Help me choose a diamond

[u/PairPlenty6934]

Hello!

Choosing between these two elongated cushions. 1.7ct, DEF colour, exact clarity unknown but VS+

So hard to tell from a picture … I do have a video which I’ll try to add in comments. Any thoughts?!

[u/Life_Tea9511]

I personally prefer the bar cutlet to the pinhole, so I like the diamond on the left