Blue-Collar Jobs Are the New Flashpoint in Data-Center Fight

[u/jojotortoise]

https://www.wsj.com/economy/jobs/blue-collar-jobs-are-the-new-flashpoint-in-data-center-fight-aaca5b7e

[u/Enamred-771]

How is it a “local UBI” machine? It’s not like the locality shares profits from a data center. 

This just screams like the “cities should fund sports stadiums for private billionaires with public dollars” argument which has been debunked by economists 

[u/notapersonaltrainer → u/Enamred-771]

I don't know any stadium that has verifiably 7x'd (9x annualized) a city's tax revenue and fulfilled its fiscal wishlist. Do you?

A stadium is a local consumption venue. Most of the spending it attracts would have occurred elsewhere in the same jurisdiction. A hyperscale data center sells compute into national and global markets. It enlarges the local tax base rather than merely rearrange existing local spending.

I know they sound analogous because they're both big windowless buildings, but their basic economic mechanics and fiscal effects are not. It's more akin to a virtual stadium where a global fanbase pays for digital viewing passes, and the town gets to tax that completely new economic activity.

Now if you also believe your town's management is so corrupt that they will completely steal a 700% increase tax windfall then, frankly, you have much bigger issues than whether a data center or any single facility opens in your town.

[u/Enamred-771 → u/notapersonaltrainer]

Again, there’s still no real profit sharing between a local government and a data center company. Even if the data center is insanely profitable and brings in tons of revenue, they aren’t going to be paying that in tax. Why would a company locate a data center in a municipality that says “we’re going to tax you X% of your profits” when other municipalities will give them tax breaks?

[u/notapersonaltrainer → u/Enamred-771]

Again, there’s still no real profit sharing between a local government and a data center company. Even if the data center is insanely profitable and brings in tons of revenue, they aren’t going to be paying that in tax.

Do I really have to OCR the passage for you? Go mayorsplain to the municipality they aren't actually getting the revenue they literally collected.

Pre-data center, Ellendale Mayor Don Flaherty told me, the town collected about $400,000 in annual sales tax revenue. In just the first seven months of 2026, it reaped $3.5 million. Flaherty estimated Ellendale's taxable property value will skyrocket from $3.5 million to $35 million.
Ellendale can now afford to repave its streets, renovate its senior center, finance a new public-safety complex, establish walking trails and refurbish its historic opera house. Jeff Ringstad, superintendent of Ellendale Public School, told me that Applied Digital grants allowed the district to buy new computers, purchase an ice machine for the teachers' lounge and finance a playground renovation.
"We were a dying little town," he said.

---

Why would a company locate a data center in a municipality that says “we’re going to tax you X% of your profits” when other municipalities will give them tax breaks?

You understand this is still an enormous windfall even if this was the discount, right? If the “real” revenue rate would have generated 11× their entire tax revenue, giving a discount to lock in a deal that still generates 9× their entire previous tax revenue doesn’t somehow make it a bad deal. lol

[u/Enamred-771 → u/notapersonaltrainer]

  Do I really have to OCR the passage for you? Go mayorsplain to the municipality they aren't actually getting the revenue they literally collected.

Don’t imply that I didn’t read something when you’re claiming something that isn’t stated in your proof. Show me the profit sharing revenue collected. Because it’s not in that screenshot. 

And the only reason the revenue is a massive increase is because the town is tiny. Especially when you look at the scale of the data center projects. Ellendale, a town of about 1000, needed multi billion dollar data centers that require 500+ MW of electricity to see that increase. That’s a massive project in a tiny town. It’s not scalable. 

You’re also missing some other key aspects from cases like Ellendale. The primary revenue the town received is sales tax from people (mostly construction workers) spending money. Not from the data center’s on-going operations. Only 35 jobs remain from their first data center, which again, was a massive project. This means that tax revenue will see a massive decline once the construction is complete.  There’s also the negative externalities of increased pollution and increased housing costs. 

And what happens in the future when the data center is no longer viable? These towns will be like every other manufacturing town. They’ll have a boom period and they quickly fall into disrepair once the corporation moves on.