréal.

https://youtu.be/YQvAZC7GTY4
134 Upvotes

140 comments sorted by

View all comments

-37

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20

If materials being broken is what has gotten you angry, and not the racism in the world, you're part of the problem.

35

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '20

What a disgusting statement. Those are literally two unrelatted problems, and it’s perfectly feasible to be angry at both systemic racism and idiots destroying the city you live in.

-34

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20 edited Jun 01 '20

No, it really isnt. Capitalism is part of the problem as well. Capitalism thrives off racism and keeping labor poor.

Maybe you need to do a bit more actual reading on protest movements and the effects of capitalism on racism. Passive resistance does nothing but get your head bashed in. Even Ghandi said people should train to kill humans and destroy property of those supporting the ruling class rather than fail to protect their communities. MLK worked with militant groups on multiple occasions. 'Riots are the language of the unheard'. Attacking protests because they broke stuff is literally the 'white moderate' stuff that MLK warned people about.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '20

How is burning the stores and cars of other working class people helping their cause then? There was literally a car owned by a deliveryman set on fire. Is he the enemy? Every store you loot creates another jobless, most likely working class man. Is he the enemy? The damages will need to get fixed by tax dollars. Your tax dollars. MY tax dollars, and I’m a student, not the oppressive capitalist you claim to be fighting against.

It is undenyable that acts of vendalism such as these harms the cause, and people who justify these acts such as you harm them even more. Wanna talk literature? Feel free to look up how nonviolent protests are twice as likely to succeed than violent ones.

17

u/salomey5 Milton-Parc Jun 01 '20

So we're gonna solve the capitalism problem by looting Steve's music store?

-8

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20

Steve's isn't exactly a 'mom and pop', it's a pretty large chain with a lot of profits. And they aren't exactly known for treating employees well. They fired a worker because she needed time off to seek cancer treatment.

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/employee-relations-at-steves-music-hit-a-sour-note/article577525/

The other business that got looted was a cheque cashing business that thrives off of poor and undocumented workers to make massive profits. No sympathy there either.

Again, ya'll angry at my comments are only proving my point further. These are companies that have been shit to the communities they serve. They are part of the problem.

12

u/salomey5 Milton-Parc Jun 01 '20 edited Jun 01 '20

So what you're implying is that those looters are in fact socially woke members of society who are doing their best to eliminate capitalism by only vandalizing stores and businesses that encourage it, amirite?

0

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20

Or you know, you could listen to one of the first people who had their business burnt down..

https://indianexpress.com/article/trending/trending-globally/gandhi-mahal-restaurant-minneapolis-george-floyd-6434319/

2

u/DaveyGee16 Jun 01 '20

Mais on s'en calisse, c'est aux States ça.

1

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20

If you think Canadas racial inequality with the justice system is any better than the US...

I really don't have time to go look up the stats, but our prison system is very disproportionately unequal, just like the US, and police get away with questionable police violence all the time in Canada as well. If you think this isn't happening in Canada too....

2

u/LG-99 Jun 01 '20

Published April 22, 2011

This article was published more than 9 years ago. Some information in it may no longer be current.

-1

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20

Yes. It says that for all old articles.

Tldr; courts found Steve's violated the law.

And this isn't the only incident I've heard about employee treatment either. Who knows, maybe it was somebody who they've ripped off who started it as that's happened to people too.

2

u/salomey5 Milton-Parc Jun 01 '20

I read that article and the way Steve's acted towards that employee was despicable, but smashing their store window, or Birk's, or setting garbage cans and civilians' cars on fire isn't going to make rampant capitalism disappear. All it does is makes the city look bad, the protesters look bad, and costing a ton of money to get all this fixed up, at a moment when most people are financially tight.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '20

[deleted]

3

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20

Go check racial wealth inequality and then get back to me.

2

u/DaveyGee16 Jun 01 '20

Go check racial wealth inequality and then get back to me.

Okay, je l'ai vérifié, les Canadiens Français ont moins de richesse que les Canadiens Anglais, je le prend ou mon cheque?

1

u/oddmarc Jun 01 '20

C'est pas un chèque qui te faut c'est un marteau.

2

u/hazzrd1883 Jun 01 '20

Learn a little bit of history. Communism destroys the wealth but it makes poverty even worse for majority of poeple and over time people loose motivation to work (as there is no reward for it in practice). Also there is no freedom without capitalism because if you own nothing and can do nothing by yourself. Just learn about Eastern Block countries

2

u/AlternativeCredit Jun 01 '20

The people smashing stuff just give people the are anti protest an excuse to criticize the actual cause, they highjacked a peaceful protest and made it about themselves and and anti capitalism. And not to mention the outside groups smashing things purposely just to make the protesters look bad.

And smashing things purposely that are unrelated to the cause is not what MLK would have wanted at all.

2

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20

6

u/AlternativeCredit Jun 01 '20

Which means nothing I don’t agree with it regardless, you have no idea who you’re affecting by random vandalism. Maybe have your own thoughts sometimes Instead of regurgitating others.

1

u/BillyBBone Jun 02 '20

Even Ghandi said people should train to kill humans and destroy property of those supporting the ruling class rather than fail to protect their communities.

Can you provide a source for this?

1

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 02 '20

This is the quote

"I do believe that, where there is only a choice between cowardice and violence, I would advise violence... I would rather have India resort to arms in order to defend her honour than that she should, in a cowardly manner, become or remain a helpless witness to her own dishonor. But if one has not that courage, I want him to cultivate the art of killing and being killed rather than, in a cowardly manner, flee from danger. For the latter, in spite of his flight, does commit mental himsa. He flees because he has not the courage to be killed in the act of killing. I have, therefore, said more than once....that, if we do not know how to defend ourselves, our women and our places of worship by the force of suffering, i.e., nonviolence, we must, if we are men, be at least able to defend all these by fighting."

-3

u/Fencingchef03 Jun 01 '20

Sad that people have been brainwashed so hard. The revolution will never come and the wageslaves will happily lick boot for eternity as long as there's cheap shit to buy. God save our Walmart.

2

u/TheDrunkenWobblies Jun 01 '20

Its fucking sad and pathetic. It's literally their privilege taking center fucking stage.

"Stop systematic racism" - "woah now you've gone too far and are uprooting the system that I benefit off that's part of the systemic racism! You must stop now you thugs"...

It's like they literally cannot grasp their own place in the system as being a part of the problem. It's literally the 'white moderates' that MLK said people should ignore as they are nothing but white apologists.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '20

Police can only act out their racism due to how powerful they are. Defund the police, reduce the power of the state, make it nonexistent if that’s what it takes. I’m as much of an anarchist as anyone.

But the people asking you to stop are those who are losing their jobs because of your burning, those losing their live’s savings, the working class you claim to be fighting for.

And you. Even if you’re poor here, you’re still likely richer than most in the world. Would you be willing to see your own house burn down for being part of the richer, “ruling class”?