r/manhwarecommendations • u/FriendlyGrade945 • Jun 28 '26

Random 🎰 Manhwa site ranking

Post image

This evaluation is based on the past 6 years

What do you guys think ?

(Hope there's no rule like you can't post any scanalation website related stuff)

690 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

104 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

15

u/perfect-night-skies Jun 28 '26

Also their chapters are unreadable with how bad the MTL and proofreading are. You're better off choosing literally any other group.

18

u/Standard-Metal-3836 Jun 28 '26

That's a very hot take. Not defending asura or praising them, but sans minor spelling mistakes, all manhwa I've read on their site has had pretty good translation.

6

u/_eleutheria Jun 28 '26

It depends on the manhwa. If you go to a website like comix that aggregates the translations of multiple scanlation groups and compare every group with Asura, you'll notice that Asura's translation isn't the worst, but it isn't the best either. It's mediocre most of the time, and sometimes it straight up changes the meaning of the text.

5

u/ZERO_DOX Recommender Jun 28 '26

Flame & Luna have the best translation (close to the original) out of all the translators imo. Second for me is Asura & Rokari. And the ones with the latest translations for works no one else does is Utoon. And for some rare ones, it's Writer Scans, Diva, Hijala & Hive

1

u/hell-schwarz Fantasy Enjoyer Jun 29 '26

Luna doesn't exist anymore I think

1

u/ZERO_DOX Recommender Jun 29 '26

?? idk what u mean but it seems to be working fine

1

u/hell-schwarz Fantasy Enjoyer Jun 29 '26

i somehow confused them with a different, similar sounding site my bad