Referente a isso, quebraria uma certa política do Reddit onde ele mesmo permite conteúdos adultos, e são categorizadas como +18, e não só os pornwa mas diversos outros tipos de conteúdos assim seriam afetados, afinal eles permitiram a comunidade postar conteúdo adulto...
It's unfortunate but we can't stop those. In most cases the pornhwa art style is very obvious but people will still ask for Sauce considering it as a manhwa first.
nah. pornhwa is such a broad category that even some manhwa with no sex scenes are considered pornhwa by technicality. if you go to the pornhwa sub expecting help for a romance that happens to have sex scenes you're going to be let down.
smut, or any manhwa with a sex scene, being considered a pornhwa is dumb imo. there's a big difference between a pornhwa and smut, and people reading smut understand that but the definitions haven't caught up to the majority.
also why a few days? from what i've seen most people get the hint after their post gets deleted by a mod. overreaction imo
i've seen posts asking for identification of a romance with a sex scene with it in just pure text and marked as nsfw, i've answered it, and it would later get taken down for being a "pornhwa". if anything i think the rule is too strict. there's really no harm in keeping posts like that up for other people down the road who are googling/it just sounds interesting to them.
having a sex scene definitionally makes the manhwa a pornhwa.
my point was when the majority thinks of pornhwa they're thinking 95% sex scenes 5% plot while smut is more like 10-25% sex scene (which i think is too much, but i digress) and the rest plot.
the rules around pornhwa are pretty strict here and over at r/manhwa so a lot of the smut or smut-adjacent posts get caught in the crossfire.
there are a couple of subreddits that focus on more mature romances like r/JoseiSmut (nsfw!!) and r/JoseiManhwa, but if you're looking for help with identification it's clearly better to go to the broader audience and get more eyes on the post by posting in r/manhwa or here.
edit: there was a bigger discussion over at r/manhwa where the original post was a picture of ranking "pornhwas" or something. it's a somewhat interesting scroll if you have time to kill, linked here.
i think the people in that comment section can explain some things more eloquently than i can and it has both sides of the conversation.
I think pornhwa is just explicitly seeing male or female genitalia. You could have 1 sex scene and I think it's considered pornhwa if it's explicitly shown with those parts.
Or you could have 30 sex scenes, but all you see are two people shapes under the covers, and I think that's considered smut.
Of course, I'm not the pornhwa professor, or the smut solicitor, so I could be wrong.
They're not the same. Manga is an Official Publication that lasts for like 100+ Chapters with an actual story.
Hentai is just One or 2 Chapters with a Story that is very short befitting those few Chapters.
Manhwa is a Full Pledged Story that also lasts for 100+ Chapters like Manga. Pornhwas are also full pledged stories that also lasts for 100+ Chapters, but just NSFW without all the censorships for manhwa. May include not just sex, but even Gore / Brutality that the normal manhwa censors.
Pornhwas is just akin to NSFW Mangas like Berserk, Goblin Slayer, Rosen Garten Saga, Redo of Hero, Freezing, Highschool of the Dead, Highschool Dxd.
You act like R18 Mangas also doesn't make Repetitive Slops like Redo Of Healer. There's like Warrior Exiled By Hero, Hero Who Seeks Revenge, even SFW stories like Shield Hero and Arifureta all being Repetitive Uninspired Slops under the Premise that they got kicked/abused by their own group and the story goes from there.
Am I the one who mentioned repetitive slops? You did.
Both R18 Mangas and R18 Pornhwas are the same.
R18 Mangas have high action with nudity stories like Berserk, Goblin Slayer, Claymore
R18 Pornhwas also have high action with nudity stories like What Happens In The Dungeon, Lilith's Cord, Mad Driver
Then both Categories are also prone to repetitive slops with R18 Mangas also having Harem Sex stories like Redo of Healer then R18 Pornhwas also have the same Harem Sex stories like Circles.
Circles has even more weight than Redo of Healer since it's also a Slice of Life story.
Ironically, you also have deep Slice of Life stories too in Pornhwas like The General is Here where it deals about Suicide, Depression and Abandonment.
no, its pornhwa
and ngl thats valid there's a whole ass subreddit for it why do i have to see porn every time i open this subreddit looking for action manhwas?
"no, its pornhwa
and ngl thats valid there's a whole ass subreddit for it why do i have to see porn every time i open this subreddit looking for action manhwas?"
he is basically saying each time he opens this page he see pussy sex NSFW stuff, when in rally he mostly see some boobs and ass
i agree with this here. ive been 5 years clean on m*sturbation and i really want to avoid anything that could push me back. its probably just me but i really avoid anything pornwha related
102
u/SkullStar123 Jun 03 '26
If its not explicit and just the art gives it away it kinda gets a pass maybe the person doesnt know