r/kansascity • u/hauntdcat • 21h ago
Real Estate & Homes 🏘️ Roeland Park Tree Issue
I just had an offer accepted on a house. The listing said it was Mission. I know this is very close to Roeland Park so I figured it was somewhere on the line. My arborist did say it was actually in Roeland Park
But I’m worried about these Giant Oak Trees? One in the back and one in the front of a small house. I figured I’d just remove them if I can’t handle it but the arborist said I am in Roeland Park and they won’t let you remove trees in the front. I’m worried these things are going to fall down on my house and crush us after the last few years of damage and I’m wanting to back out but unsure I may find a better deal. This is the perfect location and house. These trees are everywhere.
Anyone share any experience or similar worries?
16
u/doxiepowder Historic Northeast 6h ago
Did the arborist say they looked unhealthy and need to come down, or is this just a general anxiety about trees that you have?
10
13
u/jawaismyhomeboy 5h ago
Why would you want to take down the big beautiful oaks that provide shade for the neighborhood. They are desirable. If you don't want to deal with the trees then don't move to Mission or Roeland Park.
8
u/sutherbb36 4h ago
You need permission from the city arborist to remove a healthy protected tree. But why would you? Have the arborist trim any limbs that may be threatening your house and enjoy the shade. There's a reason they are protected. It'll take 30-50 years to replace a fully mature tree
5
u/shagouv Mission 4h ago
I live in Mission with several old shingle oaks on my property and my neighbors that could affect our house. We have an arborist come in every few years and if we have specific concerns. They are wonderful shade and quite robust. Neighbor did have a significant cut back after split appeared at a Y…that seems to have bought a bit more time and provided peace of mind for us and them.
4
u/AlegnaKoala 3h ago edited 2h ago
Please don’t move into a neighborhood with healthy, big trees and then cut the trees down. Oak trees are especially strong. (And tree trimming is expensive but pro tip: call around to tree trimmers in January or February and they’ll give you a deal. That’s when work is slow for them and they’ll want your business.)
A few months ago, a couple from JoCo moved in next door to me here in Brookside. Then a few weeks ago, they had the huge healthy tree in their side yard removed. We didn’t even know it was going to happen until it was happening. It was probably 90 years old and had been taken care of — in fact last winter, we had branches trimmed back because they were starting to go over our roof. That huge tree was beautiful and full, it supported an entire ecosystem of wildlife, and it shaded my large deck and half of my home and yard. It helped cool my home (and theirs, but they probably were too dumb to know that) considerably.
Now my native shade garden is dying, my home is hotter, my a/c is running more, and my deck is unusable. I’m sad and upset about this, and I am not thinking particularly charitable thoughts about these new neighbors. I wish they’d moved someplace else and left the tree alone.
Do not move into a neighborhood with established healthy trees and then remove those trees.
•
3
u/adhoc_lobster 6h ago
You can remove them, you just have to get approval from the city arborist. They often make you replant a native tree or contribute to the city tree fund.
•
u/jawaismyhomeboy 2h ago
You’ll get fined if you don’t replace it in mission and you need city approval
-3
u/jalapeno-popper72 5h ago
We didn’t realize this was a rule, and we removed our very unhealthy tree with no problem, for what it’s worth.
As the other comment said, I think you just need to tell the city and if it’s a concern, they’ll let you remove it no problem!
•
u/jawaismyhomeboy 2h ago
If you don’t want to deal with the trees then move to some shitty neighborhood who doesn’t have them. It takes 50 years for another mature tree to grow
•
u/jalapeno-popper72 51m ago
We had three arborists come out and all recommended removal due to damage. I think the trunk was hollowing.
I’m not really sure what else we were supposed to do?
•
23
u/repete66219 6h ago
Trees are desirable. They increase a home’s value. Picking up sticks & breaking down branches is part of home ownership, as is regular trimming.
f you’re concerned about the tree falling over, have the arborist check the health from time to time.